How to Appeal a Personal Injury Verdict
What happens after a jury or judge rules against you
If you lost your personal injury case at trial, you have a limited window to file an appeal — typically 30 days from the date the verdict was entered, though this varies by state and court. An appeal does not mean a new trial or a chance to present new evidence. Instead, an appellate court reviews the written record of what happened at trial to decide whether the judge made a legal error that affected the outcome. If the court finds such an error, it may order a new trial, reduce the damages awarded, or reverse the verdict entirely.
The appeal process is expensive and slow. You will need a lawyer who specializes in appellate work, and the case will take one to three years to resolve. Most appeals fail — the appellate court upholds the original verdict more often than it overturns it. But if the trial judge made a significant mistake in how they instructed the jury, admitted evidence improperly, or applied the law incorrectly, an appeal may be your only path forward.
Key Takeaways
- You must file a notice of appeal within 30 days of the verdict in most states, or you lose the right to appeal entirely.
- An appeal reviews whether the judge made a legal error, not whether the jury made the right decision about the facts.
- You will need an appellate attorney, and the process typically costs several thousand dollars and takes one to three years.
- The appellate court will read the trial transcript and written briefs, but will not hear new witnesses or see new evidence.
- Most appeals are denied, so you should discuss with your lawyer whether your case has grounds strong enough to justify the time and cost.
The 30-day important date and notice of appeal
The first step is filing a notice of appeal with the trial court clerk within 30 days of the verdict. This is a short document that tells the court you are appealing and identifies which party you are appealing against. Missing this important date almost always means you lose your right to appeal — courts rarely grant extensions, and the important date is strictly enforced.
If you do not have a lawyer yet, you must hire one when ready. Many trial lawyers do not handle appeals; appellate practice is a separate specialty. Your trial attorney can refer you to an appellate lawyer, or you can contact your state bar association for a referral. Some appellate lawyers will review your case for free to decide whether it is worth taking on.
Once your appellate lawyer is hired, they will file the notice of appeal on your behalf. They will also order the trial transcript from the court reporter — this is the word-for-word record of everything said at trial and is essential to the appeal. The transcript can cost $1,000 to $3,000 or more depending on trial length.
What the appellate court will and will not review
An appellate court does not retry your case. It does not decide whether the jury was right about the facts — whether the defendant was actually negligent, whether you were actually injured, or how much your damages are worth. Those are jury decisions, and appellate courts give them significant deference.
Instead, the appellate court reviews whether the judge made a legal error. Common grounds for appeal include: the judge gave incorrect jury instructions, the judge admitted evidence that should have been excluded, the judge excluded evidence that should have been admitted, the judge made a ruling on a motion that was legally wrong, or the verdict was so far out of line with the evidence that no reasonable jury could have reached it. This last ground — called a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, or JNOV — is rarely successful.
The appellate court will not hear new witnesses, see new evidence, or listen to oral arguments from you or your lawyer (though some courts allow brief oral arguments). It will read the trial transcript, the written briefs filed by both sides, and any exhibits entered at trial. That is the entire record it reviews.
The appellate brief and the written record
Your appellate lawyer will write a brief — a detailed legal document that explains what error the trial judge made and why that error was serious enough to overturn the verdict. The brief must cite the trial transcript by page number to show exactly where the error occurred. It must also cite case law and statutes to show that the judge's action violated the law.
The other side will file a response brief defending the judge's decision. Your lawyer may then file a reply brief. This exchange of written arguments is the heart of the appeal. The quality of the briefs matters enormously — a poorly written brief with weak legal arguments will not persuade the court, no matter how unfair the trial was.
Your appellate lawyer will also prepare the record on appeal, which is the official collection of all documents from the trial court — the complaint, motions, trial transcript, exhibits, and the judgment. The appellate court uses this record to understand what happened.
How long an appeal takes and what it costs
An appeal typically takes 12 to 36 months from the time you file the notice until you receive a decision. The timeline depends on the court's caseload and the complexity of the issues. During this time, very little happens — your lawyer writes the brief, the other side responds, and then you wait for the court to schedule oral arguments or issue a written decision.
The cost of an appeal usually ranges from $5,000 to $15,000 or more, depending on the length of the trial, the complexity of the legal issues, and how much work the appellate lawyer must do. Some appellate lawyers charge a flat fee for the entire appeal; others bill by the hour. You should ask for a written fee agreement before hiring.
During the appeal, the trial judgment remains in effect. If you won money at trial, the other side can appeal that judgment too. If you lost and owe money, the other side may begin collecting while your appeal is pending, though your lawyer can ask the trial court to stay (pause) the judgment pending appeal.
When an appeal is worth pursuing
Before you commit time and money to an appeal, have an honest conversation with your appellate lawyer about your chances. Ask them to identify the specific legal error they believe occurred and to explain why that error is likely to persuade the appellate court to overturn the verdict. If your lawyer cannot point to a clear error in the judge's legal rulings — if the case straightforward came down to the jury not believing your evidence — an appeal is unlikely to succeed.
Appeals succeed most often when the judge gave the jury incorrect instructions, admitted evidence that was clearly prejudicial and should have been excluded, or made a ruling on a key motion that was legally wrong. Appeals rarely succeed when the issue is straightforward that the jury did not find your evidence convincing.
You should also consider whether you can afford the cost and time. If you are already financially strained from the trial, an appeal that takes two years and costs $10,000 may not be realistic. Your lawyer can help you weigh the strength of your case against the practical realities of pursuing it.
What happens if you win the appeal
If the appellate court agrees that the judge made a reversible error, it will issue a written opinion explaining its decision. The court may order a new trial, in which case your case goes back to the trial court and starts over. You will have another trial, another jury, and another chance to present your evidence — but you will also face another round of litigation costs and delays.
Alternatively, the appellate court may reduce the damages awarded, order the trial court to enter judgment in your favor, or remand the case for a new trial on damages only (if the error affected only the amount of money, not liability). The specific remedy depends on what error the court found and how serious it was.
If the appellate court denies your appeal, the trial verdict stands. You may be able to appeal to your state's highest court, but that court accepts very few cases and the standards for review are even stricter. Your appellate lawyer can advise you on whether that step makes sense in your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I appeal if I did not have a lawyer at trial?
Yes, but it is much harder. You can still file a notice of appeal and hire an appellate lawyer. However, if you represented yourself, the appellate court will assume you knew the rules and may not excuse errors you made during trial. You should hire an appellate lawyer as soon as possible after the verdict.
What if I cannot afford an appellate lawyer?
If you are indigent (very low income), you may be able to request a court-appointed appellate lawyer, but this is available only in criminal cases and some civil cases involving fundamental rights. In most personal injury appeals, you must hire your own lawyer or represent yourself. Some appellate lawyers work on contingency (taking a percentage of any money recovered on appeal), though this is less common than in trial work.
Can I appeal while the trial court is still deciding other motions?
Not usually. You must wait until the judge has entered a final judgment — a written order that resolves all claims and all parties. If the case is still pending on some issues, the appeal court will likely dismiss your appeal as premature. Your lawyer can ask the trial judge to clarify whether the judgment is final.
Does filing an appeal stop the other side from collecting the judgment against me?
Not automatically. The trial judgment remains in effect while you appeal. However, your lawyer can ask the trial court for a stay of judgment, which pauses collection efforts while the appeal is pending. The court will grant a stay only if you show a likelihood of success on appeal and that you will suffer irreparable harm if collection continues.
How many times can I appeal?
You have one appeal as of right to the intermediate appellate court (usually called the Court of Appeals). After that, you can petition your state's highest court for review, but that court decides which cases it will hear and accepts only a small percentage. Once the highest court denies review, the case is over.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.