Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Compare Wrongful Death Lawyers in Texas by Track Record and Results

What "Success Rate" Actually Means When You're Comparing Wrongful Death Lawyers

A lawyer's success rate in wrongful death cases is not a single number you can look up. Different lawyers track and report their results in different ways, and what one firm calls a "win" another might not count the same way. Before you compare lawyers, you need to understand what you're actually measuring: settlements reached, cases that went to trial and won, cases dismissed or lost, and the dollar amounts recovered in each category.

Texas wrongful death cases settle far more often than they go to trial. A lawyer who settles 95 percent of cases might have a higher average payout per case than one who takes 40 percent to trial—or the opposite, depending on the cases involved. The lawyer's website or marketing materials might emphasize trial wins, but most of your case will likely never see a courtroom. You need to know what the lawyer actually does in the settlement phase, where most wrongful death cases end.

When a lawyer tells you their success rate, ask them to define it: Do they count only cases that went to verdict? Do they include settlements? Do they exclude cases they turned down? Do they count cases where they recovered something but less than the family wanted? The answer matters because it changes what the number means.

Key Takeaways

  • Success rates are not standardized—ask each lawyer to define what they count as a success and whether that includes settlements, trials, or both.
  • Texas State Bar records show disciplinary history and bar status, but not case outcomes; you must ask the lawyer directly for their track record.
  • Average settlement amounts and trial verdicts matter more than win percentages, because most wrongful death cases settle rather than go to trial.
  • Request specific case examples from the past three to five years in fact patterns similar to yours, not just a general success rate number.
  • A lawyer's experience in the specific type of death (vehicle, workplace, medical) and the specific county where your case would be filed affects their actual track record there.

What Information You Can Find Through Official Texas Records

The State Bar of Texas maintains a public database where you can look up any licensed lawyer's bar status, disciplinary history, and whether they are in good standing. This is not a success rate—it is a record of complaints, suspensions, or disbarment. You can search by name at texasbar.com. A clean record does not mean the lawyer wins cases; it means they have not been disciplined by the bar for ethics violations or misconduct.

The State Bar database will tell you if a lawyer has been sanctioned for failing to communicate with clients, mishandling money, or other violations. It will not tell you how many cases they have won or what they recovered. That information comes only from the lawyer themselves, and you have to ask for it directly.

Court records in the county where the death occurred are public, but they do not list the settlement amount in most cases. Settlements are confidential agreements between the family and the defendant or insurance company. Trial verdicts are public record, but only a small fraction of wrongful death cases reach trial. You can search county court records online, but you will see case names and outcomes, not dollar amounts for settled cases.

Questions to Ask a Wrongful Death Lawyer About Their Track Record

When you contact a lawyer, ask these specific questions and request written answers or documentation:

  1. How do you define a successful case? Do you count only cases that went to trial and won, or do settlements count? Do you count cases where you recovered something but the family was not satisfied?
  2. What percentage of your wrongful death cases settle versus go to trial? This tells you whether the lawyer's experience is in negotiation or courtroom work.
  3. What is the average settlement amount you have recovered in wrongful death cases in the past three years? Ask for the range (lowest to highest) as well as the average, because one very large case can skew the average upward.
  4. What is your trial win rate, and how many wrongful death cases have you taken to trial in the past five years? A lawyer who has tried only two cases to verdict has less trial experience than one who has tried twenty, even if both won.
  5. Can you provide three to five case examples from the past three years with similar facts to mine? Ask what the death was (vehicle accident, workplace injury, medical error, etc.), what county the case was in, and what the outcome was. Do not ask for client names—those are confidential—but ask for enough detail to understand whether the lawyer has handled cases like yours.
  6. What is your experience in [the specific county where my case would be filed]? A lawyer who has settled dozens of cases in Harris County may have little experience in Tarrant County, where judges and juries may respond differently.

How Settlement Amounts and Trial Verdicts Compare Across Lawyers

Two lawyers in the same city can have very different average payouts because they handle different types of cases. A lawyer who focuses on high-income earner deaths (where lost wages are substantial) will have higher average settlements than one who takes cases across all income levels. A lawyer who turns down weak cases will have a higher average payout than one who takes every case that walks in the door. Neither approach is wrong, but they produce different numbers.

When comparing lawyers, ask whether their average settlement includes only cases they handled from start to finish, or whether it includes cases they inherited from another lawyer or took over mid-stream. Ask whether the average includes cases where the family rejected the settlement offer and the case was dismissed. These details change what the number tells you.

Trial verdicts in Texas wrongful death cases vary widely by county and by the type of death. A verdict for $2 million in a rural county might be considered high; the same verdict in Houston might be considered modest for a high-income earner. Ask the lawyer what verdicts have been returned in similar cases in your specific county in recent years, so you understand what is realistic for your situation.

Red Flags When a Lawyer Quotes a Success Rate

Be cautious if a lawyer claims a success rate above 95 percent or says they "win" nearly every case. This usually means they are turning down most cases that come through the door, or they are defining "success" in a way that excludes losses. Both are possible, but you need to understand which one it is.

Be cautious if a lawyer refuses to give you specific examples or says their results are "confidential." Settlements are confidential, but a lawyer can describe the type of case and the outcome without naming the client. If they will not do that, ask why.

Be cautious if a lawyer's website or marketing materials show only trial verdicts and no mention of settlements. This suggests they want you to think they take cases to trial, when in reality most wrongful death cases settle. It does not mean they are dishonest, but it means they are emphasizing one part of their work and downplaying another.

Be cautious if a lawyer quotes an average settlement amount without explaining what cases are included in that average. Ask for the range, the number of cases, and the time period. A lawyer who has handled five cases in the past year has less data than one who has handled fifty.

How to Evaluate Experience in Your Specific Type of Case

Wrongful death cases fall into broad categories: vehicle accidents (car, truck, motorcycle), workplace deaths, medical errors, premises liability (slip and fall, inadequate security), and product liability. A lawyer with strong results in vehicle accident cases may have little experience with medical malpractice wrongful death cases, where the legal and medical issues are different.

Ask the lawyer how many cases they have handled in your specific category in the past three to five years. Ask what the outcomes were. If they have handled only one or two cases like yours, they have less experience than a lawyer who has handled ten or twenty. Experience matters because it teaches a lawyer what insurance companies and juries in your area expect, what defenses are common, and what settlement range is realistic.

Also ask whether the lawyer has experience in the specific county where your case would be filed. Texas has 254 counties, and they vary in how juries respond to wrongful death cases, what judges allow in discovery, and how quickly cases move through the system. A lawyer with strong results in one county may have no track record in another.

How to Request and Review Written Documentation

Ask the lawyer to provide their track record in writing. This can be a summary of cases, a list of verdicts and settlements, or a detailed breakdown by case type and outcome. Request that it cover the past three to five years and include the type of death, the county, the outcome, and the dollar amount (for trials; settlements may be confidential, but the lawyer can say "settled" or give a range).

If the lawyer provides a list, look for patterns. Do they have more experience in your county than others? Do they have a track record in cases similar to yours? Is the average settlement or verdict amount consistent, or does it vary widely? Wide variation can mean they take on very different cases, which is fine, but it makes their average less meaningful for your situation.

Ask whether the lawyer will provide references from past clients or families. Some lawyers will, some will not (because of confidentiality agreements). If they will, ask for references from cases similar to yours, not just their best cases. A family whose case settled for less than they hoped can still tell you whether the lawyer communicated well and worked hard on their behalf.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I find a lawyer's success rate on the Texas State Bar website?

No. The State Bar database shows bar status and disciplinary history only, not case outcomes or success rates. You must ask the lawyer directly for their track record. The State Bar does not collect or publish case outcome data.

What is a "good" success rate for a wrongful death lawyer in Texas?

There is no standard definition. Most wrongful death cases settle rather than go to trial, so a high trial win rate does not necessarily mean better results overall. Focus on average settlement and verdict amounts in cases similar to yours, and ask the lawyer to explain how they define success.

Should I choose the lawyer with the highest average settlement amount?

Not automatically. A high average can mean the lawyer is selective about which cases they take, or it can mean they handle cases with higher damages (like deaths of high-income earners). Ask what cases are included in that average and whether it matches your situation. A lawyer with a lower average but more experience in your specific county or case type may be a better fit.

If a lawyer won't give me specific examples of past cases, should I hire them?

Ask why first. Some lawyers cite confidentiality agreements, but they can usually describe case types and outcomes without naming clients. If they refuse to provide any detail about their track record, that is a reason to be cautious and look for another lawyer who will.

Does a lawyer's success rate in other types of cases tell me anything about their wrongful death work?

Not much. A lawyer who is excellent at personal injury cases may have little experience with wrongful death, which has different legal issues and damages calculations. Ask specifically about their wrongful death track record, not their overall success rate.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.