What Happens When You're Deposed in a Wrongful Death Case
What a deposition is and why you'll give one
A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you testify under oath before a court reporter, but not in front of a judge or jury. In a wrongful death case, you may be deposed if you have knowledge about the death, the person who died, the defendant's conduct, or the harm the family suffered. The other side's lawyer asks the questions; your own lawyer sits with you and can object to certain questions, but cannot answer for you.
Depositions happen during the discovery phase—the period before trial when both sides gather evidence and information from each other. The defendant's insurance company and their lawyer use your deposition to understand your case, find weaknesses in your account, and preserve your testimony in written form. If the case settles before trial, your deposition may never be used. If it goes to trial, portions of it can be read aloud to the jury or played as video.
You will be deposed if you are the plaintiff (the family member suing), a witness to the death or the events leading to it, a family member testifying about the deceased's character or the family's losses, or an informed witness (such as a medical examiner or economist) hired by your side. The defendant and their witnesses will also be deposed by your lawyer.
Key Takeaways
- A deposition is a recorded question-and-answer session under oath, conducted by the other side's lawyer before trial, with a court reporter present to create a transcript.
- You must answer truthfully and completely; lying under oath is perjury and can result in criminal charges, regardless of whether the case settles or goes to trial.
- Your lawyer can object to improper questions and advise you not to answer certain ones, but cannot tell you what answer to give or answer on your behalf.
- Preparation with your lawyer before the deposition—reviewing documents, discussing likely questions, and understanding the case timeline—significantly affects how clearly and confidently you testify.
- The transcript becomes part of the court record and can be used to impeach your testimony at trial if your answers change, so consistency and accuracy matter more than speed or certainty.
How to prepare with your lawyer before the deposition
Meet with your lawyer at least one week before the deposition, longer if possible. Bring any documents you have: medical records, funeral bills, photographs, text messages, emails, or notes about conversations with the deceased or witnesses. Your lawyer will review the case timeline with you—when the death occurred, what led to it, what you observed, and what you learned afterward. Walk through the facts in order so you can answer questions about dates, locations, and sequences of events without hesitation.
Your lawyer will explain what the other side's lawyer is trying to accomplish and what questions are likely to come. They will ask you practice questions, often tough ones, so you experience the pressure in a safe setting. This is not about coaching you to change your story; it is about making sure you understand what you know, what you do not know, and how to say it clearly. If you do not remember something, say so. If you are unsure, say so. Guessing or exaggerating will be caught and used against you.
Review any documents the other side has already sent to your lawyer—police reports, medical examiner's findings, witness statements, or the defendant's own account. Know what is in them and where your testimony agrees or differs. If you disagree with something in a document, be ready to explain why and what your basis is for disagreeing.
What the other side's lawyer will ask and how to answer
The defendant's lawyer will ask about your relationship to the deceased, what you witnessed or learned about the death, the defendant's actions or negligence, the deceased's health or habits, your family's financial situation, and the losses your family suffered. They will also ask about any statements you have made to others, any prior lawsuits or claims you have filed, and anything that might suggest your testimony is biased or unreliable.
Answer only the question asked. If the lawyer asks "Did you see the defendant that day?" answer yes or no, then stop. Do not volunteer extra information, explain your reasoning, or tell a longer story unless the lawyer asks you to. Long answers give the other side more material to pick apart and more chances to catch you in an inconsistency. If you do not understand a question, say so and ask the lawyer to rephrase it. If you need a moment to think, take it—silence is fine, and rushing leads to mistakes.
If your lawyer objects to a question, listen to the objection. If the lawyer says "You don't have to answer that," do not answer. If the lawyer objects but says "You can answer," then answer. Never argue with the other side's lawyer or become defensive. Stay calm, speak clearly, and remember that the court reporter is writing down everything you say—including sighs, pauses, and tone of voice that suggest you are uncertain or evasive.
What happens if you do not remember or do not know
Saying "I do not remember" or "I do not know" is always better than guessing. The other side's lawyer will often ask the same question in different ways to see if your answer changes. If you say "I do not know" the first time and then answer the question the second time, you will look unreliable. If you say "I do not know" both times, you are consistent and credible.
If a document refreshes your memory—meaning the lawyer shows you something written at the time that helps you recall what happened—you can change your answer. Say "Looking at this document, I now remember that..." and give the corrected answer. This is normal and does not hurt your credibility; it shows you are trying to be accurate.
If the lawyer asks you to estimate something—a distance, a time, a dollar amount—give your best estimate and say it is an estimate. Do not pretend to know something you do not. For example: "I would estimate the distance was about 50 feet, but I am not certain" is far better than "It was exactly 50 feet."
How your deposition can be used later
The court reporter will create a transcript—a word-for-word record of everything said during the deposition. Both your lawyer and the other side's lawyer receive a copy. If the case goes to trial, the other side can read portions of your deposition aloud to the jury or play a video recording of you testifying. Your own lawyer can also use your deposition to refresh your memory before you testify at trial, or to show the jury that your trial testimony is consistent with what you said under oath earlier.
If your trial testimony contradicts what you said at the deposition, the other side will use the transcript to impeach you—to show the jury that you are unreliable or dishonest. This is one reason accuracy and consistency matter more than certainty. If you said at the deposition "I think the light was red" and then testify at trial "The light was definitely red," the other side will highlight the change and suggest you are making things up as you go.
If the case settles before trial, your deposition may never be seen by a judge or jury. But it still exists in the court file and can be reviewed by insurance adjusters, mediators, or the other side's lawyer if a dispute arises later about what was agreed to.
What you must not do during a deposition
Do not lie or exaggerate. You are under oath, and perjury—lying under oath—is a crime. It can result in criminal charges, fines, and jail time, separate from the civil case itself. Insurance companies and defense lawyers investigate witnesses who seem dishonest, and juries notice inconsistencies. The truth, even if it hurts your case, is always safer than a lie.
Do not let your lawyer coach you on what answer to give. Your lawyer can advise you on how to answer clearly and truthfully, but cannot tell you to say something false or to hide information. If your lawyer asks you to do that, you have the right to refuse and to ask for a different lawyer.
Do not argue with the other side's lawyer, become angry, or refuse to answer questions your lawyer has not objected to. These behaviors make you look guilty or unreliable, even if you are neither. Stay professional and calm, no matter how aggressive or rude the other side's lawyer becomes.
Do not discuss the deposition with other witnesses or family members before their depositions are finished. The other side may ask them what you told them, and if your accounts differ, it will look like you coordinated your stories. Wait until all depositions are complete before comparing notes.
The role of your lawyer during the deposition
Your lawyer sits next to you during the deposition and can object to questions that are improper—for example, questions that ask you to guess about what someone else was thinking, questions that misstate facts already established, or questions that ask for information protected by attorney-client privilege. When your lawyer objects, the court reporter notes the objection in the transcript, but you still answer the question unless your lawyer tells you not to.
Your lawyer cannot coach you during the deposition itself or tell you what answer to give. They can take a break and talk to you privately if they believe the other side is asking improper questions repeatedly or if you seem confused. They can also clarify the record if they believe a question was misunderstood or if your answer was incomplete.
After the deposition, your lawyer will review the transcript with you to make sure it is accurate. If there are errors—words the court reporter misheard—you can file corrections. Your lawyer will also use the deposition to refine the case strategy, identify weak points that need more evidence, and prepare you for trial testimony if the case does not settle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I bring documents or notes to the deposition to help me remember?
You can bring documents that existed before the deposition—medical records, emails, photographs, or your own contemporaneous notes. You cannot bring a script or outline prepared by your lawyer specifically for the deposition. If you refer to a document during the deposition, the other side's lawyer can ask to see it and may introduce it as evidence.
What if I say something at the deposition that I later realize was wrong?
Tell your lawyer when ready. If the error is significant and the case goes to trial, your lawyer can address it during your trial testimony by explaining the mistake and correcting it. The other side will likely use the deposition transcript to show the inconsistency, but your lawyer can argue that the correction shows you are trying to be accurate, not that you are dishonest.
How long does a deposition usually take?
Depositions in wrongful death cases typically last between two and six hours, depending on how much the other side's lawyer needs to know and how detailed your answers are. Complex cases with multiple witnesses or significant damages may involve longer depositions. Your lawyer can usually estimate the length based on the case complexity.
Can the other side use my deposition against me if I do not testify at trial?
Yes. If you do not testify at trial, the other side can read your deposition testimony aloud to the jury or play a video of it. Your lawyer can also use it the same way. This is one reason depositions are taken—to preserve testimony in case a witness cannot or will not appear at trial.
What happens if I refuse to answer a question at the deposition?
If your lawyer has not objected and told you not to answer, refusing to answer can result in a court order forcing you to answer, sanctions against your case, or even contempt of court charges. If your lawyer has objected and instructed you not to answer, the other side can ask the judge to compel you to answer, and the judge will decide whether the question is proper.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.