When You Can Turn Down a Personal Injury Settlement and What Happens Next
Yes, you can reject a settlement offer, but the decision has real consequences
You have the legal right to refuse any settlement offer, no matter how far along the case is. Your lawyer cannot force you to accept, and neither can the other party. But rejecting an offer means the case continues, which costs more money, takes more time, and carries the risk that a jury awards you less than what was offered — or nothing at all.
The choice is yours to make, but it should rest on whether you believe a jury is likely to award you more than the offer, minus what you will spend on legal fees and court costs to get there. That calculation changes depending on how strong your case is, how much uncertainty remains, and how much longer the case will take.
Key Takeaways
- You can reject a settlement at any stage, including after your lawyer recommends accepting it, but your lawyer must tell you the risks of refusing.
- Rejecting an offer means the case goes to trial or arbitration, which costs more in legal fees and takes months or years longer.
- If you reject an offer and a jury awards you less, you still owe your lawyer's fees and court costs from that smaller amount.
- The decision should turn on whether you believe a jury will award more than the offer minus your remaining legal costs, not on emotion or principle alone.
- Your lawyer can advise you on the strength of your case and the likelihood of a better outcome, but cannot override your choice to reject.
What happens to your case when you say no
Once you reject an offer, the case moves into the next phase. If you are still in discovery — the period when both sides exchange documents and take depositions — that process continues. If discovery is complete, the case heads toward trial or arbitration, depending on what your contract or court order requires.
The other party may make another offer later, usually a higher one as trial approaches and their own costs and risk increase. But they are not required to. They may decide to take the case to trial and let a jury decide, betting that they will win or that the jury will award less than they offered.
Throughout this time, your lawyer continues to bill you for work — depositions, motions, trial preparation, informed witnesses, and the trial itself. These costs add up quickly. A case that settles before trial might cost $5,000 to $15,000 in legal fees depending on complexity and your fee arrangement. A case that goes to trial can cost $25,000 to $100,000 or more, again depending on the case.
The math of rejecting an offer
Before you reject, do the math. If the offer is $50,000 and you believe a jury might award $75,000, that sounds like a reason to reject. But if your lawyer estimates another $30,000 in legal fees and costs to reach trial, and there is a real chance the jury awards $60,000 instead, you end up with $30,000 after fees — less than the offer.
Your lawyer should walk you through this calculation. They should tell you:
- What they estimate the case is worth based on similar cases and the strength of your evidence
- What they estimate it will cost in legal fees and court costs to reach trial
- What they estimate the odds are of winning at trial and what range a jury might award
- Whether the offer is above, below, or in line with what similar cases settle for
If your lawyer thinks the offer is fair or better than fair, they will usually recommend accepting. That recommendation is worth taking seriously — they have seen many cases and know what juries typically do. But the choice remains yours.
When rejecting makes sense
Rejecting an offer is reasonable when the evidence strongly favors you and the offer is clearly low. This might happen early in a case, before the other party has seen all your evidence, or when they are trying to settle cheaply to avoid a larger judgment.
It also makes sense if you have a strong case on liability — meaning it is clear the other party was at fault — but the damages are still being calculated. In that situation, rejecting an early offer and pushing for a higher one as trial approaches is a common strategy.
Rejecting also makes sense if you have the financial ability to wait. If you do not need the money when ready and can afford to pay your lawyer as the case continues, you have more flexibility to hold out for a better offer or take the case to trial.
When rejecting is risky
Rejecting becomes risky when liability is unclear — when a jury might find the other party was not at fault, or only partly at fault. In those cases, an offer of anything is better than the risk of nothing. A jury might award zero.
It is also risky when your damages are hard to prove. If your injuries are soft-tissue injuries like whiplash, or if your lost wages or medical bills are disputed, a jury might award far less than you expect. The other party knows this and may have offered based on a realistic view of what a jury will do.
Rejecting is risky if you need the money soon. The longer a case takes, the more financial pressure you face. If you reject an offer and the case takes another two years to trial, you may end up accepting a lower offer later just to end it, or you may be forced to settle for less because you ran out of money.
Your lawyer's role in the decision
Your lawyer must tell you about any offer and explain what it means. They must also tell you the risks and benefits of accepting or rejecting. But they cannot tell you that you must accept, even if they think you should.
If you and your lawyer disagree strongly — you want to reject and they think it is a mistake — you have options. You can ask them to explain their reasoning in detail and ask questions until you understand. You can ask for a second opinion from another lawyer. Or you can fire your lawyer and hire someone who agrees with you, though that costs time and money.
If your lawyer thinks rejecting the offer is so unreasonable that they cannot ethically represent you further, they can withdraw from the case. This is rare, but it can happen. If it does, you will need to find a new lawyer quickly.
What happens if you reject and lose at trial
If you reject an offer, go to trial, and the jury awards you less than the offer, you still owe your lawyer's fees and court costs. Those come out of the jury award. If the jury awards $30,000 and your lawyer's fees and costs total $40,000, you may owe your lawyer money out of pocket, depending on your fee agreement.
Some lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you win — usually 33% to 40% — and you pay nothing upfront. If you lose, you owe nothing. If you win less than the offer, your lawyer still takes their percentage, which can leave you with very little.
Other lawyers charge by the hour, and you pay them regardless of the outcome. If you reject an offer and lose, you owe the full hourly bill.
Before you reject, make sure you understand your fee agreement and what you will owe if the case does not go the way you hoped.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my lawyer refuse to represent me if I reject a settlement they recommend?
Your lawyer can withdraw from your case if they believe continuing would violate ethics rules, but this is uncommon. More often, they will explain their concerns and let you decide. If you and your lawyer cannot agree on strategy, you can hire a different lawyer, though this costs time and money.
What if the other party makes a lower offer after I reject the first one?
This can happen, especially if new evidence hurts their case. But they may also make no new offer and take the case to trial instead. Do not assume they will keep negotiating. Once you reject, be prepared for the case to move forward toward trial.
Can I accept a settlement offer after I have already rejected one?
Yes, if the other party is willing to negotiate again. But they are not required to make another offer, and if they do, it may be lower than the one you rejected. Rejecting signals that you are willing to go to trial, which changes the negotiation.
How long does a case take after I reject a settlement?
It depends on the court's schedule and how much work remains. If discovery is complete, trial might happen in three to twelve months. If discovery is still ongoing, it could take a year or more. Your lawyer can estimate based on your specific case and local court delays.
What if I cannot afford to keep paying my lawyer while the case continues?
Talk to your lawyer about your financial situation. If you are on contingency, you owe nothing unless you win. If you pay hourly, ask whether they will work on contingency instead, or whether they can reduce their hourly rate. Some lawyers will adjust their arrangement if you are struggling financially.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.