Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How To Appeal a Denied Wrongful Death Claim in Illinois

What happens when your wrongful death claim is denied

A denial from an insurance company or a judgment against you in court does not end your case. Illinois law gives you a specific window to challenge that decision, and the steps you take depend on whether the denial came from an insurer (before trial) or from a judge or jury (after trial). The process is different for each, and the timeline matters — miss the important date and you lose the right to appeal.

Most denials happen at the insurance stage: the at-fault party's insurer says the claim lacks merit, that their policyholder was not at fault, or that the death does not fall under the policy. If you went to trial and lost, you have different grounds and different important date. Either way, you will need to understand what you are challenging and who you are challenging it to.

Key Takeaways

  • Insurance denials can be challenged through the insurer's internal appeal process, which must be completed before you can file a lawsuit.
  • Court judgments can be appealed to the Illinois Appellate Court within 30 days of the judgment, but only on legal errors, not on disagreement with the jury's decision about facts.
  • You must file a notice of appeal with the trial court and serve the other party's attorney within the 30-day window, or your right to appeal is lost.
  • An appeal is expensive and slow — it typically takes one to two years — so understanding whether you have grounds before you file matters.
  • A wrongful death appeal in Illinois usually requires an attorney, because the rules of appellate procedure are strict and mistakes cost you the case.

Appealing an insurance company denial before trial

When an insurer denies your wrongful death claim, they send a written explanation. Read it carefully — it will tell you the reason (liability denial, policy exclusion, insufficient damages evidence, or something else). That reason determines what you challenge and how.

Most insurers have an internal appeal process. You submit a written response to the denial, usually within 30 to 60 days, with any new evidence or legal argument that addresses their stated reason. Send it to the claims adjuster or the appeals department — the denial letter should list the address. Keep a copy and send it certified mail so you have proof of delivery.

The insurer will review your appeal and issue a written decision. If they uphold the denial, you can then file a lawsuit in Illinois circuit court. If they reverse it, you move into settlement negotiation. The internal appeal does not may provide anything, but it creates a record of the denial and your response, which matters if the case goes to trial later.

Filing a notice of appeal after a trial judgment

If you went to trial and the judge or jury ruled against you, you have 30 days from the date of judgment to file a notice of appeal with the trial court. This is a short document that tells the court you are appealing and which court you are appealing to (the Illinois Appellate Court for your district). Miss this important date and you cannot appeal — there is no extension.

You must also serve a copy of the notice on the other party's attorney on the same day you file it with the court. "Serve" means deliver it by mail, email, or hand delivery, depending on what the court rules allow. File the original with the trial court clerk and keep proof that you served the other side.

Within 50 days of filing the notice, you must also file a docketing statement with the appellate court. This is a form that lists the parties, the trial court case number, the judgment date, and a brief description of the issues you are appealing. The appellate court uses this to organize the case. Your attorney will handle these filings if you have one.

What grounds you actually have to appeal

An appeal is not a second trial. You cannot ask the appellate court to re-weigh the evidence or to agree with you that the jury got the facts wrong. You can only appeal on legal errors — things the judge did wrong in how they ran the trial, what evidence they allowed, or how they instructed the jury on the law.

Common legal errors in wrongful death cases include: the judge allowed evidence that should have been excluded, the judge refused to allow evidence that should have been admitted, the jury instructions misstated the law on negligence or causation, the judge made a mistake in calculating damages, or the verdict was so lopsided that no reasonable jury could have reached it. You cannot appeal because you think the jury did not believe your witnesses or because you disagree with their judgment about who was more credible.

Before you file an appeal, talk to an attorney about whether you actually have grounds. Many appeals fail because the trial record does not show a legal error that the appellate court can fix. An attorney can review the trial transcript and the judge's rulings to tell you whether an appeal is worth the cost and time.

The appellate process and timeline

After you file the notice of appeal and docketing statement, the trial court sends the complete trial record (transcript, exhibits, motions, rulings) to the appellate court. This can take several months. Once the appellate court has the record, you and the other side file written briefs — detailed legal arguments about why the judgment was right or wrong.

Your brief is usually due 60 days after the record is filed. The other side files a response brief 30 days after that. You can file a reply brief 14 days after their response. The appellate court then schedules oral argument, where you (or your attorney) stand before a three-judge panel and answer questions about your case. Oral argument usually happens 6 to 12 months after briefs are filed.

After oral argument, the court takes weeks or months to issue a written decision. The whole process — from notice of appeal to final decision — typically takes 12 to 24 months. During this time, the judgment is usually still in effect, meaning the other side can try to collect on it. You can ask the appellate court to stay (pause) collection while the appeal is pending, but you have to show that you are likely to win.

Costs and when to hire an appellate attorney

Appeals are expensive. You pay court filing fees (usually $300 to $500), transcript costs (often $1,000 to $3,000 depending on trial length), and attorney fees if you hire one. Most appellate attorneys charge hourly rates or a flat fee for the entire appeal, which can range from $5,000 to $20,000 or more depending on the complexity of the case and the amount of briefing required.

You should hire an appellate attorney before you file the notice of appeal, not after. They need to review the trial record while it is fresh and identify legal errors early. If you wait until after the notice is filed, you may have missed opportunities to preserve issues for appeal or to ask the trial judge to correct errors before they go to the appellate court.

Some attorneys who handled your trial may not be appellate specialists. Appellate practice is different — it is all writing and legal argument, not witness examination or jury strategy. If your trial attorney is not experienced in appeals, ask them for a referral to someone who is, or contact the Illinois State Bar Association for a referral.

What happens if you win the appeal

If the appellate court agrees that the trial judge made a legal error that affected the outcome, they can reverse the judgment, affirm it, or reverse and remand it. "Reverse" means they overturn the judgment entirely. "Affirm" means they uphold it. "Reverse and remand" means they find an error but send the case back to the trial court to fix it — usually for a new trial or a new damages calculation.

If the court reverses, the case is over and you have won. If they reverse and remand, you go back to trial court for a new trial or a new hearing on damages. If they affirm, the judgment stands and you can ask the Illinois Supreme Court to review the decision, but that is rare and has a very low success rate.

Even if you win on appeal, collecting the money is a separate process. The judgment will be in your favor, but you still have to pursue collection through the court system if the defendant does not pay voluntarily.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I appeal if I did not have an attorney at trial?

Yes, but it is much harder. You can represent yourself on appeal, but appellate rules are strict and technical. Missing a important date or filing a brief in the wrong format can result in dismissal. Most appellate courts will not give you extra time or forgive procedural mistakes just because you are representing yourself. Hiring an appellate attorney is strongly recommended.

What if the insurance company and the defendant's attorney both say the claim has no merit?

That does not mean you cannot appeal. Insurance companies and defense attorneys have financial incentives to deny claims. An appellate court will review the trial record independently and decide whether a legal error occurred. If there was an error, the court can reverse regardless of what either side says now.

How much does an appeal cost in total?

Court costs are usually $300 to $500. Transcripts run $1,000 to $3,000. Attorney fees vary widely — some appellate attorneys charge $5,000 to $10,000 for a straightforward appeal, while complex cases can cost $20,000 or more. Ask for a written fee agreement before you hire someone.

Can I appeal if I missed the 30-day important date?

Not in most cases. The 30-day important date to file a notice of appeal is strict, and Illinois courts rarely grant extensions. If you missed it, you have lost the right to appeal the judgment. This is why it is critical to hire an attorney when ready after an unfavorable verdict.

What if the appellate court does not issue a decision for two years?

That is normal. Appellate courts are slow, and wrongful death cases are not prioritized. You can ask the court to expedite the decision, but they rarely do. During this time, you can ask for a stay of collection, which pauses the defendant's ability to collect on the judgment while the appeal is pending.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.