Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Greg Kelley's Settlement Tells You About Wrongful Conviction Cases

Greg Kelley's settlement and what it means for wrongful conviction payouts

Greg Kelley was a high school football player in Texas who spent nearly two years in prison for a crime he did not commit. In 2020, after his conviction was overturned, he reached a settlement with Williamson County for $750,000. This is one of the larger wrongful conviction settlements on record, but it is not the largest, and the amount reflects specific facts about his case — the length of time imprisoned, the strength of evidence of innocence, and the county's willingness to settle rather than fight.

Wrongful conviction settlements vary widely. Some people receive under $100,000; others receive several million. The amount depends on how long someone was imprisoned, what state they live in, whether they have a wrongful conviction law in place, and whether the case settles or goes to trial. Kelley's settlement is useful as a reference point, but it should not be treated as a standard or a floor.

Key Takeaways

  • Greg Kelley received $750,000 from Williamson County after spending 23 months in prison for a crime he did not commit.
  • Wrongful conviction payouts depend on state law, length of imprisonment, and whether the case settles or goes to court — there is no single formula.
  • Some states have no wrongful conviction law at all, meaning people must sue and prove damages in civil court, which is slower and less certain.
  • The strongest cases for settlement involve clear evidence of innocence, exonerating DNA evidence, or prosecutorial misconduct that a county wants to avoid litigating.

How wrongful conviction settlements are calculated

There is no standard formula. Some states have wrongful conviction statutes that set a per-year amount — for example, $50,000 per year of imprisonment, or $80,000, or some other figure. Other states have no statute at all, which means a person must file a civil lawsuit and prove their damages to a jury or judge. In those cases, the settlement or award depends on what a jury thinks the case is worth.

Kelley's settlement of $750,000 for 23 months works out to roughly $39,000 per month. That is higher than some state statutes but lower than others. Texas does not have a wrongful conviction statute, so his settlement was negotiated between his lawyers and the county. The county likely settled to avoid the cost and publicity of a trial.

Factors that push settlements higher include DNA evidence that proves innocence, evidence that police or prosecutors withheld evidence or lied, a long time in prison, and a case that has received media attention. Factors that push settlements lower include cases where the evidence of innocence is less clear-cut, shorter prison terms, or cases where the person was convicted based on eyewitness testimony rather than forensic evidence.

State-by-state wrongful conviction laws

About 35 states have some form of wrongful conviction statute. These laws typically set a per-year payment, sometimes with a cap on the total amount. A few examples:

  • California: $140 per year of imprisonment, with a cap of $600,000 total.
  • Illinois: $200 per day of imprisonment, with a minimum of $400,000 for anyone imprisoned for 14 years or more.
  • New York: $50,000 per year of imprisonment, with a cap of $1 million.
  • Florida: $50,000 per year of imprisonment.

States without a wrongful conviction statute include Texas, where Kelley's case was handled. In those states, a person must file a civil lawsuit against the government agency or individual officials responsible. This is slower, more expensive, and the outcome is less certain — a jury might award nothing, or it might award far more than a statutory amount.

Some states also offer other forms of compensation beyond money, such as job training, tuition waivers, or mental health services. A few states have exoneration funds that are separate from the civil courts and designed to move faster.

What made Kelley's case settle

Kelley was convicted in 2014 of sexual assault of a child. The case rested largely on the testimony of the child and circumstantial evidence. In 2017, another man confessed to the crime, and DNA evidence linked him to the victim. Kelley was exonerated in 2020. The Innocence Project and his legal team pursued the case aggressively, and the evidence of his innocence was clear.

Williamson County settled rather than appeal or defend the conviction because the facts were against them. Once DNA evidence pointed to someone else and that person confessed, the county had no realistic path to trial. Settling also allowed the county to avoid further litigation costs and media scrutiny.

Cases that settle tend to have one or more of these features: DNA evidence that excludes the convicted person, a confession by someone else, evidence that police or prosecutors withheld evidence, or a case that has drawn public attention. Cases that go to trial often involve disputes over whether the evidence of innocence is strong enough, or whether the government bears responsibility for the wrongful conviction.

How wrongful conviction cases move through the system

The path to settlement or payout usually starts with exoneration — overturning the conviction in court. This can happen through a motion for a new trial, an appeal, or a post-conviction relief petition. Once the conviction is overturned, the person can then pursue compensation.

In states with a wrongful conviction statute, the person files a claim with the state or the relevant agency. The process is usually faster than a civil lawsuit, though it still takes months. In states without a statute, the person files a civil lawsuit against the county, the police department, or individual officers. This can take years.

Many cases settle before trial. The government agency and the person's lawyers negotiate a figure, and both sides agree to end the case. Settlement is faster and cheaper than trial, and it avoids the risk of a jury awarding nothing or awarding far more than either side expected.

Why settlement amounts vary so widely

Two people who spent the same amount of time in prison can receive very different settlements. The difference usually comes down to the strength of the evidence of innocence and the state's wrongful conviction law.

Someone exonerated by DNA evidence in a state with a generous wrongful conviction statute may receive $200,000 or more per year of imprisonment. Someone exonerated in a state with no statute, or with a low per-year amount, may receive far less — or may have to go to trial and risk getting nothing.

The age of the case also matters. Older cases, especially those from before DNA testing was available, may have weaker evidence of innocence and may be harder to settle. Newer cases often have better documentation and clearer evidence.

Media attention and public pressure can also affect settlement amounts. Cases that have been covered by major news outlets or investigated by journalists are sometimes settled for more, because the government wants to avoid further publicity.

What happens after a settlement is reached

Once a settlement is agreed, the person receives the money, usually in a lump sum, though some settlements are structured as annuities or paid over time. The settlement agreement typically includes a clause that prevents the person from suing again for the same wrongful conviction.

The money is taxable as income in most cases, though some states exempt wrongful conviction settlements from state income tax. Federal tax treatment varies, and a person should consult a tax professional before assuming the entire settlement is tax-free.

Beyond the financial settlement, some people pursue other forms of justice: expungement of their criminal record, a formal apology from the state, or changes to police or prosecutorial practices. These are sometimes negotiated as part of the settlement agreement, and sometimes pursued separately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is $750,000 a typical wrongful conviction settlement?

No. Settlements range from under $100,000 to several million dollars. Kelley's settlement is on the higher end, partly because the evidence of his innocence was very strong and partly because Texas has no wrongful conviction statute, so the county had to negotiate rather than follow a set formula.

What if someone was wrongfully convicted in a state with no wrongful conviction law?

They must file a civil lawsuit against the government agency or officials responsible. This is slower and more uncertain than claiming under a state statute, because the person must prove damages and convince a judge or jury that the government is liable. Many of these cases settle, but some go to trial.

Does a wrongful conviction settlement include money for lost wages?

It depends on the state law and the settlement agreement. Some state statutes include only a per-year amount for imprisonment. Others allow the person to sue for additional damages, such as lost wages, emotional distress, or damage to reputation. This is usually negotiated in the settlement.

How long does it take to receive a wrongful conviction settlement?

In states with a wrongful conviction statute, the process can take several months to a year after exoneration. In states without a statute, a civil lawsuit can take two to five years or more, depending on whether it settles or goes to trial. Kelley's case took about three years from exoneration to settlement.

Can someone be denied a wrongful conviction settlement?

In states with a wrongful conviction statute, the person is usually may have access to to the payment once their conviction is overturned. In states without a statute, a civil lawsuit can be dismissed or lost, meaning the person receives nothing. Some settlements also include conditions, such as a requirement not to speak publicly about the case.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.