Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Respond to a Summons in a Personal Injury Lawsuit

What a summons means and what you must do

A summons is a court document that notifies you that someone has filed a lawsuit against you and tells you the important date to respond. It is not a demand for money — it is a notice that a case has been started. You have a specific number of days (usually 20 to 30, depending on your state and how you were served) to file a written response with the court, or you will lose the case by default even if the claim against you is false.

The summons will arrive with a complaint, which is the document that describes what the plaintiff (the person suing) says you did wrong and what they are asking for in damages. Together, these two documents mean you must act — ignoring them is the single most costly mistake you can make in a personal injury case.

Your response is called an answer in most states. An answer admits or denies each claim in the complaint and can raise legal defenses. You do not have to prove anything in your answer — you are straightforward telling the court and the other side what you dispute and what you do not.

Key Takeaways

  • You must file a response with the court by the important date on the summons, or the case will be decided against you without a hearing.
  • Your response (called an answer) denies or admits each claim and can raise legal defenses, but does not require you to prove anything yet.
  • You should contact a lawyer before filing, because missing the important date or filing the wrong document can cost you the case permanently.
  • The important date is usually 20 to 30 days from the date you were served, and it does not change if you ignore the summons or ask for more time without court permission.
  • Filing an answer does not settle the case — it starts the discovery process, where both sides exchange documents and information.

Understanding the important date and what happens if you miss it

The summons will state the exact date by which you must respond. This important date is not a suggestion and does not extend automatically. If you do not file a response by that date, the court will enter a default judgment against you, meaning the judge decides the case in the plaintiff's favor without hearing your side. Once a default judgment is entered, it is extremely difficult to undo, even if you have a strong defense.

The important date runs from the date you were actually served with the summons, not from the date you received it in the mail or found it on your door. If you are unsure when you were served, look at the proof of service document that came with the summons — it shows the date and method of service. Count forward from that date, not from today.

If you believe you were served incorrectly (for example, the document was left with someone who does not live at your address and you never saw it), you can file a motion to quash service, but you must do this before or with your answer. This is a technical argument that requires careful filing, which is why consulting a lawyer before the important date is important.

What to include in your written response

Your answer must respond to each claim in the complaint. For each claim, you will either admit it, deny it, or state that you do not have enough information to admit or deny it. You are not required to explain your reasoning — a straightforward "Defendant denies" is sufficient. However, if you admit something, that admission can be used against you later, so read the complaint carefully.

Your answer should also include affirmative defenses, which are legal reasons why the plaintiff should lose even if everything they said is true. Common affirmative defenses in personal injury cases include comparative fault (the plaintiff was partly responsible for their own injury), assumption of risk (the plaintiff knew the danger and accepted it), or that the statute of limitations has expired. Your state's rules will list which defenses are available.

The answer must be filed with the court and served on the plaintiff's lawyer (or the plaintiff if they do not have a lawyer). "Served" means you must send them a copy by mail, email, or hand delivery, depending on what the court rules allow. You must also file a document called a certificate of service that proves you sent them a copy.

When you should hire a lawyer before responding

You can file an answer yourself, but doing so without understanding the rules can hurt your case permanently. A lawyer can review the complaint, identify which claims are legally weak, spot defenses you might not know about, and file the answer correctly. The cost of a consultation before the important date is usually far less than the cost of losing by default or admitting something you should have denied.

Many personal injury lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of any settlement or judgment you receive and charge nothing upfront. However, if you are the defendant (the person being sued), the other side's lawyer is usually working on contingency, not yours. You may need to pay a lawyer hourly or a flat fee to defend yourself, though some lawyers will take a case on contingency if they believe you have a counterclaim (a claim against the plaintiff).

If you cannot afford a lawyer and the case involves a small amount of money, you might represent yourself, but understand that you are responsible for following all court rules. Courts do not give you extra time or forgive mistakes just because you are not a lawyer.

What happens after you file your answer

Once you file your answer, the case enters the discovery phase. This is when both sides exchange documents, answer written questions (called interrogatories), and sit for interviews under oath (called depositions). Discovery can last months and is often where cases are won or lost, because it is where the strength of each side's evidence becomes clear.

Filing an answer does not mean the case will go to trial. Most personal injury cases settle during or after discovery, once both sides understand what evidence exists. Your answer straightforward preserves your right to defend yourself and keeps the case alive while settlement negotiations happen.

If the case does not settle, your answer and the evidence from discovery will be used at trial. The judge or jury will decide whether the plaintiff proved their case and, if so, how much you owe.

Common mistakes to avoid when responding

The most common mistake is missing the important date. Do not assume you have more time than the summons states, and do not wait to hear from the other side. Mark the important date on your calendar when ready and work backward to give yourself time to consult a lawyer.

The second mistake is admitting too much. Every admission in your answer can be used against you in discovery and at trial. If you are unsure whether something is true, state that you do not have enough information to admit or deny it — this is a valid response.

The third mistake is filing the wrong document or filing in the wrong court. Some courts require your answer to be in a specific format, and some require it to be filed electronically. Check your court's website or call the clerk's office to learn the local rules before you file.

How to find the court rules for your state and county

Each state has its own civil procedure rules that govern how you must file your answer. These rules are usually called the Rules of Civil Procedure or Code of Civil Procedure and are available free on your state court's website. Your county or district court may also have local rules that add to the state rules.

The summons should tell you which court the case is filed in. Go to that court's website and look for a section on filing documents or local rules. Many courts now require electronic filing through a system called e-filing, and the court website will explain how to set up an account and file your answer online.

If you cannot find the rules online, call the clerk's office for the court listed on the summons. The clerk can tell you the important date, the filing method, and what documents you need to include with your answer. The clerk cannot give you legal information, but they can tell you what the court requires.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if I do not think the summons is real?

A summons is real if it came from a court and has a case number, judge's name, and court address on it. If you are unsure, call the court's clerk's office and give them the case number — they can confirm whether a case has been filed. Do not ignore a summons because you think it might be fake; the cost of being wrong is too high.

Can I ask for more time to respond?

You can ask the court for an extension, but only if you file the request before the important date passes. This is called a motion for extension of time. Some courts grant these automatically if both sides agree; others require you to show good cause. Do not wait until the last day to ask — file the request at least a week before the important date.

Do I have to respond if I think the lawsuit is frivolous?

Yes. Even if you believe the claim is baseless, you must file an answer by the important date. You can raise defenses in your answer that argue the claim has no legal basis, but you cannot skip responding. If you want to argue the case should be dismissed, you can file a motion to dismiss along with or instead of an answer, but this must also be filed by the important date.

What if I was served but I did not open the envelope?

The important date still runs from the date you were served, not from the date you opened the envelope. If you find an old summons, check the proof of service to see when it was delivered, then count forward. If the important date has passed, contact a lawyer when ready — you may be able to file a motion to set aside the default judgment, but this must be done quickly.

Can I settle the case before I file an answer?

Yes, but you should still file an answer by the important date unless you have a written agreement with the other side that says you do not have to. Even if settlement talks are happening, filing protects you in case the talks fall through. Once you have a signed settlement agreement, you can ask the court to dismiss the case.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.