Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Expect When You're Deposed as a Wrongful Death Plaintiff

What happens during a wrongful death plaintiff deposition

A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you sit across from the defendant's lawyer (and sometimes other lawyers) and answer questions under oath about the death, your relationship to the person who died, and the impact on you. The defendant's insurance company pays for it. A court reporter records everything you say, word for word, and creates a transcript that becomes part of the case file. You are not in a courtroom — depositions usually happen in a lawyer's office or conference room — but the oath is real, and lying carries the same legal consequences as lying in court.

The deposition serves two purposes for the other side: to lock in your story before trial (so they can catch you if you change it later) and to assess how you will perform in front of a jury. Your own lawyer will be there to object to improper questions and advise you, but you answer the questions, not your lawyer.

Most wrongful death depositions last two to four hours, though complex cases can run longer. You will be asked about the person who died, your financial losses, medical bills, funeral costs, and the emotional toll. The defendant's lawyer will also probe for weaknesses — inconsistencies in your account, gaps in your memory, or anything that might reduce the value a jury assigns to your claim.

Key Takeaways

  • A deposition is a recorded question-and-answer session under oath, held before trial, where the defendant's lawyer questions you about the death and its impact on you.
  • Your own lawyer attends and can object to improper questions, but you must answer the questions asked, not your lawyer.
  • The defendant's side uses the deposition to lock in your story and to see how credible and sympathetic you appear to a potential jury.
  • Preparation with your lawyer beforehand — reviewing documents, practicing answers, and understanding what topics will be covered — significantly affects how you perform.
  • Staying calm, answering only what is asked, and correcting yourself if you misspeak are more important than trying to persuade or win points during the deposition.

How to prepare for your deposition

Start by reviewing all documents related to the death and your losses: the death certificate, medical records, funeral invoices, insurance policies, emails, text messages, and any written communications with the defendant or their insurance company. Your lawyer will ask you to gather these before the deposition date. Bring originals or certified copies if you have them; the defendant's lawyer may ask to see them during the deposition.

Meet with your lawyer at least once, and ideally twice, before the deposition. In the first meeting, walk through the facts of the death chronologically — what you knew, when you knew it, and who told you. In the second meeting, do a practice run. Your lawyer or a colleague will play the defendant's lawyer and ask tough questions. This is uncomfortable, but it trains you to stay composed when challenged and to notice which topics trip you up or make you emotional.

Prepare a written summary of your financial losses: funeral and burial costs, medical bills from before death, lost wages if you had to take time off work, and ongoing costs like counseling or medication. Bring this summary to the deposition. The defendant's lawyer will ask for specific dollar amounts, and having documentation prevents you from guessing or overstating.

Write down the names, dates, and key facts you want to remember. You do not need to memorize them — you can refer to notes during the deposition — but reviewing them beforehand makes recall faster and more confident.

What the defendant's lawyer will ask about

Expect detailed questions about your relationship to the person who died: how long you knew them, how often you saw them, what you did together, and whether you had any conflicts. The lawyer is building a picture of how close you were, because that affects the damages a jury might award. If you were estranged or had not spoken in years, the defendant's side will emphasize that. If you were very close, your lawyer will want to highlight it.

You will be asked about the death itself: what you saw or heard, who told you what happened, when you learned the person had died, and how you found out. The defendant's lawyer will probe for inconsistencies between your account and police reports, witness statements, or medical examiner findings. If you do not remember something clearly, say so. Guessing or filling in gaps makes you look unreliable.

Financial questions will cover funeral and burial costs (bring receipts), medical bills, lost wages, and ongoing expenses like therapy or medication. The defendant's lawyer may challenge whether certain costs are reasonable or directly caused by the death. Be prepared to explain why each expense is necessary.

You will also be asked about your emotional state and daily life since the death: whether you sleep, eat, work, or socialize differently; whether you have sought counseling; and how the death has affected your relationships. The defendant's lawyer may suggest you are exaggerating or that your suffering is not as severe as you claim. Stay factual and avoid hyperbole.

How to answer questions effectively

Listen to the entire question before you answer. Do not interrupt or rush. If you do not understand what is being asked, say so and ask for clarification. A vague or confusing answer looks evasive, even if you meant well.

Answer only what is asked. If the lawyer asks "Did you attend the funeral?" say "Yes" or "No." Do not volunteer extra information or explain your reasoning unless asked. Extra details give the defendant's lawyer more material to challenge and can contradict something you say later.

If you do not know the answer, say "I do not know" or "I do not remember." Do not guess, estimate, or make something up. If you are not sure of a date or amount, say "approximately" or "I believe it was around [amount]." Admitting the limits of your memory is more credible than pretending certainty you do not have.

If you misspeak or realize your answer was wrong, correct yourself when ready. Say "I need to clarify what I just said" or "Actually, I misspoke — it was [correct version]." Correcting yourself on the record is far better than letting a wrong answer stand and having your lawyer try to fix it later.

Stay calm and neutral in tone. The defendant's lawyer may ask provocative questions or suggest you are lying or exaggerating. Do not get angry, defensive, or argumentative. A jury watching the deposition video will judge your credibility partly on how you handle pressure. Staying composed makes you look more trustworthy.

Topics the defendant's lawyer will use to challenge your claim

The defendant's side will look for any reason to reduce the value of your claim. Common attack angles include: whether you were actually financially dependent on the person who died, whether your emotional distress is as severe as you say, whether you have exaggerated your losses, and whether you have a financial motive to lie (for example, if you stand to inherit money or receive life insurance).

They may also challenge the causation chain — whether the defendant's actions actually caused the death, or whether other factors (the person's own health, a third party's conduct, or bad luck) were responsible. This is especially common in medical malpractice wrongful death cases. Your lawyer will have prepared you for these arguments, but expect them to come up.

If there are gaps in your memory or inconsistencies in your account, the defendant's lawyer will exploit them. They may show you documents that contradict something you said, or ask you to explain why your current account differs from something you said to police or to the insurance company months ago. This is why preparation and honesty are so important.

What your lawyer can and cannot do during the deposition

Your lawyer can object to questions that are improper — for example, questions that ask you to speculate about what someone else was thinking, questions that assume facts not in evidence, or questions that violate attorney-client privilege. When your lawyer objects, you do not have to answer that particular question. However, the defendant's lawyer can usually rephrase and ask again, and then you must answer.

Your lawyer can also advise you during breaks. If you are struggling with a line of questioning or need to clarify something, ask for a break and talk to your lawyer in private. Do not discuss your testimony with anyone else during breaks — not family members, not other witnesses, and not people in the waiting room.

Your lawyer cannot tell you to refuse to answer a question (except in rare circumstances involving privilege), and cannot coach you on what to say during the deposition itself. Your lawyer's role is to protect your legal rights, not to help you win points or persuade the other side.

After the deposition ends

The court reporter will send a transcript to all the lawyers within a few weeks. Your lawyer will review it and may ask you to review it too, to catch any transcription errors (the reporter may have misheard something). You can request corrections if the transcript is inaccurate, but you cannot change your answers.

The defendant's lawyer may use the deposition transcript to make a motion to dismiss the case or to argue for a lower settlement value. Your lawyer will use it to prepare for trial, to refresh your memory if the case goes to trial, and to support settlement negotiations. The transcript is also evidence — if your case goes to trial and you testify differently than you did at the deposition, the defendant's lawyer will show the jury the transcript to undermine your credibility.

After the deposition, stay in close contact with your lawyer. Do not discuss the case with anyone except your lawyer and when ready family. Do not post about it on social media. Anything you say can be discovered by the other side and used against you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I bring notes or documents to the deposition?

Yes. You can bring notes to refresh your memory, and you can refer to them while answering questions. However, the defendant's lawyer can ask to see any notes you use and can ask you questions about them. Bring only documents and notes that are accurate and that you are comfortable the other side seeing.

What if I get emotional during the deposition?

It is normal to become emotional when discussing the death of someone close to you. Take a break if you need one — ask your lawyer or the court reporter. Crying or showing emotion does not hurt your case, but try to stay composed enough to answer questions clearly. The defendant's lawyer may use visible emotion as evidence that you are unstable or exaggerating, so balance honesty about your feelings with composure.

Can the defendant attend my deposition?

Yes, the defendant can attend and usually does. You will be answering questions in front of the person (or their representative) you are suing. This is another reason to stay calm and professional — the defendant is watching and forming impressions of you that may affect settlement negotiations.

What happens if I contradict something I said in a police report or earlier statement?

The defendant's lawyer will point out the contradiction and ask you to explain it. If the contradiction is minor and you can explain it (for example, you misremembered a date), say so. If it is major, it damages your credibility. This is why preparation with your lawyer is so important — you should review all prior statements before the deposition and be ready to address any inconsistencies.

Do I have to answer questions about my personal life or finances unrelated to the death?

The defendant's lawyer can ask broad questions about your background, finances, and personal life if they are relevant to your claim — for example, your income, your employment history, or whether you have other sources of financial support. Your lawyer can object if the questions are too invasive or not reasonably related to the case, but the scope is fairly wide. Expect personal questions and answer honestly.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.