How to Defend Yourself in a Personal Injury Lawsuit
What happens when you're sued for personal injury
When someone sues you for personal injury, you will receive a document called a complaint that explains what they claim you did, how it harmed them, and what money they want. You then have a set number of days—usually 20 to 30 depending on your state—to file a written response called an answer. If you do not respond by that important date, the court can enter a default judgment against you, meaning you lose without ever presenting your side.
The lawsuit will then move through a process called discovery, where both sides exchange documents, answer written questions, and sit for recorded interviews called depositions. Most personal injury cases settle during or after discovery, but some go to trial. Your job in defending yourself is to show either that you were not responsible for the harm, that the harm was not as serious as claimed, or that the other person was partly at fault.
You do not have to represent yourself. Many people hire a personal injury defense attorney, and some insurance policies cover the cost. If you cannot afford one and the case involves a significant amount of money, a lawyer may take the case on contingency—meaning they get paid only if you win or settle favorably.
Key Takeaways
- You must file a written answer to the complaint within 20 to 30 days or risk losing by default, so mark the important date on your calendar when ready.
- Your defense might rest on showing you were not responsible, the injury was less severe than claimed, or the other person was partly at fault—each requires different evidence.
- Discovery will require you to turn over documents, answer written questions, and likely sit for a deposition where the other side's lawyer asks you questions under oath.
- Insurance often covers your defense costs and any settlement or judgment, so contact your homeowner's, auto, or business insurance company as soon as you are served.
- A defense attorney can negotiate a settlement, file motions to dismiss weak claims, and represent you at trial, and many work on a fee arrangement your insurance will pay.
Notify your insurance company when ready
If the injury happened on your property, in your vehicle, or during your business, your homeowner's, auto, or commercial liability insurance likely covers both your legal defense and any judgment or settlement. Most policies require you to notify the insurer within a specific window—sometimes as short as 30 days—so contact them the moment you receive the lawsuit or even if you receive a demand letter before being sued.
When you notify your insurer, provide them with every document you have: the complaint, any letters from the other side's lawyer, photos of the scene, medical records if you have them, and a written account of what happened. The insurance company will assign you a defense attorney at no cost to you, and that attorney works for you, not the insurance company, even though the company is paying the bill.
If you do not have insurance or the injury falls outside your policy's coverage, you will need to hire your own attorney or represent yourself. Many personal injury defense attorneys charge hourly rates ranging widely by location and experience, so get fee agreements in writing before you hire.
File your answer before the important date
Your answer is a formal document that responds to each claim in the complaint. You can deny the allegations, admit them, or say you do not have enough information to admit or deny. You can also raise affirmative defenses—legal reasons why you should not be held responsible even if the facts in the complaint are true. Common affirmative defenses include comparative negligence (the other person was partly at fault), assumption of risk (they knew the danger and accepted it), and statute of limitations (the lawsuit was filed too late).
If you miss the important date to file your answer, the other side can ask the court for a default judgment. Once entered, a default judgment is hard to overturn. If you realize you are about to miss the important date, file something—even a straightforward letter to the court explaining why you need more time—rather than file nothing.
Your attorney or the court's website will have the local rules for how to format and file your answer. Many courts now accept electronic filing, and some require it. If you are representing yourself, the court clerk can tell you the rules but cannot give you legal information on what to say in your answer.
Gather and preserve evidence
Start collecting evidence when ready: photos of the scene, medical records, repair estimates, witness contact information, and any written communications with the other side. If the injury happened on your property, take photos showing the condition before and after. If it was a vehicle accident, get the police report number. If it was a workplace injury, get the incident report.
Do not destroy or alter anything related to the incident, even if it looks bad for you. Destroying evidence is illegal and will hurt you far more than the evidence itself. If you have electronic communications—texts, emails, social media posts—about the incident, preserve them. During discovery, the other side will ask for these anyway, and if you have deleted them, the court may assume they were damaging and hold that against you.
Be careful what you say going forward. Do not post about the incident on social media, do not discuss it with anyone except your attorney, and do not apologize or admit fault to the other person. Anything you say can be used against you in court. Your attorney will advise you on what you can safely discuss.
Understand the discovery process
Discovery is the phase where both sides exchange information. The other side will send you interrogatories (written questions you must answer under oath), requests for production (demands for documents), and requests for admission (statements they ask you to admit or deny). You will have 30 days to respond, and your attorney will help you do so accurately and without volunteering extra information.
You will also likely sit for a deposition, where the other side's attorney asks you questions while a court reporter records your answers. You can bring your attorney to the deposition. Answer only what is asked, do not guess or speculate, and if you do not understand a question, say so. If your attorney objects to a question, you can refuse to answer it.
Discovery can be expensive and time-consuming, but it is also where most cases settle. Once both sides understand the strength of the other's evidence, they often agree on a settlement rather than go to trial. Your attorney will advise you on whether a settlement offer is reasonable.
Evaluate settlement offers
At any point before trial, the other side may offer to settle—to end the case in exchange for a payment and a release of all claims. Settlement offers often come after discovery, when both sides have a clearer picture of the case. Your attorney will explain what the offer means, what you would owe in taxes or to your insurance company, and how it compares to the risk of going to trial.
Settling means you avoid the uncertainty and expense of trial, but it also means paying money and admitting nothing (most settlements include language saying you do not admit wrongdoing). Going to trial means a judge or jury decides, which could result in a verdict in your favor or a judgment against you for more than the settlement offer. Your attorney can help you weigh these options, but the decision is yours.
If your insurance company is paying your defense, they may have a say in whether to settle, depending on your policy. Read your policy or ask your attorney what control you have over settlement decisions.
Prepare for trial if settlement fails
If the case does not settle, it will go to trial. Before trial, your attorney will file motions—formal requests to the court—asking the judge to dismiss claims that are legally weak or to rule on disputed facts. Some cases are won or lost on motions before trial ever starts.
At trial, the other side will present evidence and witnesses to prove you were responsible and caused harm. Your attorney will cross-examine their witnesses and present your own evidence and witnesses to show you were not responsible, the harm was less severe, or they were partly at fault. You may testify, but you do not have to—your attorney will advise you on whether it helps or hurts your case.
Trial is formal and governed by rules of evidence. Your attorney knows these rules; if you represent yourself, the judge will expect you to follow them anyway. If you are representing yourself and the case is complex or involves significant money, strongly consider hiring an attorney for trial even if you handled earlier stages alone.
Know when to hire an attorney
You can represent yourself in a personal injury lawsuit, but it carries real risks. You might miss important date, file documents incorrectly, say something in a deposition that hurts your case, or fail to present evidence effectively at trial. If the other side has an attorney—which they usually do—you are at a disadvantage.
Hire an attorney if: the amount of money at stake is significant (more than a few thousand dollars), the facts are complicated, you have been injured seriously, the other side is represented by an attorney, or you straightforward do not understand the process. Many defense attorneys offer free initial consultations, so you can ask questions before committing.
If you cannot afford an attorney and your insurance is not paying, ask the court about fee waivers or reduced fees based on income. Some attorneys also work on contingency in defense cases, though this is less common than in plaintiff cases.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I ignore the lawsuit?
If you do not file an answer by the important date, the court will enter a default judgment against you. This means you lose without presenting your side, and the other side can collect the full amount they asked for. Default judgments are very hard to overturn, so ignoring a lawsuit is the worst thing you can do.
Can I be sued for more than the insurance policy limit?
Yes. If the judgment exceeds your policy limit, you may owe the difference out of pocket. This is called an underinsured situation. Your attorney can sometimes negotiate with the other side to accept the policy limit as full settlement, but there is no may provide. This is one reason to make sure your insurance limits are adequate.
Will I have to go to trial?
Most personal injury cases settle before trial—estimates range from 85 to 95 percent. But you should prepare for trial anyway, because the threat of trial is what motivates settlement. If the other side believes you will fight at trial, they are more likely to settle reasonably.
Can the other side see my social media posts?
Yes. During discovery, they can demand access to your social media accounts, and anything you posted is fair game. Even deleted posts can sometimes be recovered. Do not post about the incident, your injuries, or your activities during the lawsuit—anything you share can be used against you.
What does it mean if my insurance company hires my attorney?
Your attorney represents you, not the insurance company, even though the company is paying the bill. Your attorney's duty is to you. However, if a conflict arises—for example, if a settlement offer exceeds your policy limit—the insurance company's interests and yours may diverge, and you may need separate counsel.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.