What Interrogatories Are and Why the Defense Sends Them in Wrongful Death Cases
What interrogatories are and why defendants use them in wrongful death cases
Interrogatories are written questions the defendant's lawyer sends to you (the plaintiff or your attorney) during the discovery phase of a lawsuit. In a wrongful death case, the defendant wants to understand your claim, the deceased person's background, your relationship to them, and the damages you are seeking. Interrogatories are one of the cheapest and fastest ways for the defense to gather this information before trial.
The defendant is not trying to be friendly. These questions are designed to lock you into specific answers, find contradictions, identify weaknesses in your case, and limit what you can say later. Every answer you give becomes part of the court record and can be used against you at trial or during settlement negotiations. This is why you should never answer interrogatories without your attorney reviewing them first.
Interrogatories are different from a deposition, where a lawyer asks you questions out loud and a court reporter records your answers. Interrogatories are written, you have time to think and consult your lawyer, and your attorney can object to questions that are improper or too broad. You typically have 30 days to respond, though your lawyer can ask for more time.
Key Takeaways
- Interrogatories are written questions from the defendant's lawyer that you must answer under oath, and your answers become evidence in the case.
- The defense uses interrogatories to learn details about the deceased, your relationship, how the death occurred, and what damages you are claiming.
- You have the right to object to questions that are vague, overly broad, ask for legal conclusions, or seek information protected by attorney-client privilege.
- Your attorney should review every interrogatory before you answer, because incomplete or careless answers can be used to undermine your case at trial.
- Failing to respond within the important date or refusing to answer without a valid objection can result in sanctions, including fines or dismissal of your case.
Common interrogatory topics in wrongful death cases
The defendant will ask about the deceased person's age, occupation, health history, and any prior injuries or illnesses. They want to know whether the person had pre-existing conditions that might have contributed to their death, or whether they were already at higher risk. This information helps the defense argue that the defendant's conduct was not the sole cause of death.
You will be asked about your relationship to the deceased—whether you were a spouse, parent, child, or other relative—and how often you saw them. The defense wants to establish whether you actually suffered emotional harm or lost companionship, or whether you are claiming damages you did not really experience. They may ask about the deceased's income, job title, and earning potential, because these numbers directly affect the financial damages you can recover.
Interrogatories will also ask you to describe exactly how the death occurred, what you know about the defendant's actions, and whether anyone else was involved. The defense is looking for inconsistencies between your account and what witnesses or documents say. They may ask whether the deceased was wearing a seatbelt, was under the influence, was following traffic laws, or took any action that contributed to their own death—anything that reduces the defendant's liability.
Finally, expect questions about your damages claim: how much money are you seeking, how did you calculate that number, what medical bills or funeral expenses did you incur, and what other losses are you claiming. The defense wants to know whether your damages are reasonable and well-documented, or whether you are inflating the numbers.
What you can and cannot object to
You do not have to answer every interrogatory. Your attorney can object on several grounds. If a question is vague or ambiguous—for example, "Tell us about the deceased's health"—your lawyer can object and ask the defendant to be more specific. If a question is overly broad—asking for information that has nothing to do with the case—you can object. If a question asks you to make a legal conclusion rather than state a fact—such as "Was the defendant negligent?"—that is objectionable.
Information protected by attorney-client privilege does not have to be disclosed. This means you do not have to answer questions about conversations with your lawyer or documents your lawyer created for the purpose of the lawsuit. Work product—materials prepared by your attorney in anticipation of litigation—is also protected and does not have to be turned over.
However, you cannot object straightforward because the answer is unfavorable or because you do not want to answer. You cannot refuse to answer because the question is difficult or because the answer might hurt your case. If you object without a valid reason, the court can order you to answer anyway, and the judge may penalize you for the delay.
How to prepare answers with your attorney
When your lawyer receives interrogatories, do not answer them yourself or talk to the defendant's lawyer directly. Sit down with your attorney and go through each question together. Your lawyer will explain what the defendant is really asking and why, and will help you understand how your answer might be used.
Be honest and accurate. Do not guess, estimate, or assume. If you do not know the answer to a question, say so—"I do not know" is a valid answer. If a question asks for information you do not have access to, tell your lawyer, and they may object or ask the defendant to provide the information instead. Do not try to be clever or evasive. Vague or incomplete answers often hurt you more than straightforward ones, because the defendant can argue that you are hiding something or that your case is weak.
Your attorney will also help you understand the scope of what you need to provide. Some interrogatories ask you to identify documents—for example, "Produce all medical records of the deceased." Your lawyer will tell you which documents you must gather and whether any are protected by privilege. This is part of the broader discovery process, and your failure to produce documents can result in serious penalties.
important date and consequences of not responding
You typically have 30 days from the date you receive the interrogatories to respond. Your attorney can request an extension, usually for another 30 days, if there is a good reason—for example, you need time to gather medical records or locate witnesses. The defendant's lawyer must agree to the extension, or your attorney must ask the court for one.
If you miss the important date without an extension, the defendant can file a motion to compel—a request to the court asking the judge to force you to answer. If the court grants the motion, you will have to answer the interrogatories, and you may also have to pay the defendant's attorney fees for the time they spent filing the motion. If you continue to refuse or delay, the judge can impose sanctions, which may include fines, striking your claims from the case, or even dismissing your entire lawsuit.
Responding late also weakens your negotiating position. If the defendant is trying to settle the case, they are less likely to offer a fair amount if you are not meeting your obligations or if they think you are disorganized. Courts also take missed important date seriously, and judges may view your failure to respond as a sign that your case is not solid.
How interrogatory answers affect settlement and trial
The defendant's lawyer will use your interrogatory answers to evaluate the strength of your case and decide whether to settle or go to trial. If your answers are detailed, consistent, and well-supported by documents, the defendant is more likely to offer a reasonable settlement. If your answers are vague, contradictory, or reveal weaknesses, the defendant will push for a lower offer or take the case to trial, betting that a jury will be skeptical of your claim.
At trial, the defendant's lawyer will use your interrogatory answers to cross-examine you. If you say something different in court than you said in your written answers, the lawyer will confront you with the interrogatory response and ask why you changed your story. This can seriously damage your credibility with the jury. Your attorney will prepare you for this during trial preparation, but the best defense is to give careful, accurate answers from the start.
Settlement negotiations often hinge on the information revealed in interrogatories, depositions, and document production. If the defendant learns that the deceased had a serious pre-existing condition, or that you did not actually suffer significant financial loss, they will use that information to argue for a lower settlement. Conversely, if your answers show that the defendant's conduct was clearly negligent and that your damages are substantial and well-documented, the defendant may be motivated to settle rather than risk a jury verdict.
Working with your attorney on strategy
Your lawyer's job is not just to answer the interrogatories, but to answer them in a way that supports your case. This does not mean being dishonest—it means being precise, complete, and strategic. For example, if a question asks "Describe the deceased's health," a weak answer is "He was healthy." A stronger answer is "The deceased was a 45-year-old male with no history of heart disease, no prior surgeries, and no chronic medications. He exercised regularly and had a normal BMI. His most recent physical examination, dated [date], showed no abnormalities."
Your attorney will also advise you on which objections to make. Sometimes it is better to object to a question that is too broad and offer to answer a narrower version instead. This shows the court that you are cooperating while protecting yourself from having to provide irrelevant information. Other times, your lawyer may advise you to answer a question even if it is somewhat unfavorable, because refusing to answer looks worse.
Keep in mind that interrogatories are just one part of discovery. The defendant will also take your deposition, request documents, and may send you requests for admission—statements they ask you to confirm or deny. Your attorney will coordinate your answers across all of these discovery tools to make sure your story is consistent and your case is as strong as possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse to answer an interrogatory if the answer will hurt my case?
No. You must answer interrogatories truthfully and completely, even if the answer is unfavorable. You can only object if the question is vague, overly broad, seeks privileged information, or asks for a legal conclusion. Refusing to answer without a valid objection can result in court sanctions, including fines or dismissal of your case.
What happens if I give an answer in interrogatories and then say something different at my deposition?
The defendant's lawyer will use the interrogatory answer to cross-examine you and challenge your credibility. You should review your interrogatory answers before your deposition so you can be consistent. If you have new information or realize your earlier answer was incomplete, tell your attorney when ready so they can explain the change to the court if necessary.
Do I have to answer interrogatories about conversations with my lawyer?
No. Conversations with your attorney and documents your attorney created for the purpose of the lawsuit are protected by attorney-client privilege and work product doctrine. Your lawyer will object to these questions on your behalf. However, you must still object formally in writing—you cannot straightforward refuse to answer.
What if I do not know the answer to an interrogatory?
Say so. "I do not know" is a complete and valid answer. However, if the information is reasonably available to you—for example, medical records of the deceased—you may need to obtain those records and provide the information. Your attorney will tell you whether you have a duty to investigate or gather documents to answer the question.
Can the defendant use my interrogatory answers against me at trial?
Yes. Your interrogatory answers are part of the court record and can be introduced as evidence at trial. The defendant can use them to cross-examine you, to impeach your credibility if you testify differently, or to support their own arguments. This is why it is critical to answer carefully and truthfully, with your attorney's guidance.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.