Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Happens After You Lose a Car Accident Lawsuit in Michigan

The judgment becomes a debt you owe, and the other side can collect it through Michigan's court system

When a Michigan court rules against you in a car accident lawsuit, the judge issues a judgment — a legal order stating you owe the other party a specific amount of money. This judgment does not disappear if you ignore it. The other side can use it to collect through wage garnishment, bank account levies, property liens, or by asking the court to seize assets. You have limited time to appeal, and after that window closes, the judgment can follow you for years.

The amount you owe includes what the judge awarded for the other person's medical bills, vehicle damage, lost wages, and pain and suffering — but not attorney fees, since Michigan is a "no fee-shifting" state. If the judgment includes interest, that amount grows over time. Understanding what happens next, and what options you have to respond, matters more than the judgment itself.

Key Takeaways

  • A judgment in Michigan is enforceable for 10 years from the date it is entered, and the other side can renew it for another 10 years before it expires.
  • The other party can collect through wage garnishment (up to 25% of your disposable income), bank levies, property liens, or by asking the court to seize non-exempt assets.
  • You have 21 days from the judgment date to file a motion for a new trial, and 30 days to file a notice of appeal — missing these important date closes those doors permanently.
  • Certain assets are protected from collection in Michigan, including your primary home (up to a limit), vehicles, and retirement accounts, though the other side can still place a lien on your home.
  • If you cannot pay, you may be able to work out a payment plan with the other party or ask the court to modify the judgment, but ignoring it will make collection easier and faster.

How Michigan enforces judgments and collects money

Once the judgment is final, the other party becomes a judgment creditor and you become the judgment debtor. They do not have to wait for you to pay voluntarily. Michigan law gives them several tools to collect.

Wage garnishment is the most common method. The creditor files a garnishment order with your employer, and your employer must withhold up to 25% of your disposable income (gross pay minus taxes and mandatory deductions) and send it to the court. This continues until the judgment is paid off. Your employer must comply, and you cannot be fired for a single garnishment, though multiple garnishments can create workplace complications.

Bank levies freeze money in your checking or savings accounts. The creditor identifies your bank, the court issues a levy, and the bank holds funds up to the judgment amount. You have a short window (usually 10 days) to claim exemptions before the money goes to the creditor. Property liens attach the judgment to real estate you own. This does not force a sale when ready, but it clouds your title and must be paid off if you ever sell or refinance. The creditor can also ask the court to seize non-exempt personal property — vehicles, equipment, or other assets — though this is less common in car accident cases.

What assets are protected from collection in Michigan

Michigan law shields certain property from judgment collection, but the protections are limited and do not cover everything you own.

Your primary residence is protected up to $3,500 in equity (this amount can change, so verify the current limit). This means if you own a home worth $200,000 with a $150,000 mortgage, your $50,000 equity is above the exemption, and a creditor can place a lien on the home. The lien does not force a sale, but it must be paid when you sell or refinance.

One vehicle is protected up to $3,500 in equity, and certain tools or equipment used in your trade are exempt. Retirement accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s) are generally protected, as are life insurance proceeds and some disability benefits. However, bank accounts, investment accounts, and other liquid assets are not exempt — a levy can reach them when ready.

The creditor cannot touch wages that are already garnished for child support or other court orders, but they can still pursue other collection methods. If you are unsure whether a specific asset is protected, you can file a claim of exemption with the court, and a judge will decide.

Your options to appeal or challenge the judgment

You have a narrow window to challenge the judgment before it becomes final and enforceable. Missing these important date means you lose the right to appeal.

A motion for a new trial must be filed within 21 days of the judgment. This asks the judge to reconsider the case based on errors in the trial, newly discovered evidence, or procedural problems. This motion is rarely granted, but it preserves your right to appeal if the judge denies it. You must have a specific legal reason — not straightforward disagreement with the outcome.

A notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days of the judgment (or within 30 days of the judge's ruling on your motion for a new trial, if you filed one). This sends the case to the Michigan Court of Appeals, where three judges review whether the trial judge made legal errors. An appeal does not retry the facts; it examines whether the law was applied correctly. Appeals are expensive, take 12 to 18 months, and succeed only if the trial record shows clear legal error. Many people cannot afford to appeal, and many appeals fail.

If you miss both important date, the judgment is final. You cannot appeal after 30 days have passed, and the creditor can begin collection when ready.

Negotiating a payment plan or settlement with the creditor

You do not have to wait for the creditor to pursue collection. You can contact them directly and propose a payment plan or settlement.

A payment plan lets you pay the judgment in installments over time. The creditor is not required to agree, but many will negotiate rather than pursue costly collection methods. Put any agreement in writing and keep copies. If you miss payments, the creditor can resume collection efforts, so only agree to amounts you can actually pay.

A settlement means paying less than the full judgment amount in exchange for the creditor agreeing to dismiss the judgment. Again, the creditor has no obligation to settle, but they may prefer a may provide partial payment to the uncertainty of collection. If you reach a settlement, get a written agreement and a satisfaction of judgment — a court document stating the judgment has been paid and is no longer enforceable.

If you cannot pay anything now, explain your situation honestly. Some creditors will agree to pause collection efforts if you are experiencing genuine hardship, though this is not may provide. Ignoring the judgment and hoping it goes away will not work — it will only make collection easier when the creditor decides to act.

How long a judgment remains enforceable and what happens if you ignore it

A Michigan judgment is enforceable for 10 years from the date it is entered. Before that period ends, the creditor can renew the judgment for another 10 years, and potentially renew it again. This means a judgment can follow you for decades if the creditor keeps renewing it.

If you ignore the judgment, the creditor will eventually collect through the methods described above — garnishment, levies, or liens. They do not need your permission or cooperation. The longer you wait, the more interest accrues (Michigan judgments earn 5% annual interest unless the contract specifies otherwise), and the larger the total debt becomes.

Ignoring a judgment also damages your credit report. The judgment appears as a public record and can lower your credit score significantly, making it harder to borrow money, rent housing, or get insurance. Some employers check credit reports, and a judgment may affect your job prospects.

If you are sued again by the same creditor or a debt buyer who purchased the judgment, you cannot use the same defenses you raised in the original trial. The judgment is final on those facts, and a second lawsuit will move faster.

When to consider talking to a lawyer after a judgment

After you lose a lawsuit, a lawyer can help you understand your specific options, but the decision to appeal, negotiate, or accept the judgment depends on your circumstances and what you can afford.

Talk to a lawyer if you believe the trial judge made a clear legal error — not just a decision you disagree with, but a mistake about how the law applies. A lawyer can review the trial record and tell you whether an appeal has any realistic chance of success. Appeals are expensive and slow, so you need honest information about whether it is worth pursuing.

A lawyer can also help you negotiate with the creditor or explore whether you have defenses to collection (for example, if the creditor is trying to collect from protected assets). Some lawyers offer payment plans or work on reduced fees for post-judgment matters, though this is less common than representation during the trial itself.

If you cannot afford a lawyer and your income is very low, you may be able to file a claim of exemption or ask the court to modify the judgment without representation. The court clerk can point you toward self-help resources, though they cannot give you legal information.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the creditor take my house if I have a judgment against me?

Not when ready. Michigan protects up to $3,500 in home equity from judgment liens. If your equity exceeds that amount, the creditor can place a lien on your home, but this does not force a sale. The lien must be paid when you sell or refinance. If you have very little equity, the lien may be worthless to the creditor because the sale proceeds would not cover it.

What if I cannot afford to pay the judgment?

Contact the creditor and explain your situation. Some will negotiate a payment plan or settlement. You can also ask the court to hold a debtor's examination, where you explain your income and assets to a judge, who may modify the judgment or set up a payment schedule. Ignoring the judgment will not make it go away, but it will make collection easier for the creditor.

How much time do I have to appeal the judgment?

You have 30 days from the date the judgment is entered to file a notice of appeal with the Michigan Court of Appeals. If you want to file a motion for a new trial first, you have 21 days to do that, and then 30 days from the judge's ruling on that motion to appeal. Missing these important date closes the appeal door permanently.

Will the judgment show up on my credit report?

Yes. A judgment is a public record and will appear on your credit report, typically lowering your credit score. It can remain on your report for seven years from the date it is entered, even if you pay it off before then. Paying the judgment does not remove it from your report, but it may improve your score over time.

Can the creditor garnish my wages if I am already struggling financially?

Yes. Michigan allows wage garnishment up to 25% of your disposable income. However, if you are receiving public benefits or your income is very low, you may be able to claim exemptions. File a claim of exemption with the court within 10 days of receiving the garnishment notice, and a judge will decide whether your wages are protected.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.