Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Sedgwick Actually Pays for Pain and Suffering in Workers' Comp Claims

Sedgwick doesn't set the pain and suffering payment—your state's workers' compensation law does

Sedgwick is a claims administrator, not the insurer or the decision-maker on what you receive. When Sedgwick handles your workers' compensation claim, they process payments according to the rules written into your state's workers' comp statute. Pain and suffering—called non-economic damages in legal terms—is treated very differently in workers' comp than it is in a personal injury lawsuit.

Most states do not allow pain and suffering payments in workers' compensation at all. Instead, workers' comp provides wage replacement (a portion of lost income), medical benefits (treatment costs), and permanent disability awards (a lump sum or structured payment if your injury causes lasting impairment). Sedgwick pays what the law requires—nothing more, nothing less. The amount depends entirely on which state you were injured in and how that state defines permanent disability.

If you believe your claim should include pain and suffering, the issue is not with Sedgwick's payment formula. The issue is whether your state's law permits it, and whether your injury meets the threshold to receive it. Sedgwick follows the law; they do not interpret it in your favor or negotiate it upward.

Key Takeaways

  • Workers' compensation in most states does not pay for pain and suffering; it pays wage replacement, medical costs, and permanent disability awards based on state law.
  • Sedgwick administers the claim according to your state's statute, so the payment amount is determined by law, not by Sedgwick's discretion.
  • Permanent disability awards vary widely by state—some use a body part schedule (a fixed amount per type of injury), others use an impairment rating, and a few use a wage-loss formula.
  • If your state does allow pain and suffering in workers' comp, it is usually only available if you can prove the employer was negligent or violated a safety statute—a much higher bar than a standard claim.
  • Reviewing your state's workers' comp statute or speaking with a workers' comp attorney in your state is the only way to know what you are may have access to to receive.

How states define what Sedgwick will pay for permanent injury

Every state has its own formula for permanent disability awards. Sedgwick's job is to calculate and pay according to that formula. The three most common approaches are:

Schedule awards assign a fixed dollar amount or number of weeks of pay to each body part. For example, loss of a finger might be worth 50 weeks of your average weekly wage; loss of an arm might be worth 312 weeks. The injury itself determines the payout—not pain, not suffering, not how much it affects your life. You lose the finger, you get the amount the law says a finger is worth in your state.

Impairment ratings

Wage-loss formulas

When pain and suffering might be available in workers' comp

A small number of states allow workers to recover pain and suffering in workers' compensation, but only under specific conditions. These are rare exceptions, and Sedgwick will only pay them if the law in your state permits it and your claim meets the threshold.

The most common scenario is when you can prove the employer or a co-worker acted with gross negligence or intentional misconduct—not ordinary carelessness, but reckless disregard for safety. For example, if your employer knowingly removed a safety guard from machinery and you were injured as a result, you might have grounds for a claim beyond workers' comp. Some states also allow pain and suffering if the employer violated a specific safety statute.

Even when these conditions exist, you typically cannot recover pain and suffering through Sedgwick's workers' comp claim. Instead, you would file a separate lawsuit against your employer or the responsible party. That lawsuit is outside the workers' compensation system entirely. Sedgwick handles the workers' comp claim; your attorney handles the personal injury or negligence claim.

What Sedgwick actually needs to calculate your permanent disability award

To determine what Sedgwick will pay, the claims administrator needs three pieces of information: your average weekly wage before injury, the medical impairment rating or body part involved, and your state's statutory formula.

Your average weekly wage is usually calculated from your pay stubs in the 52 weeks before injury, or from a shorter period if you have not worked that long. Sedgwick will request this from your employer's payroll records. The higher your wage, the higher your award (in most states).

The medical impairment rating or body part classification comes from your treating physician or from an independent medical examination. Sedgwick may request additional medical records or a second opinion if the initial rating seems inconsistent with your medical history. Once the rating is established, Sedgwick plugs it into the state formula and calculates the award.

If you disagree with the rating or believe Sedgwick has miscalculated the award, you can request a recalculation or file a dispute with your state's workers' compensation board. Sedgwick does not have the authority to override the formula or award more than the law allows.

Why Sedgwick's payment is lower than you might expect

Workers' compensation awards are often smaller than people expect because the system trades the right to sue for may provide benefits. You do not have to prove fault; you do not have to go to court; you receive benefits quickly. In exchange, you receive only what the statute provides—not what a jury might award in a personal injury case.

A personal injury lawsuit for pain and suffering can result in much larger awards because a jury can consider emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and future suffering. Workers' compensation does not. It is a no-fault system designed for speed and certainty, not for full compensation of all losses.

Sedgwick's role is to administer this trade-off fairly and according to law. If you believe the award is too low, the problem is not Sedgwick's calculation—it is that workers' compensation law in your state does not cover pain and suffering. Your only recourse is to explore whether you have a separate claim outside the workers' comp system, which requires speaking with an attorney licensed in your state.

Requesting a recalculation or disputing Sedgwick's award

If you receive a permanent disability award from Sedgwick and believe it is incorrect, you have the right to request a recalculation. Start by asking Sedgwick in writing to explain how they calculated the award—which wage figure they used, which medical rating they applied, and which state formula they followed.

If you find an error (for example, Sedgwick used the wrong wage period or applied an outdated impairment rating), request a corrected calculation. Sedgwick must respond in writing and explain their reasoning. Keep copies of all correspondence.

If Sedgwick refuses to recalculate or you still disagree after recalculation, you can file a dispute with your state's workers' compensation board or agency. The process and timeline vary by state, but most states allow you to request a hearing before an administrative judge. You do not need an attorney, though many people find one helpful. The judge will review the medical evidence, the wage records, and the state statute, then issue a decision on what you are owed.

Understanding the difference between workers' comp and a personal injury claim

The confusion about pain and suffering often comes from mixing workers' compensation with personal injury law. They are two separate systems with different rules, different payouts, and different timelines.

In workers' compensation, you receive benefits regardless of who was at fault. Your employer does not have to be negligent; you do not have to prove anything except that you were injured at work. Sedgwick processes the claim and pays according to the statute. Pain and suffering is not part of this system in most states.

In a personal injury lawsuit, you must prove the other party was negligent or acted wrongfully. If you win, you can recover pain and suffering, lost wages, medical costs, and other damages. However, you cannot sue your employer for a work injury in most states—that is why workers' compensation exists. The exception is if your employer acted with gross negligence or intentional misconduct, or if a third party (not your employer) caused the injury.

If you were injured at work and believe someone other than your employer was responsible—a equipment manufacturer, a contractor, a property owner—you may have a personal injury claim separate from workers' comp. That claim could include pain and suffering. Sedgwick handles the workers' comp side; your attorney handles the personal injury side.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue my employer for pain and suffering if I was injured at work?

In most states, no. Workers' compensation is the exclusive remedy for work injuries, meaning you cannot sue your employer. However, if your employer acted with gross negligence or intentional misconduct—such as knowingly exposing you to a hazard—some states allow you to step outside workers' comp and file a lawsuit. You need an attorney in your state to determine if this applies to you.

Does Sedgwick have the power to increase my award if I can show I suffered a lot?

No. Sedgwick calculates awards according to your state's statutory formula. They cannot increase an award based on your pain or suffering because the law does not allow it. If you believe the award is wrong, the issue is the calculation itself—the wage figure, the medical rating, or the formula—not the level of pain you experienced.

What if I disagree with the impairment rating the doctor gave me?

You can request a second medical opinion. If the second opinion differs significantly from the first, Sedgwick may order an independent medical examination by a neutral physician. You can also dispute the rating through your state's workers' compensation board. The board will review the medical evidence and decide whether the rating is accurate.

Is there any way to get more money than what Sedgwick calculated?

Only if you have a claim outside workers' compensation—for example, against a third party like a manufacturer or contractor, or against your employer if they acted with gross negligence. Those claims are separate from your workers' comp case and would be handled by a personal injury attorney, not by Sedgwick.

Why does my friend's award seem so much higher than mine for a similar injury?

The award depends on your average weekly wage, your state's formula, and the specific medical rating for your injury. Two people with the same injury type can receive very different awards if they earned different wages or live in different states. Ask Sedgwick to break down your calculation so you can see exactly how they arrived at the amount.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.