What Happens When You're Sued for Personal Injury
You have legal obligations the moment you're served with a lawsuit
Being named as a defendant in a personal injury lawsuit means someone is claiming you caused them harm and are asking a court to order you to pay for it. You are not automatically liable — the plaintiff has to prove their case — but you do have concrete legal important date and procedures to follow from the moment you receive the lawsuit papers. Missing these important date can result in a default judgment against you, which means the court rules in the plaintiff's favor without hearing your side.
The first document you'll receive is called a complaint, which outlines what the plaintiff claims happened, how you caused it, and what damages they're seeking. This comes with a summons, a court order telling you when you must respond. You will also receive information about where and how to file your response. The timeline varies by state and court, but you typically have 20 to 30 days to respond in writing.
Key Takeaways
- You must respond to the lawsuit in writing within the important date set by the court — usually 20 to 30 days — or risk a default judgment against you.
- Your response options include filing an answer (admitting or denying each claim), a motion to dismiss (arguing the lawsuit should not proceed), or both.
- Most personal injury cases settle before trial, but you should assume the case will go to trial unless and until a settlement agreement is signed.
- Your insurance company, if you have liability coverage, will likely assign you a lawyer at no cost to you and will handle settlement negotiations.
- If you cannot afford a lawyer and the case involves significant money, you may be able to find one on a contingency basis, though this is less common for defendants.
What your response to the lawsuit must include
Your written response is called an answer in most cases. In it, you admit or deny each factual claim in the complaint. You do not have to agree with the plaintiff's legal conclusions — only with or against the specific facts they allege. For example, if the complaint says "the defendant ran a red light," you can admit you were at that intersection but deny you ran the light. You can also say you lack information to admit or deny a claim, which is treated as a denial.
Along with your answer, you can raise affirmative defenses — legal arguments that even if the plaintiff's facts are true, you should not be held liable. Common affirmative defenses include comparative negligence (the plaintiff was partly at fault), assumption of risk (the plaintiff knew the danger and accepted it), or statute of limitations (the lawsuit was filed too late). Your state's law determines which defenses are available in your type of case.
You can also file a motion to dismiss before or instead of an answer. This argues that the complaint fails to state a valid legal claim, that the court lacks authority over you, or that the lawsuit was filed in the wrong place. If the judge grants the motion, the case ends without you having to file an answer. If the judge denies it, you then file your answer.
How insurance coverage changes your position
If you have homeowners, auto, or business liability insurance, your insurance company has a duty to defend you in the lawsuit. This means they will hire a lawyer for you at no cost and will pay for your legal defense. You should notify your insurance company when ready after receiving the lawsuit papers — your policy likely requires it, and delaying can give the company grounds to deny coverage later.
Your insurance company's lawyer works for you during the lawsuit but also represents the insurance company's financial interests. If a settlement offer comes in, the insurance company decides whether to accept it (up to your policy limits). If the judgment exceeds your policy limits, you may be personally responsible for the difference, though this is rare in practice because most cases settle within coverage limits.
If you do not have insurance or the claim exceeds your coverage, you will need to hire your own lawyer. This is expensive, and most personal injury defendants cannot afford hourly rates. Some lawyers will take a defendant's case on contingency (taking a percentage of any settlement or judgment in your favor), but this is uncommon because defendants rarely recover money — they usually pay it.
The discovery process and what you'll be asked to produce
After you file your answer, both sides enter discovery, a period where each side requests documents, answers to written questions, and testimony from the other side. You will receive interrogatories (written questions you must answer under oath), requests for production of documents (asking you to turn over emails, photos, medical records, or other evidence), and possibly a deposition (an in-person or video interview where a lawyer questions you under oath).
You must respond to discovery requests within the important date set by the court — usually 30 days. Failing to respond can result in sanctions, including fines or even a default judgment. Your lawyer will help you prepare answers and decide what documents to produce. Do not destroy documents or communications related to the incident, even if they look bad for your case — doing so can result in severe penalties.
During your deposition, the plaintiff's lawyer will ask you about the incident, your actions, your knowledge, and anything else relevant to the case. You should prepare thoroughly with your lawyer beforehand. Anything you say can be used against you at trial, so answer only what is asked, do not volunteer information, and say "I don't know" or "I don't remember" if that is truthful.
Settlement negotiations and when cases go to trial
Most personal injury cases settle before trial. Settlement discussions can begin at any point — sometimes before you even file an answer, sometimes months into discovery, sometimes on the courthouse steps. If your insurance company is defending you, they will handle settlement negotiations. If you hired your own lawyer, your lawyer will negotiate on your behalf.
A settlement is a written agreement where you pay the plaintiff a sum of money in exchange for them dropping the lawsuit. The amount depends on the strength of each side's case, the severity of the plaintiff's injuries, the insurance coverage available, and how much each side wants to avoid the risk and cost of trial. Your lawyer should explain the risks of going to trial — a jury might award more than the settlement offer, or less, or nothing.
If settlement talks fail, the case proceeds to trial. At trial, the plaintiff presents evidence and witnesses to prove you caused their harm. You present your defense. A judge or jury decides whether you are liable and, if so, how much you must pay. Trial is expensive, time-consuming, and unpredictable. Most defendants prefer settlement if the terms are reasonable.
Finding and evaluating a lawyer if you don't have insurance coverage
If you are being sued and have no insurance, your first step is to find a lawyer quickly — your response important date is approaching. Start by contacting your state bar association, which maintains a lawyer referral service. Many bar associations have sections for civil defense lawyers, who specialize in defending personal injury cases.
When you call a lawyer, be honest about your financial situation. Ask whether they will take the case on contingency (unlikely for a defendant) or what their hourly rate is. Ask how much the case will cost in total, including filing fees and informed witnesses. Ask how long they have been defending personal injury cases and what their experience is with cases similar to yours.
Red flags include a lawyer who guarantees an outcome, who pressures you to settle when ready, who is hard to reach, or who cannot clearly explain the process and your options. A good lawyer will listen to your account of what happened, explain the law and your risks honestly, and give you time to decide before you hire them.
What happens if you lose or if a judgment is entered against you
If a judgment is entered against you — either because a jury found you liable or because you failed to respond and the court entered a default judgment — you owe the plaintiff the amount the court ordered. If you have insurance, your insurance company pays up to your policy limits. If the judgment exceeds your coverage, you are responsible for the difference.
You have the right to appeal a judgment, which means asking a higher court to review the trial court's decision. Appeals are expensive and succeed only if the trial court made a legal error, not straightforward because you disagree with the outcome. Your lawyer can advise you on whether an appeal is worth pursuing in your case.
If you cannot pay a judgment, the plaintiff can pursue collection actions, including garnishing your wages, placing a lien on your property, or seizing bank accounts. The specifics depend on your state's law and what assets you have. Some assets, like your primary home or retirement accounts, may be protected from collection in some states.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do the moment I receive the lawsuit papers?
Read the summons carefully to find your response important date. Contact your insurance company when ready if you have liability coverage. Call a lawyer the same day if you do not have insurance. Do not ignore the papers or assume the case will go away. Missing the important date results in a default judgment against you.
Can I settle the case without going to trial?
Yes, most cases settle. Settlement can happen at any stage, from before you file an answer to the day before trial. Your lawyer or insurance company's lawyer will negotiate with the plaintiff's lawyer. You have the right to accept or reject any settlement offer, though your insurance company's lawyer will advise you on whether the offer is reasonable.
What if I cannot afford a lawyer?
If you have liability insurance, your insurance company provides a lawyer at no cost. If you do not have insurance, contact your state bar association's lawyer referral service. Some lawyers may take a case on contingency, though this is uncommon for defendants. Legal aid organizations rarely help defendants in civil cases, but it is worth asking.
Can the plaintiff take my house or my paycheck if I lose?
If a judgment is entered against you, the plaintiff can pursue collection actions including wage garnishment and property liens. However, your primary home and certain retirement accounts are protected from collection in many states. The specifics depend on your state's law and the size of the judgment.
What happens if I ignore the lawsuit?
If you do not respond by the important date, the court will enter a default judgment against you, meaning the plaintiff wins without a trial. You will owe the full amount the plaintiff requested. You may be able to ask the court to set aside the default judgment, but this requires a good reason and must happen quickly.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.