Why Wrongful Death Cases Are Civil, Not Criminal — And What That Means for You
Wrongful death lawsuits are civil cases, not criminal ones
A wrongful death lawsuit is always a civil matter. You sue in civil court, the burden of proof is lower than in criminal court, and the remedy is money damages — not jail time or criminal penalties. This is true even when the death resulted from conduct that could also be prosecuted as a crime, like drunk driving or assault.
The key difference: a criminal case is brought by the government (a prosecutor or district attorney) to punish someone for breaking the law. A civil case is brought by a private party (usually the deceased person's family) to recover money for their losses. These are separate legal systems with separate rules, separate courts, and separate outcomes.
Understanding this distinction matters because it shapes what you can recover, what evidence you need, how long the case takes, and whether a criminal conviction — or lack of one — affects your civil claim.
Key Takeaways
- Wrongful death is a civil lawsuit where the family sues for money damages, not a criminal prosecution where the government seeks punishment.
- You can file a wrongful death civil case even if no criminal charges were filed or even if the defendant was acquitted in criminal court.
- The civil standard of proof is "preponderance of the evidence" (more likely than not), which is much lower than the criminal standard of "beyond a reasonable doubt."
- A criminal conviction can strengthen your civil case, but it is not required — you can win a wrongful death lawsuit based on civil evidence alone.
- Money damages in civil court are the only remedy available; the defendant will not face jail time or criminal penalties from a wrongful death lawsuit.
How civil and criminal cases differ in wrongful death situations
When someone dies due to another person's negligence or intentional conduct, two separate legal paths can unfold — and they operate independently of each other.
In a criminal case, a prosecutor decides whether to charge the defendant with a crime like vehicular homicide, manslaughter, or murder. The government bears the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt — a very high standard. If convicted, the defendant faces prison time, fines, probation, or other criminal penalties. If acquitted, the defendant cannot be retried for the same conduct (double jeopardy protection).
In a civil wrongful death case, the deceased person's family (or estate) sues the defendant directly. The family must prove the defendant's conduct caused the death, but only by a preponderance of the evidence — meaning it is more likely than not that the defendant was responsible. If the family wins, the defendant pays money damages. If they lose, the defendant pays nothing. There is no criminal penalty, no jail time, and no double jeopardy — the family can sue even if the defendant was acquitted in criminal court.
This separation is intentional. Criminal law protects society by punishing wrongdoing. Civil law compensates victims for their losses. They serve different purposes and use different standards of proof.
Why a criminal conviction is not required to win a wrongful death case
Many families assume they need a criminal conviction to win a wrongful death lawsuit. They do not. A civil case stands on its own, with its own evidence and its own lower standard of proof.
Imagine a car accident where the driver was speeding and ran a red light, killing a pedestrian. The prosecutor might decline to file criminal charges because the evidence does not meet the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard — perhaps there are no witnesses, or the traffic light timing is unclear. But the family can still file a wrongful death civil suit. The same evidence that was insufficient for criminal court may be enough for civil court, where the standard is straightforward "more likely than not."
Conversely, a defendant might be acquitted in criminal court (found not guilty) and still lose a wrongful death civil case. The jury in criminal court may have had reasonable doubt, but the civil jury may find it more likely than not that the defendant was responsible. This happens regularly in high-profile cases.
The reverse is also true: a criminal conviction makes a civil case much easier to win, because the conviction is often admissible as evidence in the civil lawsuit. But it is not a prerequisite.
The burden of proof difference and why it matters
The difference between "beyond a reasonable doubt" and "preponderance of the evidence" is the single most important factor in understanding why wrongful death cases are civil, not criminal.
Beyond a reasonable doubt means the jury must be nearly certain — typically described as 95% or higher confidence — that the defendant committed the crime. It is a very high bar. Prosecutors must eliminate reasonable doubt, not just show the defendant probably did it.
Preponderance of the evidence means the evidence tips the scales in your favor — 51% confidence is enough. If the jury thinks it is more likely than not that the defendant's conduct caused the death, you win. This is the same standard used in most civil cases, from contract disputes to car accidents.
This lower standard exists because civil cases involve money, not freedom. A defendant who loses a civil case pays damages; they do not go to prison. The law treats the risk of a wrongful judgment differently when liberty is at stake versus when money is at stake.
What happens if there is a criminal case and a civil case at the same time
In some situations, both a criminal prosecution and a civil wrongful death lawsuit proceed simultaneously or in sequence. They remain separate, but they can affect each other strategically.
If the criminal case goes first and results in a conviction, that conviction is often admissible in the civil case and makes the family's job much easier. The defendant has already been found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, so proving liability by a preponderance of the evidence is straightforward.
If the criminal case results in acquittal, the family can still pursue the civil case. The acquittal does not prevent a civil suit, and it does not prevent a civil judgment against the same defendant. The defendant's lawyer will argue that the acquittal shows innocence, but the civil jury is free to reach a different conclusion based on the lower standard of proof.
If the criminal case has not been filed or is still pending, the family usually proceeds with the civil case anyway. Many families do not wait for a criminal outcome; they file the civil suit to preserve evidence, meet statutes of limitations, and begin recovering damages. The civil case may actually move faster than the criminal case, since criminal cases often take years.
What you can recover in a civil wrongful death case
Because wrongful death is a civil matter, the only remedy is money. The defendant will not face jail time, criminal fines, or probation — only a judgment to pay damages to the family.
Damages in a wrongful death case typically include:
- Economic losses: medical bills from the final illness or injury, funeral and burial costs, lost wages the deceased would have earned, and lost financial support the family depended on.
- Non-economic losses: pain and suffering of the deceased (in some states), loss of companionship, loss of parental guidance, and emotional distress to surviving family members.
- Punitive damages: in some cases where the defendant's conduct was especially reckless or intentional, the court may award extra damages to punish the defendant and deter similar conduct. These are rare and vary by state.
The amount varies widely depending on the deceased person's age, earning capacity, family situation, and the nature of the defendant's conduct. There is no fixed formula, and damages are determined by a jury or, in some cases, a settlement agreement.
When you might need a lawyer for a wrongful death case
Wrongful death cases are complex civil lawsuits that almost always require a lawyer. The family must prove causation (that the defendant's conduct caused the death), identify all responsible parties, navigate insurance claims, and present evidence to a jury. These are not tasks for someone without legal training.
Most wrongful death lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of the settlement or judgment (usually 25% to 40%) and charge no upfront fee. This makes legal representation accessible even when the family cannot afford to pay hourly rates.
A lawyer will also help you understand the statute of limitations in your state — the important date for filing a wrongful death suit. These important date vary by state and can be as short as one or two years from the date of death. Missing the important date means losing the right to sue entirely.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue someone for wrongful death if they were not charged with a crime?
Yes. Criminal charges and civil lawsuits are separate. A prosecutor might decline to file charges, or charges might be dismissed, but you can still file a wrongful death civil suit based on the same facts. The civil standard of proof is lower, so you may succeed even if the prosecutor did not have enough evidence for a criminal case.
What if the person who caused the death was found not guilty in criminal court?
You can still file a wrongful death civil case. An acquittal in criminal court does not prevent a civil lawsuit or prevent a civil judgment. The civil jury uses a different standard of proof and may reach a different conclusion. This has happened in several high-profile cases.
How long does a wrongful death lawsuit take?
Civil wrongful death cases typically take one to three years from filing to settlement or trial, though complex cases can take longer. Criminal cases often take much longer. Many families settle before trial, which speeds up the process. Your lawyer can give you a more specific timeline based on the facts of your case.
Do I have to wait for a criminal case to finish before suing?
No. You can file a civil wrongful death suit while a criminal case is pending, or even if no criminal case has been filed. Many families do not wait because the statute of limitations for civil suits is often shorter than the time it takes to resolve a criminal case.
What is the difference between a wrongful death case and a personal injury case?
A personal injury case is brought by an injured person for their own damages. A wrongful death case is brought by the deceased person's family or estate for losses caused by the death. The legal standards are similar, but wrongful death cases involve different damages — loss of companionship, lost financial support, and funeral costs rather than the injured person's medical bills and pain and suffering.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.