Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Look for in a Wrongful Death Attorney's Track Record

How to Read a Wrongful Death Attorney's Settlement History

When you are looking at a wrongful death attorney, their past settlements tell you something real: what they have actually recovered for families like yours, and how long those cases took. But settlement numbers alone can mislead you. A $2 million settlement in a case with clear liability and a young victim with decades of lost income is not the same as a $2 million settlement in a case where fault was disputed. You need to know what the attorney recovered, why the case settled at that amount, and whether the facts match your own situation.

Most attorneys will show you their largest settlements first. That is normal marketing. What matters is whether they can explain what made each case strong or weak, and whether they handled cases similar to yours. An attorney who settled five cases involving workplace deaths may be more useful to you than one who settled one $5 million case involving a car accident, even if the dollar amounts suggest otherwise.

Key Takeaways

  • Settlement amounts mean less than the facts behind them—ask why each case settled at that figure and whether liability was clear or disputed.
  • Look for cases similar to yours in how the death occurred, the victim's age, and the type of defendant (employer, driver, manufacturer, hospital).
  • Ask how long cases took from filing to settlement, because timeline matters as much as the final number when you are grieving and need money.
  • Request the attorney's win rate or the percentage of cases that settled versus went to trial, because some attorneys settle quickly while others push cases further.
  • Verify settlements through court records or bar association databases rather than relying only on what the attorney's website displays.

What Settlement Numbers Actually Tell You

A settlement is what both sides agree to pay to end the case before trial. It is not a judgment—a judge did not decide it. That matters because a settlement can reflect a strong case, a weak case, a plaintiff who needed money fast, or a defendant trying to avoid a jury. You cannot know which without asking.

When an attorney shows you a $3 million settlement, ask: Was liability clear, or did the defendant deny responsibility? Was the victim a 28-year-old earning $80,000 a year, or a 72-year-old retired? Did the case involve a single defendant or multiple parties who shared fault? Did the attorney go to trial and then settle, or settle early? Each answer changes what that $3 million means. A settlement that came after a jury found the defendant liable is stronger evidence of the attorney's skill than one that came after six months of negotiation with an insurance company.

Ask the attorney directly: "Of your last ten wrongful death cases, how many went to trial, and how many settled?" If nine out of ten settled, that tells you something. If five went to trial and five settled, that tells you something different. Neither answer is wrong—it depends on your case and what you need.

Matching Past Cases to Your Situation

The most useful settlement to know about is one that resembles your case in three ways: how the death occurred, who caused it, and the victim's age and earning potential. An attorney with a strong record in workplace deaths may have less experience with medical malpractice. An attorney who has won large settlements against manufacturers may have limited experience suing hospitals or government agencies, which have different rules and defenses.

When you meet with an attorney, bring the facts of your case and ask: "Have you handled cases like this before? How many? What did they settle for?" Listen for specifics. "Yes, I have handled workplace deaths" is less useful than "I have handled three cases involving falls from height at construction sites, and they settled for $1.2 million, $890,000, and $1.6 million." The second answer tells you the attorney knows the category and can predict what yours might be worth.

Pay attention to the defendant type. Suing a large corporation with insurance is different from suing a small business or a government agency. Suing a hospital involves medical informed testimony and different standards of care. Suing a driver involves insurance coverage limits that may cap what you can recover. An attorney experienced in your type of defendant will know these limits and how to work around them.

Timeline: How Long Cases Take to Settle

Settlement amounts matter, but so does when the money arrives. A case that settles in eight months is not the same as one that takes three years, even if both settle for the same amount. You may need the money sooner. You may not have the emotional energy to wait. The attorney's timeline history tells you what to expect.

Ask: "How long did your last five wrongful death cases take from filing to settlement?" Write down the answers. If most took 18 to 24 months, that is your baseline. If one took four years, ask why—was it unusually complex, or did the attorney delay? If one settled in four months, ask whether that was because liability was clear or because the family needed money urgently and accepted less.

Some attorneys push cases toward trial because they believe they can win more money that way. Others settle early because they want to close cases and move on. Neither approach is wrong for every case, but you should know which type of attorney you are hiring. If you need money within a year, an attorney who typically takes three years may not be the right fit, even if their settlements are larger.

Win Rate and Trial History

A win rate is the percentage of cases an attorney wins or settles favorably. It is not the same as a settlement rate. An attorney might settle 80 percent of cases (meaning 80 percent end in money for the client) but have a trial win rate of 60 percent (meaning they win 60 percent of the cases that actually go to trial). Both numbers matter.

Ask the attorney: "What percentage of your wrongful death cases settle, and what percentage go to trial?" Then ask: "Of the cases that go to trial, what percentage do you win?" If the attorney says "I settle 90 percent of cases" but will not say what happens in the 10 percent that go to trial, that is a red flag. You want to know whether the attorney is good at trial or just good at negotiating early settlements.

Trial experience matters because it affects settlement negotiations. An insurance company or defendant's attorney will offer more money if they believe the plaintiff's attorney will actually take the case to trial and win. If your attorney has never tried a wrongful death case, the other side knows it and may offer less. Ask whether the attorney has tried wrongful death cases to verdict, and if so, how many and what the outcomes were.

How to Verify Settlements and Check Records

An attorney's website can show you anything. Court records show you what actually happened. Before you hire an attorney based on their settlement history, verify at least two or three of the largest cases they mention.

Start with your state's court records system, usually available online through the state court website or a service like PACER (Public Access to Court Electronic Records) for federal cases. Search by the attorney's name or the case name if the attorney provides it. You can see the filing date, the parties involved, and often the settlement amount if it was filed with the court. Some settlements are confidential and will not appear in public records, which is legal—but if an attorney claims a settlement and you cannot find any record of it, ask why.

You can also contact your state bar association. Most bar associations maintain disciplinary records and can tell you whether an attorney has faced complaints or sanctions. Some bar associations publish settlement data or attorney profiles. Call your state bar's lawyer referral service and ask whether they have information about the attorney's history.

Ask the attorney directly for references—other families who have hired them for wrongful death cases. A reputable attorney should be willing to provide names of past clients (with permission) or at least describe their cases in detail. If an attorney refuses to discuss their cases or provide any way to verify their history, that is a reason to look elsewhere.

Red Flags in an Attorney's Settlement History

Some patterns should make you cautious. If an attorney shows you one very large settlement and nothing else, ask why. If they have been practicing for ten years but can only name three wrongful death cases, they may not have much experience. If all their settlements are confidential and cannot be verified, you have no way to check their claims.

Be skeptical of an attorney who promises a specific settlement amount or says "cases like yours typically settle for $X." No attorney can predict what your case will be worth without knowing all the facts, and promising a specific outcome is a violation of ethics rules. A good attorney will give you a range based on similar cases and explain what factors could move your case up or down within that range.

If an attorney pressures you to hire them quickly or says you have limited time to decide, that is a red flag. Wrongful death cases have strict filing important date (called statutes of limitations), but those important date are usually two to three years from the death. You have time to interview multiple attorneys and make a careful choice. Do not let urgency push you into hiring someone you have not fully vetted.

Questions to Ask About Specific Settlements

When an attorney shows you a settlement, ask these questions in this order:

  1. How did the death occur? (This tells you if the case is similar to yours.)
  2. Who was the defendant? (A large corporation, a small business, a government agency, an individual?)
  3. Was liability clear or disputed? (Did the defendant admit fault, or did you have to prove it?)
  4. What was the victim's age and occupation? (This affects how much lost income you can claim.)
  5. How long did the case take? (From filing to settlement.)
  6. Did the case go to trial, or settle before trial?
  7. What was the insurance coverage limit? (Sometimes settlements are capped by how much insurance the defendant had.)
  8. Can you show me the court filing or settlement agreement? (This verifies the amount and details.)

Write down the answers. Compare them to your own case. If the attorney has handled cases very similar to yours and recovered substantial money, that is a good sign. If most of their cases are different from yours, or if they cannot explain why a settlement was that amount, keep looking.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I hire the attorney with the biggest settlements?

Not necessarily. A $5 million settlement in a case with clear liability and a young victim with high earning potential is not the same as a $5 million settlement in a case where fault was disputed and the victim was retired. Look for an attorney with strong settlements in cases similar to yours, not just the largest numbers overall.

What if an attorney will not show me their settlement history?

That is a reason to hire someone else. Reputable attorneys are proud of their work and willing to discuss it. If an attorney claims confidentiality for all their cases, ask them to describe cases in general terms without naming clients. If they refuse, move on.

Can I find settlement information online?

Some settlements appear in court records, which are public. Others are confidential by agreement between the parties. You can search your state's court website or ask the attorney to provide court filings. You can also contact your state bar association to ask about the attorney's history and any disciplinary records.

Does a higher settlement mean the attorney is better?

Not always. A settlement depends on the facts of the case—how clear liability is, the victim's age and earning potential, the defendant's insurance, and many other factors. An attorney who recovers $800,000 in a weak case may be more skilled than one who recovers $2 million in a case with obvious liability. Ask about the facts, not just the number.

What should I do if I find a discrepancy between what the attorney claims and what court records show?

Ask the attorney to explain the difference. It may be that the settlement was confidential and the court record shows only the filing, or that the attorney is describing a different case. If the attorney cannot explain it clearly, that is a sign to hire someone else.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.