What to Expect When You're Deposed in a Wrongful Death Case
A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you give sworn testimony before the other side's lawyer
In a wrongful death case, a deposition is a recorded conversation where a lawyer asks you questions under oath about what you know regarding the death. You sit in a room (or now, often on video) with a court reporter who types everything said, the lawyer asking questions, and sometimes your own lawyer beside you. Nothing is decided at a deposition — it is not a trial. The purpose is for the other side to learn your account of events and to lock in what you say so they can compare it later to testimony or documents.
Depositions happen in civil cases, not criminal ones. If you are the surviving family member, you may be deposed by the defendant's lawyer or insurance company lawyer. If you are a witness to the death or events leading up to it, either side may depose you. The questions can feel invasive and the setting can feel hostile, but understanding what is happening and what you are required to do makes the experience less disorienting.
Key Takeaways
- You must answer questions truthfully under oath; lying in a deposition is perjury and carries criminal penalties.
- Your lawyer can object to questions that are illegal to ask, but you still must answer most questions even if they feel unfair or painful.
- You can ask for a break, ask for a question to be repeated, and say "I don't know" or "I don't remember" — you are not required to guess.
- The deposition transcript becomes part of the court record and can be used in trial, so your words matter even though no judge is present.
- Preparation with your lawyer before the deposition — reviewing documents, discussing likely topics, and practicing your answers — significantly reduces anxiety and mistakes.
What the other side's lawyer will ask about
The questions will focus on what you know about the death itself, the events that led to it, and your relationship to the person who died. If you are the surviving spouse or parent, expect questions about the deceased's health, habits, daily routine, and any prior injuries or medical conditions. The lawyer may ask about financial matters — income, debts, insurance policies, inheritance — because wrongful death damages include lost earnings and support. This can feel like they are trying to reduce the person's worth to a number. They are, in a sense, but that is how damages are calculated in civil law.
If you witnessed the death or the incident that caused it, questions will be much more specific: exactly where you were standing, what you saw and heard, what the lighting was like, whether you smelled anything, what you did when ready after. The lawyer will ask you to describe the same event multiple times, sometimes in different order, to see whether your account stays consistent. This is not a trick — it is standard practice. Honest people remember the same core facts the same way each time, even if small details shift.
You will also be asked about conversations: what the deceased said to you, what doctors or police told you, what you told others about the death. Some of these questions may be objectionable (your lawyer can say so), but many will be allowed even if they involve what someone else said, because the lawyer is trying to understand what information was available and when.
How to answer without hurting your case
The most important rule is: tell the truth. Do not exaggerate, do not guess, do not try to make your case sound better. If you do not know something, say "I don't know." If you do not remember, say "I don't remember." If you are not sure whether something happened before or after something else, say that. Vagueness is not perjury. Certainty that is false is.
Listen to the full question before you answer. Lawyers sometimes ask compound questions — "Did you see him fall and did you call 911?" — and you need to answer each part. If you do not understand a question, ask the lawyer to rephrase it. If your lawyer objects to a question, pause and let them finish the objection before you answer. In most cases you will still have to answer even after an objection, but your lawyer's objection becomes part of the record.
Do not volunteer information beyond what was asked. If the lawyer asks "What time did you arrive at the hospital?" answer with the time, not with a story about the drive or the waiting room. Extra details give the other side more material to work with and can make you sound defensive or rehearsed. Speak in plain language. Do not use medical jargon unless you are a medical professional, and do not use legal language — just describe what you saw and know in your own words.
If you need a break, ask for one. You can say "I need a few minutes" and step out of the room. The court reporter will note the break in the transcript. Staying calm and clear is more important than rushing through.
Questions about your damages claim and financial situation
The defendant's lawyer will ask detailed questions about money: the deceased's income, your lost financial support, medical bills, funeral costs, and your own financial situation. They may ask what insurance policies existed, what the will said, whether you received any inheritance, and what you expect to receive from this case. These questions are legal and you must answer them, even though they feel intrusive.
Bring documents to the deposition if your lawyer tells you to — pay stubs, medical bills, funeral invoices, bank statements. The lawyer may ask you to identify them and explain them. If you do not have a document with you, you can say so, and your lawyer can arrange to provide it later. Do not guess at numbers. If you do not remember the exact amount of a bill, say "I don't remember the exact amount, but I have the invoice" or "approximately $X."
The purpose of these questions is not to be cruel. The defendant's insurance company will use this information to calculate what they think the case is worth. Your honest answers about real losses — lost income, funeral costs, medical care — support your claim. Inflated or invented losses undermine it.
What your lawyer can and cannot do during the deposition
Your lawyer sits beside you or across the table. They can object to questions that violate rules of evidence — for example, questions asking you to guess what someone else was thinking, or questions about conversations protected by attorney-client privilege. When your lawyer objects, the court reporter notes it and the other lawyer usually asks the question anyway. You then answer it (unless your lawyer instructs you not to, which is rare). Your lawyer's objection protects your right to challenge the question later in court if needed.
Your lawyer cannot tell you what to say or coach you during the deposition itself. They can take a break and talk to you privately, but during the questioning you are on your own. This is why preparation beforehand matters so much. Your lawyer should review likely topics with you, show you documents you will be asked about, and discuss how to handle difficult questions. Some lawyers do a mock deposition — they ask you the hard questions so you are not hearing them for the first time from the other side's lawyer.
Your lawyer can also ask you questions after the other lawyer finishes. This is called "redirect" and gives you a chance to clarify something or provide context that was missing. Use this time to correct any misunderstanding, but do not use it to argue or to add new complaints.
After the deposition: transcript review and corrections
The court reporter will prepare a written transcript of everything said. You will receive a copy and have the chance to read it and note any errors — places where you were misheard or where the transcript is unclear. You can note corrections on a form called an "errata sheet." These corrections become part of the record. Do not use the errata sheet to change your testimony or to add new information; use it only to fix transcription errors (the reporter typed "he" when you said "she," for example).
Your lawyer will review the transcript with you and discuss what it means for your case. The transcript is now part of the discovery process and will be available to the judge and jury if the case goes to trial. If you settle before trial, the deposition transcript may not be used publicly, but it will have informed the settlement negotiations.
Preparing for your deposition: what to do before the date
Meet with your lawyer at least once, ideally twice, before the deposition. Bring any documents related to the death, the incident, your relationship to the deceased, and your losses — medical records, funeral bills, pay stubs, insurance policies, emails, text messages, photos. Your lawyer will review these with you and explain which ones you will likely be asked about.
Discuss the timeline of events. Write down dates and times if you can, or at least the order of what happened. The other lawyer will ask you to be specific, and if you have thought through the timeline beforehand you will be less likely to contradict yourself.
Talk with your lawyer about the hardest topics — the moment of death, your grief, your financial struggles since the death. These conversations are difficult but they prepare you emotionally for the deposition. Your lawyer can also tell you which questions you might be asked that are designed to provoke an emotional reaction, and how to stay composed.
Dress professionally and arrive early. Bring water and any medications you need. Get enough sleep the night before. These practical steps reduce stress and help you think clearly during the questioning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse to answer a question at my deposition?
In almost all cases, no. Your lawyer can object to a question, but you must still answer it unless your lawyer tells you not to (which is rare and usually only for questions protected by attorney-client privilege or spousal privilege). Refusing to answer can result in the judge ordering you to answer, or in sanctions against you or your lawyer.
What if I cry or get angry during the deposition?
It is normal and human to have an emotional reaction when discussing the death of someone you loved. Take a break if you need one. The court reporter will note the break in the transcript. Do not apologize for your emotions or try to hide them, but do try to regain your composure so you can answer questions clearly.
Can the defendant's lawyer use my deposition testimony against me at trial?
Yes. The transcript can be read to the jury, or video of the deposition can be played. This is why accuracy and honesty matter — your words at the deposition become evidence. If your trial testimony contradicts your deposition testimony, the other side will point that out to undermine your credibility.
Do I have to answer questions about my personal life or medical history?
Most personal questions are allowed if they relate to your credibility or to your damages claim. Questions about your mental health, substance use, or criminal history may be asked. Your lawyer can object if a question is too invasive or not relevant, but you will likely still have to answer. If you are uncomfortable, say so, but answer the question.
What happens if I make a mistake or say something wrong during the deposition?
You can correct yourself during the deposition — say "Actually, I misspoke" and give the correct answer. You can also note the error on the errata sheet after you receive the transcript. If the error is significant and you did not catch it, your lawyer can address it with the judge before trial, but it is better to get it right the first time.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.