Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Expect When the Other Side Questions You at Your Deposition

What happens during cross-examination at your deposition

Cross-examination at a deposition is when the other side's lawyer questions you under oath about your injury, your medical care, your lost wages, and your version of what happened. You are sitting in a room with a court reporter, your own lawyer, and the other side's lawyer — usually in an office, not a courtroom. The other lawyer will ask you questions designed to test the strength of your claim, find inconsistencies in your story, or get you to admit facts that help their case. Your answers are recorded word-for-word and can be used later in court or to pressure you into settling.

This is not a conversation. The other side's lawyer is not trying to understand you — they are trying to build a record that weakens your case. Knowing what to expect and how to answer protects you from accidentally damaging your own claim.

Key Takeaways

  • Cross-examination happens under oath, meaning false or evasive answers can be used against you in court and may expose you to perjury charges.
  • The other side's lawyer will ask narrow, leading questions designed to lock you into specific answers that help their case.
  • Your own lawyer can object to certain questions, but you still have to answer most of them — objections do not give you permission to stay silent.
  • Pausing before you answer, admitting what you do not know, and sticking to what actually happened are the three most important things you can do.
  • Anything you say at deposition can be read to a jury later, so treat every answer as if a judge is listening.

The types of questions the other side will ask

The other lawyer will use leading questions — statements phrased as questions that suggest the answer they want. For example: "You were texting when the accident happened, weren't you?" or "You didn't seek medical attention until three days later, correct?" These are not open-ended questions asking what you remember. They are designed to get you to agree with a specific version of events.

They will also ask about your medical history before the injury, your prior claims or lawsuits, any gaps in your treatment, and anything you said to friends, family, or on social media. They want to show that your injury is not as serious as you claim, that you are exaggerating, or that something else caused your pain. They may ask the same question multiple times in slightly different ways to see if your answer changes.

They will ask about your job, your income, how much time you actually missed work, and whether you were able to do any activities during your recovery. They want to minimize the amount of lost wages or lost earning capacity you can claim. They will also ask detailed questions about your pain — when it started, where it is, what makes it better or worse, whether you can do specific tasks — because pain is subjective and harder to prove than a broken bone.

How to answer without hurting your case

Listen to the entire question before you answer. Do not interrupt or start talking while the lawyer is still speaking. Pause for a moment after the question ends — this gives your lawyer time to object if the question is improper, and it gives you time to think instead of blurting out an answer you regret.

Answer only what is asked. If the question is "Did you go to the doctor on January 15th?" the answer is "Yes" or "No," not a story about why you went or what happened there. If you volunteer extra information, the other side will use it. If you do not know the answer, say "I don't know" or "I don't remember" — do not guess, do not make something up, and do not say "I think" or "probably." Those words make you sound uncertain about things you should be certain about.

If you do not understand the question, say so. Ask the lawyer to rephrase it or define a term. This is not weakness — it is protection. A confusing question often contains a trap, and asking for clarity gives you time to spot it. If the question assumes a fact that is not true — "When you were speeding through the intersection..." — you can correct it: "I was not speeding. I was driving at the posted speed limit."

Never argue with the lawyer or get angry. Stay calm and professional. If you lose your temper, the jury will remember that, not your injury. If the lawyer is being rude or asking improper questions, your lawyer will object — that is their job. Your job is to answer truthfully and clearly.

What your lawyer can and cannot do during cross-examination

Your lawyer sits next to you during the deposition. They can object to certain types of questions — questions that ask for legal conclusions, questions that violate attorney-client privilege, questions that are vague or compound, or questions that ask you to speculate about things you have no way of knowing. When your lawyer objects, the court reporter records the objection, but you still have to answer the question unless your lawyer tells you not to.

Your lawyer cannot tell you what to say or coach you on your answers during the deposition itself. They can object, they can ask for a break if you need one, and they can clarify something after the other side is done questioning you. But they cannot put words in your mouth or signal you to change your story. If you need a break to talk to your lawyer privately, you can ask for one — the deposition will pause, and you can step out of the room.

Before the deposition, your lawyer should prepare you by going over the facts of your case, the types of questions you will face, and how to answer them. If your lawyer has not done this, ask them to. Preparation is not coaching — it is making sure you understand the process and are ready to tell the truth clearly.

Questions about your medical treatment and recovery

The other side will ask detailed questions about every doctor you saw, every test you had, every medication you took, and every time you missed an appointment or stopped treatment. They want to show that you did not follow your doctor's information, that you got better faster than you claim, or that your injury is not as serious as you say. Be honest about all of it — if you missed appointments, say so. If you stopped physical therapy, explain why. If you felt better at some point, admit it.

They will ask whether you told your doctors about all your symptoms, whether you exaggerated your pain to the doctors, and whether you have ever had similar pain before. They will ask about any pre-existing conditions and whether the injury made them worse. They will ask whether you have received any settlement or payment from anyone else related to this injury. Answer all of these questions truthfully. Lying about medical facts is straightforward to disprove because your medical records are in writing.

If there is a gap in your treatment — a period where you did not see a doctor — the other side will argue that your injury healed during that time. Be ready to explain why you did not seek treatment: you could not afford it, you were managing the pain at home, you were waiting for an appointment, or you thought it would get better on its own. These are all common and understandable reasons. The fact that you did not see a doctor does not mean you were not injured.

Handling questions about your activities and daily life

The other side will ask what you can and cannot do now compared to before the injury. They will ask about specific activities: Can you walk? How far? Can you lift things? How much? Can you sit for long periods? Can you drive? Can you work? They will ask whether you have gone to restaurants, movies, shopping, or social events. They will ask whether you exercise, play sports, or do hobbies. They will ask about your household chores, yard work, and childcare.

Answer these questions honestly. If you can do something, say so. If you cannot, say so. If you can do it but it causes pain or takes longer than it used to, explain that. The other side is looking for evidence that you are exaggerating — that you claim you cannot work but you can go hiking, or that you say you have constant pain but you are seen smiling in a photograph. If there is a video or photo of you doing something that contradicts what you are saying, the other side will have it and will confront you with it. Do not lie about your activities. Instead, explain the difference between what you can do for a short time and what you can do all day, or the difference between what you can do on a good day and a bad day.

What happens after your deposition ends

After the other side finishes questioning you, your lawyer may ask you some questions to clarify or correct anything that was said. This is called redirect examination. Then the deposition is over. The court reporter will prepare a transcript — a typed version of everything that was said — and send it to both lawyers. You have the right to read the transcript and correct any errors the court reporter made in transcribing your words, though you cannot change your actual answers.

Your deposition testimony becomes part of the case file. If the case goes to trial, the other side can read parts of your deposition to the jury to show inconsistencies or to impeach your credibility. Your own lawyer can also use your deposition testimony to refresh your memory if you testify at trial. The deposition is a permanent record of what you said under oath, so take it seriously.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I refuse to answer a question at my deposition?

You can refuse to answer only if your lawyer objects and tells you not to answer — which happens rarely, usually for questions about attorney-client communications or trade secrets. For almost all other questions, you must answer even if you do not want to. Refusing to answer without a valid legal reason can result in the judge ordering you to answer, or in sanctions against you.

What if I give an answer at my deposition and then change it later?

The other side will use your deposition answer to attack your credibility at trial. They will ask you why you said something different before, and a jury will wonder whether you are lying now or lied then. Consistency matters. If you realize during the deposition that you gave a wrong answer, tell your lawyer during the break and correct it on the record before the deposition ends.

Can the other side use my deposition to settle the case?

Yes. If your deposition goes badly — if you contradict yourself, admit facts that hurt your case, or come across as dishonest — the other side may use it to pressure you into accepting a lower settlement. They may also use it to convince their own insurance company that the case is weaker than they thought. A strong deposition can actually help you negotiate a better settlement.

What should I wear to my deposition?

Wear what you would wear to court: business casual or business formal. Avoid anything that looks like you are trying too hard to impress or anything that contradicts your injury claim — do not wear a neck brace if you are claiming a back injury, and do not show up in athletic wear if you are claiming you cannot exercise. Dress as if a jury is watching.

Can I bring documents or notes to my deposition?

You can bring documents that help you remember facts — medical records, pay stubs, calendars, or journals you kept about your symptoms. You cannot bring a script or notes that tell you what to say. If you bring documents, the other side can ask to see them, and anything you bring can be used as evidence in the case.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.