What Happens When the Other Driver Won't Respond to Your Lawsuit
When silence from the other party becomes a legal problem
If you have filed a lawsuit against the other driver and they have not responded within the important date set by the court, you have a procedural problem that needs to be addressed—but it is not the end of your case. The other driver's silence does not automatically mean you win. Instead, it means you must take specific steps to move forward, and the steps available to you depend on how much time has passed and what the court rules require in your state.
The other driver (called the defendant) has a legal obligation to respond to your lawsuit within a set number of days—usually 20 to 30 days, depending on your state and how they were served with the papers. If they do not respond by that important date, you can ask the court to enter a default judgment against them. A default judgment is a court order that says you win because the defendant failed to defend themselves. But getting there requires you to follow the court's exact procedures, and skipping steps can delay your case or get your request rejected.
Key Takeaways
- The defendant has a specific important date—usually 20 to 30 days from when they were served—to file a response with the court.
- If they miss that important date, you must file a motion for default judgment; the court will not enter one automatically.
- Before filing for default, confirm that the defendant was properly served and that the important date has actually passed.
- Even after a default judgment, you still must prove the amount of damages you are owed, either through documents or a hearing.
- The defendant can ask the court to set aside the default judgment if they have a reasonable excuse for missing the important date.
Confirming the important date has actually passed
Before you file anything with the court, verify two things: that the defendant was properly served with the lawsuit papers, and that the response important date has truly expired. Proper service means the defendant received the papers in a way the law recognizes—usually by a process server, certified mail, or in some cases by publication in a newspaper if they cannot be located. If service was improper, any default judgment you obtain can be thrown out later.
The response important date starts from the date the defendant was served, not the date you filed the lawsuit. If the defendant was served on January 15, and your state allows 30 days to respond, their important date is February 14. If they file a response on February 15, they have missed the important date. Check your court's local rules or your state's civil procedure code—some states give longer important date if the defendant lives out of state or was served by mail rather than in person.
Look at your case file or the court's online docket to see whether any response has been filed. If nothing appears by the important date date, you can proceed to the next step. If you are unsure whether the important date has passed, contact the court clerk's office—they can tell you the exact date the defendant was served and when their response is due.
Filing a motion for default judgment
To get a default judgment, you must file a written request with the court called a motion for default judgment or motion for entry of default (the exact name varies by state). This is not something that happens automatically. You must ask for it, and you must follow your state's rules about how to ask.
Your motion should include the case number, the defendant's name, the date they were served, the important date they missed, and a statement that no response has been filed. Attach a copy of the proof of service—the document showing the defendant was served—and any other papers the court requires. Some courts want you to include a proposed default judgment form that the judge can sign if they grant your motion. Check your state's civil procedure rules or your local court's website for the exact format and what documents to include.
File the motion with the court clerk and serve a copy on the defendant (or their attorney if they have one) by mail or email, depending on what your court allows. Keep a copy of the proof that you served them. Some courts will grant a default judgment without a hearing; others require you to appear before a judge or submit additional evidence. Your court's website or the clerk's office can tell you which applies in your case.
Proving the amount of damages after default
A default judgment means the court has found that the defendant is liable—they are responsible for the accident. But it does not automatically tell you how much money they owe you. You still must prove your damages, which means showing the court what your medical bills were, what your car repair cost, what income you lost, and any other losses caused by the accident.
Some courts allow you to submit this proof in writing—through medical records, repair estimates, pay stubs, and a written statement explaining your losses. Other courts require you to appear at a hearing called a damages hearing or prove-up hearing, where you present your evidence to a judge and answer questions about your losses. The judge then decides what amount to award you. This is your chance to explain not just the bills you have, but also pain and suffering or other non-monetary losses, if your state allows you to claim them.
Bring or submit all documents that support what you are claiming: medical records and bills, repair invoices, photos of vehicle damage, pay stubs showing lost wages, and receipts for any out-of-pocket expenses. If you have medical records from treatment after the accident, those are especially important because they show the court that your injuries were real and caused by the crash. Organize these documents clearly and be ready to explain them to the judge.
The defendant can challenge the default judgment
Even after the court enters a default judgment against the defendant, they can file a motion to set it aside or vacate it. This is called a motion to vacate default or motion to set aside default judgment. The defendant does not have to prove they have a strong case on the merits; they only have to show the court that they have a reasonable excuse for missing the important date and that they want to defend themselves.
Common excuses include that they did not receive the papers, that they were out of the country, that their attorney made a mistake, or that they were dealing with a serious illness or family emergency. The court has discretion—meaning the judge can decide whether the excuse is good enough. Courts generally favor letting cases be decided on the merits rather than on procedural defaults, so judges often grant these motions if the defendant's reason sounds legitimate and they file the motion quickly after learning about the default.
If the defendant files a motion to vacate and the court grants it, you are back where you started: the defendant gets to file a response and defend the case. This is why it is important to have strong evidence of your damages ready before you even file for default. If the default is set aside, you may end up in settlement negotiations or going to trial, and you will need to prove your case all over again.
Settlement negotiations after default
A default judgment does not mean the case is over. Even after the court enters judgment, the defendant can appeal, and they can also negotiate a settlement with you. Many defendants or their insurance companies will contact you after a default judgment to discuss paying a portion of what the court awarded, rather than paying the full amount or going through an appeal.
If the defendant's insurance company reaches out, listen to their offer but do not agree to anything without understanding what you are giving up. If you have already won a judgment, you have leverage. The defendant knows they can appeal and might lose, or they might win on appeal and you get nothing. A settlement that pays you most of what you are owed now is often better than waiting months for an appeal to be decided.
Any settlement agreement should be in writing and should say that both sides are releasing each other from further claims related to the accident. Once you sign, you cannot sue them again for the same accident, so make sure the amount covers all your losses. If you are unsure whether an offer is fair, consider consulting with an attorney before you accept it.
Collecting the judgment if the defendant does not pay
Winning a judgment is not the same as getting paid. If the defendant does not pay the amount the court ordered, you will need to take additional steps to collect. This process is called judgment enforcement or execution, and it varies by state.
Common collection methods include garnishing the defendant's wages (taking money directly from their paycheck), placing a lien on their property (a legal claim that must be paid before they can sell), or seizing their bank accounts. To use these tools, you typically file additional paperwork with the court and may need to locate the defendant's employer or bank. Some states allow you to do this yourself; others require you to hire a collection agency or attorney.
Start by sending the defendant a written demand for payment, with a important date. If they do not pay, ask the court clerk what collection tools are available in your state and what forms you need to file. If the defendant has no income or assets you can reach, collecting may be difficult or impossible, but the judgment remains valid for a set number of years (usually 10 to 20, depending on your state), so you can try again later if their situation changes.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to wait before filing for default?
You must wait until the defendant's response important date has passed. That important date is usually 20 to 30 days from the date they were served, but check your state's civil procedure rules or ask the court clerk for the exact number. Filing too early will get your motion rejected.
What if the defendant says they never received the papers?
If the defendant claims they were not properly served, the court may set aside any default judgment and require you to serve them again. This is why proof of service is critical—keep the document showing how and when the defendant was served. If service was improper, you will need to have them served again before proceeding.
Can I get a default judgment if the defendant's insurance company responds but the defendant does not?
No. If the insurance company files a response on behalf of the defendant, the defendant has responded, and you cannot get a default judgment. You will have to continue with the case through settlement or trial. The insurance company's response counts as the defendant's response.
Do I need an attorney to file for default judgment?
You do not need an attorney, but the process requires following your court's specific rules about format, filing, and service. If you make a mistake, your motion can be rejected and you will have to start over. Many courts have self-help centers or websites that explain the process for your state.
What happens if I win a default judgment but the defendant appeals?
The defendant can appeal the default judgment, and the appeals court will review whether the default was proper. If the appeals court finds that the defendant had a good reason for missing the important date or that the court made an error, it can set aside the judgment and send the case back to trial. This is why collecting payment quickly, if possible, is important.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.