How to Defend Against a Personal Injury Lawsuit
You've been served with a personal injury lawsuit—here's what happens next
Being sued for personal injury is different from being in an accident. The person suing you (the plaintiff) is claiming you caused their injury and owes them money. You now have specific legal obligations and a timeline to follow. Ignoring the lawsuit or missing important date will hurt your case far more than the injury itself might have. Your first move is to notify your insurance company when ready—most people's homeowners, auto, or business insurance includes a legal defense. If you don't have insurance that covers this, you need to find a personal injury defense attorney within days, not weeks.
The next steps are straightforward but time-sensitive: you'll receive formal paperwork, you'll respond within a important date set by your state, and you'll work with an attorney to investigate the plaintiff's claims and build your defense. Most cases settle before trial, but you need a strategy in place from the start. This guide walks you through what to expect and what you need to do at each stage.
Key Takeaways
- Notify your insurance company the moment you receive the lawsuit paperwork, because they typically pay for your defense and any settlement or judgment.
- You have a specific important date (usually 20 to 30 days depending on your state) to file a written response, and missing it means the plaintiff wins by default.
- Do not communicate directly with the person suing you or their attorney—all contact goes through your lawyer or insurance company's legal team.
- Your attorney will investigate the plaintiff's claims, gather evidence that supports your version of events, and identify weaknesses in their case.
- Most personal injury lawsuits settle before trial, but you need a defense strategy in place from the start, not when trial approaches.
Understanding the paperwork you've received
The document you received is called a complaint (or sometimes a petition, depending on your state). It describes what the plaintiff claims happened, what injury they say they suffered, and how much money they're asking for. Read it carefully, but do not assume every claim in it is accurate or will be proven in court. The complaint is the plaintiff's version of events, not a statement of fact.
Along with the complaint, you should have received a summons—a document that tells you how long you have to respond. This important date is typically 20 to 30 days from the date you were served, though it varies by state and by how you were served. Some states give you longer if the summons was mailed rather than handed to you in person. Check your state's civil procedure rules or ask an attorney when ready; this important date is absolute, and courts do not extend it for convenience.
You may also receive a demand letter if the lawsuit hasn't formally started yet. This is the plaintiff's attorney asking you to pay a specific amount to settle before filing in court. Do not respond to this letter yourself. Forward it to your insurance company or attorney when ready. Responding on your own can be used against you later, so let your legal team handle all written communication.
Notify your insurance company right away
Most homeowners, auto, and business insurance policies include a legal defense clause. This means your insurance company will hire an attorney to defend you and will pay any settlement or judgment up to your policy limit. The insurance company has a legal duty to defend you as soon as they know about the claim, so call them the same day you receive the lawsuit paperwork.
When you call, have the complaint and summons in front of you. Provide the insurance company with the plaintiff's name, the date you were served, and the case number (usually printed on the summons). Ask for the name and contact information of the defense attorney they assign to you. Do not agree to anything or make any statements about what happened—just report that you've been sued and provide the documents. Keep a record of who you spoke with, the date, and the time.
If you don't have insurance that covers personal injury claims, you need to hire your own defense attorney within a few days. Waiting longer means less time to prepare your defense and gather evidence while memories are fresh. Ask friends, family, or your local bar association for referrals to attorneys who handle personal injury defense in your area.
What your defense attorney will do in the first weeks
Your attorney's job is to defend you, not to determine whether you were actually at fault. They will review the complaint, investigate the plaintiff's claims, and develop a strategy. In the first few weeks, they typically file a written response (called an answer) by the important date, either admitting or denying each claim in the complaint. They will also gather evidence: medical records, photos, witness statements, police reports, and anything else that supports your version of events.
Your attorney will identify weaknesses in the plaintiff's case—inconsistencies in their story, lack of evidence, or legal problems with their claim. They will begin communicating with the plaintiff's attorney about settlement possibilities, though serious negotiations usually happen later in the case once both sides have more information. Your attorney will also ask you detailed questions about what happened. Answer honestly and completely. Anything you tell your attorney is protected by attorney-client privilege, meaning it cannot be shared with the other side without your permission. This protection is essential to your defense, so be truthful even if the truth is unflattering.
Do not communicate with the other side
Once you've been sued, you cannot speak directly to the plaintiff or their attorney about the case. All communication must go through your attorney or insurance company's legal team. This rule exists to protect you—anything you say can be used against you in court, and statements made without your attorney present are often more damaging than helpful.
If the plaintiff or their attorney contacts you directly, do not engage. Tell them, "My attorney is handling this matter," and end the conversation. If they continue to contact you, your attorney can file a motion to stop the contact (called a motion for a protective order). Do not post about the case on social media, do not discuss it with friends who might be called as witnesses, and do not send emails or texts about what happened. Assume anything you write can be read in court.
If you have witnesses who saw what happened, tell your attorney their names and contact information. Your attorney will decide whether to interview them and how to use their statements in your defense. Do not contact witnesses yourself or ask them to keep quiet about the case.
The discovery process: what to expect
After you file your answer, both sides enter a phase called discovery. This is when the plaintiff's attorney asks you questions under oath (in a deposition) and requests documents related to the case. You must answer truthfully and provide what's requested, or the court can punish you. Your attorney will prepare you for your deposition by explaining what questions to expect and how to answer clearly and carefully.
The key to deposition testimony is to answer only what's asked, not to volunteer extra information. If you don't understand a question, say so. If you don't remember something, say that too—guessing or making something up is far worse than admitting you don't recall. Discovery typically takes several months. During this time, your attorney will also ask the plaintiff questions and request their documents. This is when you learn the strength of their evidence and the details of their claim. Many cases settle during or after discovery, once both sides understand what a trial would actually look like.
Settlement, mediation, or trial
Most personal injury lawsuits settle before trial. Settlement means you and the plaintiff agree on a dollar amount to end the case. Your insurance company usually handles settlement negotiations, though your attorney advises you on whether an offer is reasonable. You have the right to reject a settlement offer, but if you go to trial and lose, you could owe far more than the settlement amount.
Some courts require mediation before trial—a neutral third party helps both sides negotiate. Mediation is not binding; if you don't reach an agreement, the case goes to trial. Your attorney will represent you and advise you throughout. If the case goes to trial, a judge or jury will hear evidence from both sides and decide whether you're liable (legally responsible) and, if so, how much you owe. Trials are public, take time, and are unpredictable. Your attorney will prepare you to testify and will present evidence supporting your defense.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I ignore the lawsuit?
If you don't file a response by the important date, the court will enter a default judgment against you. This means the plaintiff wins automatically, and the court will order you to pay whatever amount they requested in the complaint. You cannot undo a default judgment easily, so missing the important date is one of the worst mistakes you can make.
Will my insurance company definitely pay for my defense?
Most homeowners, auto, and business policies cover personal injury defense, but some claims fall outside coverage. Your insurance company will review the complaint to decide whether to defend you. If they deny coverage, you'll need to hire your own attorney. Read your policy or ask your insurance agent what personal injury claims are covered under your plan.
Can the plaintiff contact me directly to settle?
Once you've been sued and have an attorney, the plaintiff should not contact you directly. If they do, tell them to speak with your attorney and report the contact to your legal team. Direct contact after a lawsuit is filed is considered improper and can be stopped by the court.
How much will it cost to defend myself?
If your insurance covers the claim, you pay nothing—the insurance company covers all legal fees. If you don't have insurance, attorney fees vary widely depending on whether your case settles quickly or goes to trial. Some attorneys charge hourly rates; others work on a contingency basis for certain cases. Discuss fees with any attorney you hire before they begin work.
What if I think the plaintiff's claim is completely false?
Even if you believe the claim is false, you still need to respond to the lawsuit and defend yourself in court. Your attorney will investigate and present evidence showing the claim is unfounded. straightforward saying "it's not true" is not a legal defense; you need evidence to support your position.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.