Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When and Why You Need an Expert Witness in a Wrongful Death Case

What an informed witness does in wrongful death cases

An informed witness is someone with professional credentials and experience who testifies about facts that require specialized knowledge—things a jury cannot reasonably understand without training. In wrongful death cases, experts explain how the death occurred, whether the defendant's actions caused it, and what damages the family should receive.

Unlike a regular witness who saw what happened, an informed witness interprets evidence. A medical examiner might testify about the cause of death. An accident reconstructionist might explain how a collision happened based on vehicle damage and road conditions. An economist might calculate lost earnings the deceased would have made. The informed's job is to help the jury understand technical or specialized information that matters to the case.

You do not automatically need an informed witness to file a wrongful death claim. But in most cases that go to trial, at least one informed is necessary. The defendant's lawyer will almost certainly hire experts to challenge your version of events, so your lawyer will need experts to counter those arguments.

Key Takeaways

  • informed witnesses testify about specialized topics like medical cause of death, accident mechanics, or financial losses—areas where a jury needs professional interpretation.
  • The type of informed you need depends on how the death occurred: medical experts for illness or injury, engineers for product defects, economists for lost earnings.
  • Experts must have relevant credentials, experience, and a track record of testifying; courts can exclude experts who lack these qualifications.
  • informed witnesses are expensive, typically costing thousands of dollars per case, so your lawyer should explain upfront whether one is necessary for your specific claim.
  • Your lawyer finds and hires the informed, not you; the informed works for your legal team and prepares testimony based on the evidence your lawyer provides.

Types of experts in wrongful death cases

The informed you need depends on the circumstances of the death. Medical malpractice wrongful death cases require a physician or surgeon in the same specialty as the defendant doctor—a cardiologist testifying about a cardiologist's error, for example. The medical informed reviews the deceased's medical records, explains what the standard of care required, and states whether the defendant fell below that standard.

Motor vehicle accidents typically need an accident reconstructionist—an engineer who analyzes vehicle damage, skid marks, traffic patterns, and physics to explain how the collision occurred and who was at fault. Some cases also need a biomechanical engineer to explain injury patterns and whether the injuries match the accident scenario.

Product liability wrongful death cases (a defective car part, medication, or appliance) require an engineer or scientist who can testify that the product was defective and that the defect caused the death. Workplace deaths often need an occupational safety informed to explain what safety measures should have been in place.

Nearly all wrongful death cases need an economist or financial informed to calculate the deceased's lost earnings, lost benefits, and lost household services. This informed reviews the deceased's work history, age, education, and earning potential to project what income the family lost.

How courts decide whether an informed can testify

Before an informed witness can testify at trial, the judge must decide the informed is may have access to and that their testimony is reliable. This is called a Daubert hearing in federal court and many state courts (named after a landmark case). The defendant's lawyer can challenge your informed, and the judge decides whether to allow the testimony.

Courts look at several factors: Does the informed have a relevant degree or certification? How many years of experience do they have? Have they testified in court before? Is their methodology sound—do they use methods that other experts in the field accept? Do they have financial incentives that might bias their opinion?

An informed with a medical degree, 15 years of practice, and 20 prior court appearances will pass scrutiny easily. An informed with no formal credentials, no courtroom experience, and a financial stake in the outcome may be excluded. Your lawyer should discuss the informed's qualifications before hiring them and should be prepared to defend those qualifications in court.

What experts cost and how to budget for them

informed witnesses charge for their time. A medical informed might charge $300 to $500 per hour for reviewing records and preparing a report, plus $2,000 to $5,000 per day for trial testimony. An accident reconstructionist might charge $200 to $400 per hour for investigation and analysis. An economist might charge $250 to $400 per hour. These rates vary widely by region, specialty, and the informed's experience level.

A straightforward case might need one informed and cost $5,000 to $15,000 total. A complex case with multiple experts can cost $50,000 or more. Your lawyer should give you a realistic estimate early on and explain which experts are necessary versus optional.

In some cases, your lawyer may work on contingency—meaning they take a percentage of any settlement or judgment rather than charging you upfront. When that happens, the lawyer typically pays informed costs from their own pocket and recovers them from the settlement. If you are paying your lawyer hourly, you usually pay informed costs separately as they are incurred.

How your lawyer finds and works with experts

Your lawyer maintains relationships with experts in different fields and knows which ones have strong credentials and courtroom experience. They may also use informed referral services or ask other lawyers for recommendations. You do not hire the informed directly; your lawyer does.

Once hired, the informed receives the case materials—medical records, police reports, photographs, depositions—and forms an independent opinion. Your lawyer does not tell the informed what conclusion to reach; the informed reaches their own conclusion based on the evidence. If the informed's opinion does not support your case, your lawyer needs to know that early so they can adjust strategy.

The informed typically prepares a written report explaining their findings and opinions. This report is shared with the defendant's lawyer before trial. The informed may also be deposed—questioned under oath by the defendant's lawyer—to test their opinions and credentials. At trial, your lawyer questions the informed first, then the defendant's lawyer cross-examines them.

When you might not need an informed witness

Some wrongful death cases settle before trial, and settlement negotiations may not require informed testimony. If liability is clear—the defendant admits fault or the evidence is overwhelming—you may not need an informed to prove causation. However, you will likely still need a financial informed to calculate damages, because the defendant will dispute the amount you are owed.

Cases involving obvious negligence sometimes proceed without experts. If a drunk driver killed someone, you may not need an accident reconstructionist; the police report and toxicology results may be enough. But if the defendant disputes fault or the cause of death is complex, an informed becomes necessary.

Your lawyer will advise you on whether experts are necessary for your specific case. This decision depends on the strength of your evidence, the complexity of the facts, and whether the defendant is likely to challenge key points.

Red flags when evaluating an informed

Be cautious of experts who testify in almost every case they are hired for, always reaching conclusions that favor whoever hired them. Courts notice this pattern and may exclude the informed or reduce their credibility. A good informed should be willing to say "the evidence does not support that conclusion" if that is what they find.

Avoid experts with financial conflicts of interest—someone who owns stock in a pharmaceutical company testifying about a drug's safety, for example. Courts scrutinize these relationships and may exclude the testimony or allow the defendant's lawyer to highlight the bias.

An informed should have actual experience in the field they are testifying about. A general physician should not testify about neurosurgery. An engineer who has never worked on product safety should not testify about a product defect. Your lawyer should verify the informed's background before hiring them.

Finally, be wary of experts who may provide a particular outcome or promise to "win" your case. Experts should offer opinions based on evidence, not guarantees. If an informed promises results, that is a sign they are not approaching the case objectively.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use an informed witness I know personally?

Technically yes, but it creates problems. Courts allow experts to testify even if they know the parties, but the defendant's lawyer will highlight the relationship to suggest bias. A neutral informed with no prior connection to your family is stronger. Your lawyer should hire someone based on qualifications and experience, not personal relationships.

What happens if the defendant's informed disagrees with mine?

This is normal. The jury hears both experts and decides which one is more credible. Your lawyer prepares you and your informed for cross-examination and may hire a second informed to reinforce your position if the disagreement is significant. The judge or jury weighs the competing opinions.

Do I have to disclose my informed before trial?

Yes. Discovery rules require both sides to exchange informed reports and credentials weeks or months before trial. This gives the defendant time to hire their own informed to challenge yours. Your lawyer handles this disclosure; you do not need to do anything.

What if I cannot afford an informed witness?

If your lawyer is working on contingency, they typically pay informed costs upfront and recover them from any settlement or judgment. If you are paying hourly, discuss the cost with your lawyer and ask whether the case can proceed without certain experts or whether a less expensive informed would be adequate for your situation.

Can an informed testify by video instead of in person?

Yes, especially for depositions and sometimes for trial testimony. Courts increasingly allow remote testimony, though some judges prefer in-person testimony for jury trials. Your lawyer will discuss this option with the informed and the court.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.