Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Expect When the Defense Asks You Questions Under Oath

What happens during a wrongful death deposition

A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you sit down with the other side's lawyer and answer questions under oath, before trial. The defense attorney will ask you about the death, your relationship to the person who died, the financial and emotional impact on you, and anything else they think might weaken your case. Your own lawyer will be present, but cannot answer for you or tell you to refuse most questions.

The session is recorded by a court reporter who produces a written transcript. Nothing you say is secret — the defense gets a copy, your lawyer gets a copy, and if the case goes to trial, either side can read parts of your deposition aloud in front of the jury. This is why what you say matters: contradicting yourself later looks bad, and anything you say can be used against you.

Depositions usually last a few hours, though they can run longer. You will be asked to swear or affirm that you will tell the truth, just as you would in court. The defense is not trying to be fair or friendly — they are gathering ammunition and testing whether you will hold up under pressure.

Key Takeaways

  • The defense lawyer will ask you detailed questions about the death, your losses, and your relationship to the person who died, and everything you say will be recorded and can be used at trial.
  • You must answer honestly, but you can ask for clarification if a question is unclear, and your lawyer can object to certain questions on legal grounds.
  • Contradicting yourself in a deposition damages your credibility with a jury, so preparing your story in advance and sticking to it is essential.
  • The defense will try to minimize your damages, suggest the death was not the defendant's fault, or find reasons to blame you or the person who died.
  • Your lawyer should prepare you for the deposition by doing a mock question session and explaining which topics are likely to come up.

Questions about the death itself

The defense will ask you what you know about how the death happened — what you saw, what you heard, what you were told, and when you found out. They want to know whether you have direct knowledge or are relying on what someone else told you, because secondhand information is weaker in court.

Expect questions like: "Where were you when the death occurred?" "What did you see?" "Who told you what happened?" "Did you see the defendant?" "What was the condition of the scene?" "Did you call 911?" "What did you say to the dispatcher?" They will ask about the sequence of events and try to get you to admit gaps in your knowledge or uncertainty about details.

Do not guess or fill in blanks. If you do not know something, say so. If you are not sure whether you saw something or heard it from someone else, say that too. The defense will use vague or uncertain answers to suggest the death was not as serious as you claim, or that you cannot be trusted as a witness.

Questions about your relationship and financial dependence

In a wrongful death case, your damages depend partly on how much you relied on the person who died — financially and emotionally. The defense will ask detailed questions about money: Did the person who died support you? How much did they earn? Did you work? How much did you earn? What bills did they pay? What would have happened to you financially if they had lived?

They will also ask about your relationship: How long did you know them? How often did you see them? Did you argue? Were you close? Did they help you with childcare, housework, or other tasks? They are looking for reasons to argue that your loss was smaller than you claim — that you were not truly dependent, or that the relationship was distant.

Bring documents to the deposition if your lawyer tells you to: pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements, lease agreements, anything that shows what money the person who died was giving you or what you spent on shared expenses. Numbers are harder to argue with than memory.

Questions designed to blame you or the person who died

The defense strategy often includes suggesting that either you or the person who died caused or contributed to the death. They will ask whether the person who died had any health problems, was taking medication, had been drinking, was distracted, was not paying attention, or was breaking any rules. They will ask whether you warned them about danger, whether they ignored safety instructions, whether they had done the same risky thing before.

They will also ask about you: Were you present? Did you see the danger coming? Could you have stopped it? Did you warn them? Why not? Have you had other losses or hardships that might make your damages claim seem inflated? Do you have a criminal record, financial problems, or other issues that might make a jury distrust you?

Your lawyer will have prepared you for these lines of attack. Answer honestly, but do not volunteer extra information that makes you look worse. If the question is unfair or assumes facts not in evidence, your lawyer will object — but you still have to answer unless your lawyer tells you that you do not have to.

Questions about your emotional and physical health

If you are claiming damages for emotional distress, grief, or loss of companionship, the defense will ask you to describe it in detail. They want to know: When did the grief start? When did it get better? Are you still grieving now? Have you seen a therapist or counselor? What did they say? Are you on medication? Have you returned to work? Have you taken vacations? Have you dated or remarried?

They are trying to show that your suffering was temporary, that you have recovered, or that you are exaggerating. They will ask whether you have other family members, other sources of support, or hobbies that bring you joy — anything to suggest that your life is not as damaged as you claim.

Be honest about your recovery. If you are doing better, say so. If you still struggle, say that too. Do not pretend to be more damaged than you are, because the defense will catch you in the lie and use it to discredit everything else you say.

How to prepare for your deposition

Meet with your lawyer at least once before the deposition, and ideally twice. In the first meeting, go over the facts: what happened, what you know, what you do not know, and what you were told by others. In the second meeting, do a mock deposition where your lawyer asks you the hard questions and you practice answering them.

Write down your story in chronological order and read it several times so you can tell it consistently. Write down numbers: how much money the person who died earned, how much they gave you, how much you earned, what your expenses were. Write down dates: when you met the person, when you moved in together, when the death occurred, when you found out, when you went to the funeral.

Bring all documents your lawyer asks for: identification, financial records, medical records, photographs, text messages, emails, anything that supports what you will say. Do not bring anything your lawyer did not ask for, because the defense can demand to see it.

What to do and not do during the deposition

Dress neatly and professionally, as you would for court. Arrive on time. Bring water and ask for breaks if you need them — you do not have to answer questions while you are exhausted or upset. Listen carefully to each question before you answer. If you do not understand a question, say so and ask the lawyer to rephrase it. If you need a moment to think, take it — do not rush into an answer.

Answer only the question asked. Do not volunteer extra information, do not explain yourself beyond what was asked, and do not argue with the lawyer. If your lawyer objects to a question, stop talking and wait for the lawyer to tell you whether to answer. If the lawyer says you do not have to answer, do not answer.

Tell the truth, even if the truth hurts your case. A lie discovered later will destroy your credibility and may result in sanctions from the court. Stick to what you know from your own experience. If you are testifying about what someone else told you, say so: "My sister told me that..." or "I heard that..." rather than stating it as fact.

What your lawyer can and cannot do

Your lawyer can object to questions that are legally improper — for example, questions that ask you to guess, questions that assume facts not proven, questions that violate attorney-client privilege, or questions about things that happened after the death and are not relevant to your damages. When your lawyer objects, you usually do not have to answer unless the defense lawyer pushes back and the judge rules that you must.

Your lawyer cannot tell you to lie, refuse to answer a proper question, or coach you on how to shade the truth. Your lawyer also cannot answer questions for you or tell you what to say — you have to answer in your own words. If your lawyer thinks you are about to say something damaging, they may ask for a break and talk to you privately, but they cannot prevent you from testifying truthfully.

Before the deposition, ask your lawyer which topics are off-limits and why. Ask what happens if you do not remember something. Ask what the defense is likely to focus on. A good lawyer will prepare you thoroughly so that you walk in knowing what to expect.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I refuse to answer a question at my deposition?

Your lawyer can object to certain questions on legal grounds, and you do not have to answer if the judge agrees the question is improper. But you cannot straightforward refuse to answer because you do not like the question or think it is unfair. If you refuse to answer a proper question, the judge can order you to answer, and refusing can result in sanctions.

What if I do not remember something the lawyer asks about?

Say that you do not remember. Do not guess or make something up. If you might remember with help — for example, if looking at a document would refresh your memory — tell the lawyer that. If you never knew something, say that too. Admitting you do not know is better than giving a wrong answer that contradicts you later.

Can the defense lawyer trick me or ask unfair questions?

Yes, that is part of their job. They may ask questions in a confusing way, ask you to agree with a false premise, or ask about things that are not relevant to your case. Your lawyer will object when they can, but you still have to answer most questions. The best defense is to listen carefully, ask for clarification, and answer only what was asked.

Will my deposition answers be used against me at trial?

Yes. Either side can read parts of your deposition aloud in front of the jury, especially if you say something different at trial. If you contradict yourself, the jury will see it, and your credibility will suffer. This is why preparing in advance and sticking to your story is so important.

What happens after the deposition?

The court reporter produces a transcript, usually within a few weeks. Your lawyer will review it and may ask you to review it too. The transcript becomes part of the case file and can be used in settlement negotiations or at trial. The deposition does not end the case — it is one step in the discovery process, where both sides gather information before trial.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.