Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How Personal Injury Firms Screen Cases Before Taking Them On

What Levin Papantonio Rafferty looks for when deciding whether to take a case

Levin Papantonio Rafferty, a personal injury firm based in Pensacola, Florida, uses a standard screening process that most injury law firms follow. They evaluate whether a case has a viable claim, whether the defendant has money or insurance to pay a judgment, and whether the client's injuries are serious enough to justify the cost of litigation. The firm works on contingency, meaning they only get paid if you win or settle—so they must believe the case is worth pursuing before they invest their time and resources.

The screening process is not about whether your injury is real or whether you deserve compensation. It is about whether the firm can realistically win the case and recover money. A sympathetic client with minor injuries and a clear-cut defendant may still be turned down if the defendant has no insurance and no assets. Conversely, a client with serious injuries but a weak factual case may also be declined.

Key Takeaways

  • Firms screen cases based on liability (whether the defendant was clearly at fault), damages (whether injuries are serious enough to justify litigation costs), and collectability (whether the defendant or their insurer can actually pay).
  • Contingency representation means the firm absorbs all costs upfront and only profits if you win, so they must believe the case is winnable before taking it on.
  • A strong injury case requires clear evidence of fault, documented medical treatment, and a solvent defendant or insurance policy—not just a sympathetic story.
  • If a firm declines your case, it does not mean you have no claim; it may mean the firm lacks capacity, the case is too small for their practice, or the liability is too unclear to justify their investment.

Liability: Whether the defendant was clearly at fault

The first question any firm asks is whether the defendant actually caused your injury. This is called liability, and it must be provable with evidence. A car accident with a police report showing the other driver ran a red light is straightforward liability. A slip and fall in a store requires proof that the store knew or should have known about the hazard and failed to warn you or fix it—much harder to prove.

Levin Papantonio Rafferty will look at police reports, witness statements, photographs, video footage, and any other documentation that shows fault. If liability is unclear or depends entirely on your word against the defendant's, the firm is less likely to take the case. The stronger and more objective the evidence of fault, the more likely they are to proceed.

Shared fault also matters. In Florida, you can recover damages even if you were partially at fault, but your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. If you were 40% at fault for an accident, you can only recover 60% of your damages. A firm may decline a case where liability is split evenly or where you bear significant responsibility, because the recovery becomes too uncertain.

Damages: Whether your injuries are serious enough to justify the cost

Even with clear liability, a firm will decline a case if the injuries are minor. Personal injury litigation is expensive. The firm pays for medical records, informed witnesses, depositions, court filings, and sometimes investigators—costs that can easily reach $5,000 to $25,000 or more before trial. If your medical bills total $3,000 and you have no ongoing treatment, the firm cannot justify spending that much to recover a small amount.

Levin Papantonio Rafferty looks at the severity and permanence of your injuries. Serious damages include significant medical expenses, ongoing treatment, lost wages, permanent disability, scarring, or pain and suffering. A broken bone that healed completely with no lasting effects is a weaker case than a spinal injury requiring surgery and ongoing physical therapy. The firm will request your medical records and may have a nurse or doctor review them to assess the true extent of your injuries.

The firm also considers whether your injuries have a clear causal link to the accident. If you were in a car accident and when ready sought treatment for back pain, that is straightforward. If you waited three months to see a doctor, the defendant's insurance company will argue your injuries were not caused by the accident—and the firm knows this will be harder to prove.

Collectability: Whether the defendant or their insurer can actually pay

A winning judgment is worthless if the defendant has no money and no insurance. This is called the collectability problem, and it is a major reason firms decline cases. If you are hit by an uninsured driver with no assets, you may have a perfect liability case and serious injuries, but the firm cannot collect a judgment. They will not take the case because they will not get paid.

Levin Papantonio Rafferty will investigate whether the defendant has liability insurance, what the policy limits are, and whether the defendant has personal assets that could be seized. A defendant with a $100,000 insurance policy and $50,000 in injuries is a viable case. A defendant with no insurance and a minimum-wage job is not, even if liability is crystal clear.

This is also why the firm asks detailed questions about how the accident happened and who was involved. A commercial vehicle (truck, delivery van, taxi) usually has substantial insurance. A private vehicle may have minimal coverage. A business defendant may have multiple insurance policies. The firm's goal is to understand the money available before committing resources to the case.

The firm's capacity and practice focus

Even a strong case with clear liability, serious injuries, and a solvent defendant may be declined if the firm is at capacity. Large firms like Levin Papantonio Rafferty handle hundreds of cases. They may straightforward not have attorney time available to take on new clients. This is not a reflection on your case—it is a business decision about workload.

The firm may also specialize in certain types of cases. Some personal injury firms focus on medical malpractice, others on product liability, others on car accidents. If your case falls outside their main practice areas, they may decline even if the case is strong, because they lack the specific informed or resources to handle it well. A firm that specializes in catastrophic injury cases may decline a straightforward minor injury claim because it is not their focus.

What happens if a firm declines your case

If Levin Papantonio Rafferty or another firm turns down your case, you have several options. First, understand why they declined. If it was due to capacity or practice focus rather than the merits of the case, other firms may take it. If it was due to weak liability or low damages, you should be realistic about your prospects.

You can contact other personal injury firms in your area. Many offer free initial consultations and will review your case. Different firms have different risk tolerances and practice focuses, so a case one firm declines may be acceptable to another. You can also ask the declining firm for a referral to another attorney who might be a better fit.

If you cannot find a firm willing to take your case on contingency, you have the option of hiring an attorney on an hourly basis. This means you pay them directly for their time, regardless of the outcome. This is more expensive and riskier for you, but it may be your only option if your case is too small or too uncertain for contingency representation. Some attorneys also work on a hybrid basis—a small retainer plus a percentage of any recovery.

Red flags that may cause a firm to decline

Certain patterns make a case harder to pursue. A long delay between the injury and seeking treatment raises questions about whether the injury was actually caused by the accident. Multiple prior injuries to the same body part make it harder to prove the defendant caused the current problem. Inconsistent statements about how the accident happened damage credibility.

A client who has been shopping the case to many firms and been declined repeatedly is a warning sign. It suggests the case may have problems that multiple experienced attorneys have identified. A client who is hostile, uncooperative, or unwilling to follow medical information is also risky—litigation requires cooperation and credibility, and a difficult client can undermine both.

Pre-existing conditions are not automatically disqualifying, but they complicate the case. If you had a bad back before the accident and a worse back after, the firm must prove the accident made it worse—not just that you have a bad back. This requires medical informed testimony and is more expensive to litigate.

Frequently Asked Questions

If one firm declines my case, does that mean I don't have a claim?

Not necessarily. A firm may decline for business reasons—lack of capacity, practice focus, or risk tolerance—rather than because your claim is invalid. Different firms evaluate cases differently. It is worth contacting two or three other personal injury attorneys in your area to get a second opinion before assuming your case has no merit.

What should I bring to an initial consultation?

Bring any documentation related to the accident: police reports, photographs, witness contact information, medical records, bills, and proof of lost wages. Bring your insurance information and the defendant's insurance information if you have it. The more organized your documentation, the faster the attorney can evaluate your case.

Why do firms work on contingency if it is so risky?

Contingency representation allows people who cannot afford hourly legal fees to pursue claims. It also aligns the firm's interests with yours—they only profit if you win. However, it means the firm must be selective about which cases they take, because they absorb all costs and risk if the case loses.

Can I still pursue my case if the defendant is uninsured?

Yes, but it is much harder to collect a judgment. You would need to prove the defendant has personal assets—savings, property, vehicles—that can be seized to satisfy the judgment. Most uninsured defendants have minimal assets, which is why many firms decline these cases despite clear liability.

How long does the screening process take?

An initial consultation typically takes 30 minutes to an hour. The firm may ask for medical records and other documentation, which can take a few days to gather. A decision on whether to take the case usually comes within one to two weeks, though some firms may take longer if they need to investigate further.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.