What to Expect When You Work With a Personal Injury Attorney in Buffalo
How a personal injury attorney helps after an accident or injury
A personal injury attorney in Buffalo handles the practical and legal work that comes after you've been hurt—whether from a car crash, workplace injury, slip and fall, or another incident where someone else's negligence caused your harm. They investigate what happened, gather evidence, communicate with insurance companies on your behalf, and either negotiate a settlement or take your case to court if needed. You don't pay them unless they recover money for you.
The attorney's job is to build a case that shows who was at fault and what your injury actually cost you—medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, ongoing care. Insurance companies have teams of adjusters and lawyers working to pay you as little as possible. An attorney levels that playing field by knowing what similar cases are worth, what evidence holds up, and how to push back on lowball offers.
Most personal injury work happens outside the courtroom. Your attorney will handle phone calls with adjusters, request medical records, review police reports, and negotiate. If the insurance company won't offer fair value, your attorney can file a lawsuit and prepare for trial. Either way, you're not managing that process alone while you're recovering.
Key Takeaways
- A personal injury attorney investigates your case, gathers evidence, and handles all communication with insurance companies so you can focus on recovery.
- You pay the attorney only if they recover money for you—this is called a contingency fee arrangement and is standard in personal injury law.
- The attorney's role includes calculating what your case is worth (medical costs, lost income, pain and suffering) and pushing back against insurance offers that undervalue your claim.
- Most cases settle without trial, but your attorney must be ready to file a lawsuit and go to court if the insurance company refuses a fair offer.
- In Buffalo, personal injury cases are handled in Erie County courts, and an attorney familiar with local judges and procedures can be an advantage.
What happens in the first meeting with an attorney
The first conversation is usually free and is your chance to tell the story of what happened and how it's affected you. The attorney will ask about the incident itself—where, when, who was involved, what you saw—and about your injuries and medical treatment so far. They'll want to know if you've already talked to an insurance adjuster and what you've said. Be honest about everything, including any injuries you had before this incident.
The attorney will explain how personal injury law works, what your case might be worth based on similar cases, and what the next steps would be. They'll also tell you whether they think your case is strong enough to take on. Not every injury case is worth pursuing—sometimes the at-fault person has no insurance and no assets, or the injury is minor and the costs of litigation would eat up any recovery. A good attorney will tell you that directly.
If you both agree to work together, you'll sign a retainer agreement that spells out the fee arrangement (usually 33% of any settlement or court award, sometimes higher if the case goes to trial), what the attorney will do, and what you need to do. You'll also sign a medical records release so the attorney can get your treatment history from doctors and hospitals.
The investigation and evidence-gathering phase
Once you've hired an attorney, they begin building the case. This means obtaining the police report (if there is one), medical records from every provider who has treated you, bills and receipts for all costs related to the injury, and proof of lost wages if you missed work. Your attorney may also hire investigators to photograph the scene, interview witnesses, or obtain surveillance video if one exists.
For some cases—especially car accidents—your attorney will order the other driver's insurance records and any prior claims history. They may also request the maintenance records of a vehicle or property if mechanical or structural failure played a role. If a business is at fault, the attorney might subpoena their safety logs, incident reports, or training records to show negligence.
Medical evidence is critical. Your attorney will review your medical records to understand the full scope of your injury, the treatment you've received, and what your doctors say about your long-term outlook. They may also hire a medical informed to review your case and provide an opinion on causation (whether the accident actually caused your injury) and prognosis (what your recovery will look like). This informed opinion often becomes crucial in settlement negotiations or at trial.
How settlement negotiations work
Once the investigation is complete and your medical treatment has stabilized, your attorney will send a demand letter to the at-fault person's insurance company. This letter lays out the facts of the case, explains why the other party was at fault, lists all your damages (medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering), and states the amount you're demanding to settle. The demand is usually higher than what you'd actually accept, because negotiation is expected.
The insurance adjuster will respond with a counteroffer—often much lower than your demand. Your attorney will then negotiate back and forth, exchanging offers and counteroffers. This process can take weeks or months. During this time, your attorney is also managing your medical care—making sure you're getting the treatment you need and that bills are being documented properly.
If you and the insurance company reach a number you both agree to, the case settles. The insurance company sends a check, usually to your attorney's trust account. Your attorney pays any medical providers who have a lien (a legal claim to part of your settlement), pays themselves their fee, and sends you the remainder. You'll sign a release form agreeing not to sue over this injury again.
When a case goes to trial
If settlement negotiations stall and the insurance company won't offer what your case is worth, your attorney can file a lawsuit in Erie County Court. This is a bigger commitment—it costs more in court fees and informed witness fees, and it takes longer. But sometimes it's necessary to get fair value.
Once a lawsuit is filed, both sides go through discovery, which means exchanging documents, answering written questions (called interrogatories), and sitting for depositions where you and other witnesses answer questions under oath. Your attorney will prepare you for your deposition and for trial testimony. They'll also file motions asking the court to rule on legal questions before trial even starts.
At trial, your attorney presents evidence, calls witnesses (including you), and argues why the other party was at fault and what you deserve. The other side does the same. A judge or jury then decides whether the defendant is liable and, if so, how much to award you. Trials are unpredictable—juries can award more or less than you expected—which is why most cases settle before reaching this point.
What personal injury cases cost and how fees work
Personal injury attorneys in Buffalo work on contingency, meaning you don't pay them an hourly rate or upfront fee. Instead, they take a percentage of whatever money they recover for you. The standard percentage is 33% (one-third) of a settlement, and often 40% (two-fifths) if the case goes to trial, because trial requires much more work and carries more risk.
You are responsible for costs separate from the attorney's fee—things like court filing fees, costs to obtain medical records, informed witness fees, investigator fees, and deposition transcripts. These costs come out of your settlement before the attorney takes their percentage. Your retainer agreement should spell out exactly which costs you'll owe and when.
If your case doesn't recover any money, you owe the attorney nothing. However, you may still owe the costs if they were already paid. Some attorneys will advance costs and only ask you to repay them if you win; others ask you to pay as you go. This is something to clarify in your first meeting.
Questions to ask before hiring an attorney
Before you commit to working with an attorney, ask how many personal injury cases they've handled and how many have gone to trial versus settled. Ask about their experience with cases similar to yours. Ask what they think your case is worth and what factors could make it worth more or less. Ask about their fee percentage and which costs you'll be responsible for.
Ask how often they'll update you on the case and who you'll be talking to—the attorney themselves or a paralegal. Ask whether they have a medical provider network they work with or whether you're free to choose your own doctors. Ask what happens if you disagree with a settlement offer they think you should take.
Ask whether they're licensed to practice in New York and whether they've ever been disciplined by the bar. You can verify this through the New York State Bar Association website. Ask for references from past clients if possible. A good attorney will answer these questions directly and won't pressure you to hire them on the spot.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a personal injury case usually take?
Most cases settle within 6 to 18 months, depending on how quickly your medical treatment finishes and how willing the insurance company is to negotiate. Cases that go to trial can take 2 to 4 years from the time you hire an attorney. Your attorney can give you a better timeline once they've reviewed your case.
What if I already talked to the insurance company before hiring an attorney?
Tell your attorney exactly what you said. Insurance adjusters are trained to get you to say things that can be used against you later. Your attorney can't undo what you've already said, but they can prevent you from saying anything else that hurts your case and can work around statements you've already made.
Can I still hire an attorney if the accident happened a long time ago?
New York has a statute of limitations—a important date for filing a lawsuit. For most personal injury cases, you have three years from the date of the injury. If you're close to that important date, contact an attorney when ready. Some cases have shorter important date, so don't wait.
What if the person who hurt me doesn't have insurance?
Your attorney can still pursue a claim against them personally, but collecting money from someone with no assets is difficult. If you have uninsured motorist coverage on your own auto policy, that may cover you. Your attorney will explore all options, but they'll also be honest about whether the case is worth pursuing.
Do I have to go to court or testify?
Most cases settle without trial, so you may never step foot in a courtroom. But if your case does go to trial, yes, you'll likely testify about what happened and how the injury has affected you. Your attorney will prepare you thoroughly for this.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.