Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What To Ask For In Your Personal Injury Settlement

What a settlement should cover

A personal injury settlement should compensate you for two distinct categories of loss: economic damages (the money you actually spent or lost) and non-economic damages (the harm that doesn't have a receipt). Most people focus on medical bills and miss the rest, which is why insurers count on you to ask for less than you're may have access to to.

Economic damages are straightforward to document. They include all medical treatment related to the injury—emergency room visits, surgery, physical therapy, prescription medications, and ongoing care. They also include lost wages from time you missed work, transportation costs to medical appointments, and any home modifications or equipment you needed because of the injury. Keep every receipt, bill, and pay stub showing lost income.

Non-economic damages compensate for pain, suffering, lost enjoyment of life, and emotional distress. These have no invoice, so their value depends on the severity of your injury, how long recovery takes, and whether the injury is permanent. A broken arm that heals in six weeks has a different non-economic value than a spinal injury that causes chronic pain for years.

Key Takeaways

  • Your settlement should cover all medical expenses related to the injury, including future treatment you'll need, not just bills you've already received.
  • Include lost wages for time you missed work during recovery, plus any reduction in earning capacity if the injury affects your ability to work long-term.
  • Non-economic damages—pain, suffering, and lost quality of life—typically make up 50 to 75 percent of a personal injury settlement, not the medical bills alone.
  • Ask for a breakdown of what the settlement covers so you understand which portion is taxable income and which is not.
  • Request that future medical expenses be paid through a structured settlement or set-aside fund rather than a lump sum, so the money lasts as long as you need treatment.

Medical expenses: past and future

The settlement must cover all medical bills you've already paid, but it should also account for treatment you'll need in the future. If your doctor says you'll need physical therapy for another six months, or if you have a permanent condition requiring ongoing medication or monitoring, those costs belong in the settlement amount.

Gather documentation from your healthcare providers: itemized bills, medical records showing the diagnosis and treatment plan, and any letters from your doctor describing future care needs. The insurance company will use this to calculate a reasonable estimate of future medical costs. If you underestimate, you'll be stuck paying the difference yourself.

Some settlements include a structured settlement for medical expenses, meaning the insurance company funds a separate account that pays out over time rather than giving you one lump sum. This protects the money from being spent on other things and can offer tax advantages. Ask whether this option is available.

Lost income and earning capacity

You're may have access to to compensation for wages you lost while recovering—the paychecks you didn't receive because you couldn't work. Provide your employer with a letter stating the dates you were absent and your hourly rate or salary. If you're self-employed, bring tax returns and business records showing your average income during the period you were unable to work.

Beyond lost wages, ask about lost earning capacity if the injury affects your ability to earn in the future. If you were a carpenter and the injury left you unable to do heavy lifting, your earning capacity has changed. If you can no longer work full-time or must take a lower-paying job, that loss is part of your settlement. This requires documentation from your doctor about your physical limitations and, ideally, a vocational informed's assessment of how those limitations affect your job prospects.

Include any benefits you lost—health insurance, retirement contributions, bonuses—that were tied to your employment during the recovery period.

Pain, suffering, and quality of life

Non-economic damages are harder to quantify because they're not tied to a bill, but they're often the largest part of a settlement. Courts and insurers use different methods to estimate these damages. One common approach is the multiplier method: taking your total economic damages and multiplying by a number (usually 1.5 to 5, depending on severity) to arrive at a non-economic value.

A minor injury with quick recovery might use a multiplier of 1.5. A severe injury with permanent effects might use 4 or 5. The more serious the injury, the longer the recovery, and the more it disrupts your daily life, the higher the multiplier. Document how the injury affected you: pain levels, inability to sleep, inability to exercise or pursue hobbies, emotional distress, and impact on relationships.

Keep a journal during recovery noting your pain, limitations, and how the injury changed your daily life. This becomes evidence when negotiating non-economic damages. Statements from family members, friends, or your employer about changes they observed can also support a higher valuation.

Permanent injury and disfigurement

If the injury is permanent—scarring, loss of limb, chronic pain, or reduced mobility that won't improve—the settlement should reflect that permanence. Permanent injuries command higher non-economic damages because you'll live with the effects for the rest of your life.

Get written confirmation from your doctor that the condition is permanent and describe what that means for your daily functioning. If the injury causes visible scarring or disfigurement, document it with photographs. If it limits your ability to work, exercise, or participate in activities you enjoyed, describe those losses specifically.

Permanent injuries may also justify a higher structured settlement or a larger set-aside for ongoing medical care, since you'll need treatment indefinitely.

How to negotiate the settlement amount

The insurance company will make an initial offer, usually lower than what you should receive. Your response should include a detailed breakdown of what you're asking for and why. Create a document listing each category: medical bills (with copies), lost wages (with pay stubs), future medical costs (with doctor's letter), and non-economic damages (with your calculation and supporting evidence).

If you have an attorney, they'll handle this negotiation. If you're representing yourself, send your demand in writing and keep copies. Be specific: "Medical expenses: $8,400 (itemized bills attached). Lost wages: $3,200 (pay stubs attached). Future physical therapy: $2,000 (doctor's letter attached). Non-economic damages: $45,000 (based on severity and duration of injury)."

The insurer will counter. Expect back-and-forth. If you're far apart, mediation—a neutral third party helping both sides reach agreement—is often faster and cheaper than litigation. Ask whether mediation is available before you reject an offer.

Tax treatment of your settlement

Not all settlement money is taxable income. Money for medical expenses and lost wages is generally not taxable. Money for pain and suffering is also not taxable in most cases. However, if part of the settlement is for lost interest or investment income, that portion may be taxable.

Ask the insurance company or your attorney for a written breakdown showing which portion of the settlement is for medical expenses, which is for lost wages, and which is for non-economic damages. This matters when you file taxes. Keep this document with your tax records.

If the settlement includes a structured settlement with payments over time, the structure itself has tax implications—ask a tax professional or your attorney to explain how it affects your tax liability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I ask for more than I think I'll get?

Yes. The insurance company expects you to negotiate. Start with a number higher than your bottom line, knowing you'll likely settle somewhere in the middle. However, your initial demand should be defensible—backed by documentation and reasonable calculations. An inflated number with no support weakens your position.

What if I don't have all my medical bills yet?

Request an estimate from your healthcare providers of what future treatment will cost, and include that in your settlement. You can also ask for a structured settlement that covers future medical expenses, so you're not guessing at the total. Get your doctor to write a letter describing the treatment plan and expected duration.

Can I include pain and suffering if the injury was minor?

Yes, but the amount will be smaller. Even minor injuries cause pain and disruption. However, if you were back to normal within a few days, a claim for months of suffering won't be credible. Be honest about the severity and duration of your symptoms.

What happens if I accept a settlement and then need more medical care?

Once you sign a settlement agreement, you typically can't go back and ask for more money, even if new problems arise from the injury. This is why it's critical to account for future medical needs before you settle. If you're unsure whether your recovery is complete, ask for a delayed settlement or a structured arrangement that covers care for a set period.

Do I need an attorney to negotiate a settlement?

You don't legally need one, but an attorney can often recover more than you'd get on your own—enough to cover their fee and leave you ahead. Many personal injury attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of the settlement rather than charging upfront. If the settlement is small, self-negotiation may make sense; if it's substantial, an attorney's involvement usually pays for itself.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.