What Happens During Wrongful Death Mediation
Mediation is a structured conversation where a neutral third party helps you and the defendant's insurance company reach a settlement without going to trial.
In wrongful death mediation, you sit down with the other side—usually the defendant's lawyer and insurance adjuster—in the presence of a mediator. The mediator does not decide who is right or wrong. Instead, they listen to both sides, ask questions to find common ground, and shuttle offers back and forth between you and the defendant until either a settlement number emerges or both sides agree they cannot reach one. Most wrongful death cases that settle do so through mediation rather than trial.
Mediation happens after your lawyer has gathered evidence—medical records, police reports, witness statements, and sometimes informed opinions about how the death occurred and what your financial losses are. By this point, both sides have a clearer picture of the case's strength. The insurance company knows what a jury might award; you know what risks you face if you go to trial. Mediation is where those realities meet.
Key Takeaways
- Mediation is voluntary, confidential, and either side can walk away if no settlement is reached.
- You will need to present your damages—lost income, funeral costs, loss of companionship—with documentation to support each number.
- The mediator will likely separate you and the defendant into different rooms and carry settlement offers between you.
- Most mediations last a full day, and you should expect the process to involve multiple rounds of negotiation.
- Anything you say during mediation cannot be used in court if the case does not settle and goes to trial.
Before Mediation: What Your Lawyer Will Ask You to Prepare
Your attorney will ask you to gather and organize your damages—the financial and non-financial losses caused by the death. For a wrongful death claim, this typically includes funeral and burial expenses (receipts), the deceased's lost wages (pay stubs, tax returns, employment letters), medical bills from any period between injury and death, and household expenses the deceased would have paid. You will also need to think through non-economic damages: the loss of the person's companionship, guidance, and emotional support to you and other family members.
Your lawyer will prepare a mediation statement—a written summary of the case that goes to the mediator and the other side before the session. This document lays out the facts of how the death occurred, the defendant's responsibility, and your damages with supporting numbers. It is your chance to frame the case persuasively without the pressure of live negotiation. The defendant will submit their own statement, arguing their version of events and why damages should be lower.
You should also prepare yourself emotionally and mentally. Mediation can be exhausting. You may hear the other side blame the deceased, minimize the harm, or dispute your numbers. Your lawyer will coach you on how to stay focused on settlement rather than getting drawn into arguments about fault.
How the Mediation Day Itself Works
Mediation typically begins with everyone in one room. The mediator explains the process, sets ground rules (usually that no one will interrupt), and asks each side to give an opening statement. Your lawyer will speak first, describing the death, the defendant's responsibility, and your family's losses. The defendant's lawyer will follow with their version. This is not a debate—each side presents their case, and then the mediator separates you into different rooms.
Once separated, you and the defendant will not see each other again during mediation. The mediator moves between rooms, carrying settlement offers. You might start in one room with your lawyer, the defendant in another with theirs. The mediator will ask you what number you believe the case is worth, listen to your reasoning, and then go to the other room to present that number and hear their response. They will come back to you with a counteroffer, and the process repeats.
This back-and-forth can take hours. Offers may move in small increments—$5,000 or $10,000 at a time—or in larger jumps if both sides sense movement toward a middle ground. The mediator's job is to keep both sides talking and to identify the range where settlement might happen. If the gap between your demand and their offer narrows enough, a settlement can emerge. If the gap stays wide after many rounds, the mediator may declare an impasse and end the session.
What the Insurance Company Will Challenge
The defendant's insurance adjuster and lawyer will scrutinize every number you present. They will question whether funeral costs were reasonable, whether the deceased's lost wages are calculated correctly, and whether your non-economic damages are too high. They may argue that the deceased had pre-existing health conditions that contributed to the death, or that the defendant's actions were not the sole cause. They will also research your family's financial situation to argue that your loss of companionship damages should be lower.
This is normal and expected. The mediator will relay these challenges to you, and your lawyer will help you respond with evidence. If you claimed the deceased earned $60,000 per year, bring tax returns and a letter from their employer. If you claimed funeral costs of $8,000, bring the funeral home invoice. If you claim loss of companionship, be ready to describe the deceased's role in your life—were they your parent, spouse, or child? How often did you see them? What did they do for you? The more specific and documented your damages, the harder it is for the other side to dismiss them.
Settlement Offers and When to Accept or Reject
At some point during mediation, the insurance company will make an offer—a dollar amount they are willing to pay to settle the case. Your lawyer will advise you on whether that offer is reasonable given the strength of your case, the risks of trial, and the time and cost of continuing to litigate. This is a critical moment, and it requires honest conversation between you and your attorney.
Your lawyer should explain what a jury might award based on similar cases, what percentage of cases like yours go to trial versus settle, and how long a trial would take. They should also remind you that if you reject the offer and go to trial, you might win more—or you might win less, or nothing at all. Juries are unpredictable. A settlement locks in a known amount; trial is a gamble.
You have the final say on whether to accept or reject an offer. Your lawyer cannot force you to settle, and you cannot force your lawyer to reject a reasonable offer and take the case to trial if they believe it is not in your interest. If you and your lawyer disagree strongly, you have the right to hire a different attorney, though doing so late in the process can be costly and time-consuming.
If Mediation Does Not Reach a Settlement
If after a full day of mediation the gap between your demand and the defendant's offer is still too wide, the mediator will declare an impasse. This does not mean your case is over. It means mediation did not work this time. Your case will continue through the litigation process: more discovery (exchange of documents and witness statements), possibly depositions (recorded testimony), and eventually trial if no settlement is reached.
Some cases go to mediation more than once. After additional discovery or informed reports, both sides may have new information that changes their view of the case's value. A second mediation session, scheduled weeks or months later, sometimes succeeds where the first one did not. Your lawyer will advise you on whether a second mediation makes sense.
Importantly, nothing you said during mediation can be used against you in court. Mediation is confidential. If you made an offer of $500,000 and the defendant rejected it, that offer cannot be introduced at trial to argue that you thought your case was only worth $500,000. This confidentiality is designed to encourage both sides to speak openly during mediation without fear of later consequences.
Costs and Who Pays for Mediation
Mediation costs money. The mediator charges an hourly rate, typically between $150 and $400 per hour depending on their experience and location. A full-day mediation might cost $1,200 to $3,200 total. In many wrongful death cases, the defendant's insurance company agrees to split the mediator's fee with you as part of the mediation agreement. Sometimes the defendant pays the full cost. Your lawyer will negotiate this before mediation begins.
You will also pay your lawyer's hourly rate for their time at mediation, unless you have a contingency fee agreement (where your lawyer takes a percentage of any settlement or judgment instead of hourly fees). If you are on contingency, your lawyer's mediation time is built into that percentage, so you do not pay extra.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to attend mediation in person, or can I participate by video or phone?
Many mediators now offer remote mediation, especially after the pandemic made it common. You can ask your lawyer to request a virtual session. Some mediators believe in-person mediation is more effective because body language and tone matter, but if travel is difficult or expensive, remote mediation is a reasonable alternative. The mediator and both lawyers must agree.
What if I get emotional during mediation and need to take a break?
Mediation can bring up painful memories and strong feelings. Tell your lawyer or the mediator if you need a break. The mediator will pause the session, and you can step outside, take time to compose yourself, and return when you are ready. This is normal and expected in wrongful death cases.
Can I bring family members to mediation with me?
Yes, you can bring a spouse, adult child, or other close family member for emotional support. They will sit in your room with you and your lawyer. However, they should not speak during mediation unless the mediator asks them to. Your lawyer will do the talking. Too many voices can complicate negotiations.
What happens if we reach a settlement at mediation?
If both sides agree on a number, the mediator will prepare a settlement agreement—a document that outlines the amount, when you will receive it, and any conditions (such as confidentiality or a release of claims). You and your lawyer will review it carefully before you sign. Once signed, the case is closed, and the insurance company will send the settlement funds within the timeframe stated in the agreement, usually 30 to 60 days.
Can the mediator recommend a settlement number?
Some mediators will offer a non-binding evaluation of what they think the case is worth based on what they have heard from both sides. This is called a mediator's evaluation or mediator's assessment. It is not binding—neither side has to accept it—but it can help break a deadlock if both sides trust the mediator's judgment. Ask your lawyer whether requesting an evaluation makes sense in your case.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.