What Interrogatories Are and Why a Defendant's Lawyer Sends Them to You
What interrogatories are and why defendants send them in personal injury cases
Interrogatories are written questions that the defendant's lawyer sends to you during a personal injury lawsuit. You must answer them under oath, meaning you swear the answers are truthful. The defendant uses these questions to learn the details of your claim before trial — what happened, how you were injured, what medical treatment you received, and how the injury has affected your life.
The defendant has a legal right to ask these questions as part of discovery, the phase of a lawsuit where both sides exchange information. Interrogatories are one of several discovery tools; others include requests for documents and depositions (in-person questioning). Interrogatories are usually the first written questions you receive, often arriving within weeks of the lawsuit being filed.
You cannot ignore interrogatories. Your lawyer must respond within the important date set by the court — typically 30 days in most states, though this can be extended if both sides agree or if a judge grants more time. Failing to respond can result in penalties, including sanctions from the judge or a default judgment against you, meaning you lose the case without a trial.
Key Takeaways
- Interrogatories are written questions from the defendant's lawyer that you must answer under oath within a court-ordered important date, usually 30 days.
- Your lawyer prepares the answers with you; you do not respond directly to the defendant, and your lawyer can object to questions that are improper or too broad.
- Common interrogatory topics include how the accident happened, your medical history, treatment details, lost wages, and how the injury changed your daily life.
- Answers become part of the court record and can be used against you at trial if they contradict your testimony or other evidence.
- Objections to interrogatories must be made in writing and must state a legal reason; straightforward refusing to answer without an objection can result in court sanctions.
The types of questions defendants typically ask in interrogatories
Interrogatories in personal injury cases follow predictable patterns. The defendant's lawyer wants to pin down your version of events, test the strength of your claim, and find weaknesses or inconsistencies they can use later.
Common interrogatory topics include: how the accident occurred (your account of what happened, where you were, what you were doing); the defendant's role (what you saw the defendant do or fail to do); your injuries (what hurt when ready after the accident, what symptoms you experienced); your medical history (prior injuries, surgeries, or conditions that might have contributed to your current injury); all medical treatment (doctors visited, hospitals, therapists, dates, and diagnoses); medications and prescriptions; lost income (how much time you missed work, your hourly rate or salary); and impact on daily life (activities you can no longer do, pain levels, emotional effects).
The defendant may also ask about prior lawsuits or claims you have filed, insurance coverage you carry, whether you have discussed the case with witnesses, and what damages you are seeking. These questions are designed to build a complete picture of your claim and to find anything that might reduce what a jury awards you.
How your lawyer responds to interrogatories on your behalf
You do not write the answers yourself or send them directly to the defendant. Your lawyer prepares the responses with you. The process usually begins with your lawyer sending you a copy of the interrogatories and asking you to provide detailed information about each question. You meet with your lawyer (in person, by phone, or by email) to discuss your answers.
Your lawyer then drafts formal written responses in the format required by your state's civil procedure rules. Each interrogatory receives a numbered response. Your lawyer may object to a question instead of answering it — for example, if the question is too vague, asks for information protected by attorney-client privilege, or seeks information that is not relevant to the case. Objections must state the legal reason; a blanket refusal to answer without an objection is not valid and can result in sanctions.
Once the responses are complete, you review them with your lawyer. You then sign a declaration or affidavit swearing that your answers are true and correct to the best of your knowledge. Your lawyer files the signed responses with the court and serves a copy on the defendant's lawyer by the important date. Missing the important date can result in waiving your right to object and being ordered to answer anyway, or facing other court penalties.
What happens if you object to an interrogatory
Not every interrogatory must be answered. Your lawyer can object on specific legal grounds. Common objections include: the question is vague or ambiguous; it asks for information protected by attorney-client privilege (confidential communications between you and your lawyer); it seeks information that is not relevant to the case; it is overly broad or burdensome; or it asks you to disclose a trade secret or confidential business information.
An objection must be stated in writing as part of your formal response. For example, instead of answering "Interrogatory 5: Describe all conversations you had with your doctor," your lawyer might write: "Objection: This interrogatory seeks information protected by the attorney-client privilege and the doctor-patient privilege. To the extent not privileged, Plaintiff responds as follows..." and then provide what can be disclosed.
If the defendant disagrees with an objection, they can file a motion to compel — a request to the judge to force you to answer. The judge then decides whether the objection is valid. If the judge agrees with the defendant, you must answer. If the judge agrees with you, the question is dropped. Objections must be made in good faith; using them to delay or avoid legitimate questions can result in sanctions.
How interrogatory answers are used in your case
Your interrogatory answers become part of the official court record. The defendant's lawyer will use them to prepare for trial, to depose you (question you in person), and to challenge your testimony if you say something different at trial. If your answer to an interrogatory contradicts what you say on the witness stand, the defendant will point out the inconsistency to the jury, which can damage your credibility.
Interrogatory answers can also be used to support a motion for summary judgment — a request by the defendant to dismiss the case before trial on the grounds that there is no genuine dispute about the facts. If your answers show that you cannot prove a key element of your claim, the defendant may use that to argue the case should be dismissed.
Because of this, accuracy and consistency are critical. Do not exaggerate your injuries or damages in your answers, and do not minimize them either. Stick to what you actually know and experienced. If you do not remember something, say so rather than guessing. Your lawyer will help you phrase answers that are truthful, complete, and protect your interests.
Common mistakes to avoid when answering interrogatories
One frequent mistake is providing vague or evasive answers. The defendant's lawyer will use vague answers as a reason to ask follow-up questions or to argue that you are hiding something. Answer each question directly and completely. If a question has multiple parts, address each part separately.
Another mistake is volunteering information that was not asked for. Interrogatories are narrow questions; answer what is asked, not what you think the defendant should know. Extra information can create new lines of questioning or give the defendant ammunition.
Do not answer for someone else or include information you do not personally know. If an interrogatory asks what you did or experienced, answer only from your own knowledge. If you do not know something, say "I do not know" or "I do not recall" rather than speculating.
Avoid changing your story between interrogatory answers, deposition testimony, and trial testimony. Write down your answers and review them before your deposition and before trial. Inconsistencies will be used against you. If you genuinely remember something differently later, tell your lawyer when ready so they can explain the change.
Timelines and important date for interrogatory responses
The defendant's lawyer will include a important date with the interrogatories, usually 30 days from the date they are served. Some states allow 35 or 45 days; check your state's civil procedure rules or ask your lawyer. This important date is firm unless the court extends it or both sides agree in writing to more time.
Your lawyer should begin working on responses as soon as interrogatories arrive. Do not wait until the last week. Gathering information — medical records, pay stubs, dates of treatment — takes time. If you need more time, your lawyer can request an extension from the defendant's lawyer before the important date passes. Most lawyers will grant a reasonable extension if asked in advance.
If the important date passes without a response, the defendant can file a motion to compel, and the judge may order you to answer and may impose sanctions, including attorney fees. In some cases, failure to respond can result in a default judgment, meaning you lose the case automatically.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse to answer an interrogatory because I think it is unfair?
No. You must answer interrogatories unless your lawyer files a valid legal objection. Thinking a question is unfair is not a legal reason to refuse. Valid objections include that the question is vague, seeks privileged information, or is not relevant to the case. Your lawyer will advise you on which objections explore.
What if I do not remember the answer to an interrogatory?
Say so. Write "I do not recall" or "I do not have sufficient information to answer this interrogatory." Do not guess or make up an answer. If you later remember the information, tell your lawyer so they can file a supplemental response before trial.
Can the defendant use my interrogatory answers against me at trial?
Yes. If your interrogatory answer contradicts your testimony at trial, the defendant will point out the inconsistency to the jury. This is why accuracy and consistency matter. Review your answers with your lawyer before trial so you are prepared to explain any differences if they come up.
Do I have to disclose information about my prior medical conditions in interrogatories?
Generally yes, if the question asks about your medical history or prior injuries. The defendant is may have access to to know about conditions that might be relevant to your current injury claim. However, your lawyer can object if the question is too broad or seeks information that is not relevant to the case.
What if I lie in my interrogatory answers?
Lying under oath in interrogatory responses is perjury, a serious crime. It can also result in your case being dismissed, sanctions against you and your lawyer, and referral to law enforcement. Always answer truthfully, and if you are unsure about something, discuss it with your lawyer before the response is filed.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.