When a Defendant's Insurance Won't Cover Your Injury Damages
What happens when the at-fault driver's insurance limit is less than your damages
When the person who caused your injury has insurance coverage that does not reach the full amount of your damages, you have a legal claim against that person personally for the unpaid portion. This is called being underinsured — the defendant's policy limit (the maximum the insurance company will pay) falls short of what you are owed. The insurance company will pay up to its limit, but you can pursue the defendant directly for anything beyond that.
The defendant becomes personally liable for the gap. This means you can seek a judgment against them in court, and if you win, you can attempt to collect from their personal assets — bank accounts, wages, property, or other valuables. Whether you can actually collect depends on the defendant's financial situation and your state's laws about what assets are protected from judgment creditors.
This is different from an uninsured claim, where there is no insurance at all. With underinsurance, you at least have the policy limit to work with; the question is what happens to the rest.
Key Takeaways
- The defendant's insurance company pays its policy limit first, and you must pursue the defendant personally for any damages above that amount.
- A personal judgment against the defendant allows you to seek collection from their wages, bank accounts, and other non-exempt assets, depending on your state's laws.
- Some states allow you to tap your own underinsured motorist coverage (if you have it) to cover the gap, without suing the defendant personally.
- Collecting a judgment from a defendant with few assets is often difficult and may require ongoing collection efforts over months or years.
- An attorney can help you decide whether pursuing the defendant personally is worth the time and cost, based on what you know about their finances.
How the defendant becomes personally liable
The defendant is liable because they caused the injury through negligence or wrongdoing — that liability exists regardless of their insurance. The insurance policy is straightforward a contract between the defendant and their insurance company. Once the policy limit is exhausted, the insurance company stops paying, but the defendant's legal obligation to you does not disappear.
If you file a lawsuit and win a judgment, the court orders the defendant to pay you a specific amount. That judgment is a legal debt, just like a credit card bill or a loan. The defendant is now personally responsible for satisfying it. Your next step is to collect on that judgment, which is where the defendant's personal finances come into play.
The defendant does not have to agree to this. You must prove your case in court — that they were at fault, that you suffered damages, and what those damages are worth. The insurance company's policy limit does not limit your right to sue; it only limits what the insurance company will pay.
Collection methods after you win a judgment
Once you have a judgment, you become a judgment creditor. Your state's laws determine which of the defendant's assets you can reach. Most states allow you to pursue wage garnishment (a court order that directs the defendant's employer to send a portion of each paycheck to you), bank account levies (freezing and withdrawing funds), and liens on real property (a claim against the defendant's house or land).
The process usually starts with post-judgment discovery, where you ask the defendant detailed questions about their income, assets, and debts. Many defendants must answer these questions under oath. If they refuse or lie, you can ask the court to hold them in contempt. Based on what you learn, you can then ask the court to order specific collection methods.
Wage garnishment is often the most reliable method because it is ongoing — the court order stays in place until the judgment is paid or the defendant leaves that job. Bank levies are faster but one-time; once the account is emptied, you must find another asset. Property liens are useful if the defendant owns a home, but you may have to wait until they sell it or refinance to collect.
Some states protect certain assets from judgment creditors. For example, many states exempt a portion of wages (often 75 percent of take-home pay), a primary residence up to a certain value, retirement accounts, and tools of the trade. These exemptions vary widely by state, so what you can collect depends on where the defendant lives and works.
Using your own underinsured motorist coverage instead
If you carry underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage on your own auto insurance policy, you may have another option. UIM coverage is designed to protect you when the at-fault driver's insurance is insufficient. Instead of suing the defendant personally, you can file a claim with your own insurance company for the gap between the defendant's policy limit and your damages (up to your UIM limit).
This route is often faster and more reliable than pursuing the defendant personally. Your own insurance company has assets and a legal obligation to pay valid claims. You do not have to prove the defendant's finances or chase collection. However, you must have purchased UIM coverage, and your policy must have a high enough limit to cover the gap.
Many states require insurers to offer UIM coverage, but you have to accept it — it does not come automatically. If you did not purchase it, this option is not available to you. If you did purchase it, check your policy documents to see what your UIM limit is and whether it applies to your situation.
Your own insurance company may also pursue the defendant for reimbursement (called subrogation), which means they try to collect from the defendant's insurance or personal assets to recover what they paid you. This does not affect you directly, but it can help offset your insurer's payout.
When the defendant has few or no assets
If the defendant has little income, no savings, and no property, collecting a judgment becomes very difficult. You can win in court, but a judgment against someone with no money is often uncollectible. This is a hard reality: the legal system gives you the right to pursue them, but it cannot force them to have assets.
Some defendants declare bankruptcy after a judgment, which can wipe out or reduce the debt. Others straightforward ignore the judgment, and without ongoing collection efforts, nothing happens. You can renew judgments in most states (extending the time you have to collect), but renewal does not create assets that were not there before.
Before you invest time and attorney fees in pursuing a defendant personally, it is worth investigating their financial situation. If they are judgment-proof (a legal term meaning they have no collectible assets), you may decide that suing them is not worth the cost. Your attorney can help you make this decision based on what you learn during discovery.
Working with an attorney on personal liability claims
Most personal injury attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover and charge nothing upfront. This arrangement works well when the defendant's insurance is sufficient or when you have your own UIM coverage. When you are pursuing the defendant personally for an underinsured gap, the calculation changes.
Personal collection is time-consuming and uncertain. Your attorney may still take the case on contingency, but they will likely discuss the realistic chances of collecting based on what they learn about the defendant's finances. Some attorneys charge hourly fees for collection work, since it is separate from the initial injury claim and may take months or years.
An experienced attorney can also advise you on whether settling for the insurance policy limit is the better choice. Sometimes accepting what the insurance company offers and moving on is more practical than chasing a defendant with no money. Your attorney should explain the trade-offs clearly so you can make an informed decision.
State differences in personal liability and collection
The rules for pursuing a defendant personally and collecting a judgment vary significantly by state. Some states have high wage exemptions (protecting most of the defendant's paycheck), while others allow more aggressive garnishment. Some states protect homestead property generously; others do not.
Additionally, some states have rules about how underinsured motorist claims work. A few states require you to exhaust the defendant's insurance before you can use your own UIM coverage. Others allow you to use UIM coverage regardless of whether you sue the defendant. These differences matter because they affect your strategy and your realistic recovery.
Your attorney should know your state's rules and how they explore to your specific situation. If you are considering representing yourself, research your state's judgment collection procedures through your state bar association or court system website.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue the defendant for more than their insurance policy limit?
Yes. The policy limit only restricts what the insurance company will pay. You can sue for your full damages, and if you win, the defendant is personally liable for anything above their policy limit. The insurance company pays first, up to the limit, and you pursue the defendant for the rest.
What if the defendant declares bankruptcy after I get a judgment?
Bankruptcy can discharge (eliminate) a judgment debt, depending on the type of bankruptcy and your state's laws. Personal injury judgments are sometimes treated as priority debts, but not always. An attorney can explain how bankruptcy would affect your specific judgment and what options you have.
How long can I collect on a judgment?
Judgments last 10 to 20 years depending on your state, and you can usually renew them before they expire. This means you can pursue collection for decades if necessary. However, the longer you wait, the harder it may be to locate the defendant or their assets.
Is my own underinsured motorist coverage better than suing the defendant?
Usually yes, if you have it. Your insurance company must pay valid claims and cannot claim the defendant is judgment-proof. You avoid the cost and uncertainty of collection. However, you are limited to your UIM policy limit, whereas a lawsuit could theoretically recover more if the defendant had assets.
Can the defendant's wages be garnished forever?
Wage garnishment continues as long as the judgment is active and the defendant works for an employer that honors the garnishment order. If they change jobs, you must serve the garnishment order on the new employer. Once the judgment expires (usually 10 to 20 years), you can no longer garnish unless you renew it.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.