What Happens When You Give a Deposition in a Wrongful Death Case
What a deposition is and why you'll give one
A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you sit down with a lawyer (usually the defendant's lawyer) and answer questions under oath about what you know regarding the death. You're not in court—it happens in a conference room or law office—but everything you say is recorded word-for-word by a court reporter and can be used later in trial or settlement negotiations. As the plaintiff (the person bringing the wrongful death claim), your deposition is one of the most important pieces of evidence the other side will gather.
The defendant's lawyer uses your deposition to understand your version of events, test how you'll hold up under questioning, and find any gaps or inconsistencies in your story. Your own lawyer will be there the entire time to object to unfair questions and advise you when appropriate, but you are the one answering. The deposition usually lasts between two and six hours, though it can be longer in complex cases.
Key Takeaways
- Your deposition is a recorded question-and-answer session under oath where the defendant's lawyer questions you about the death and your relationship to the person who died.
- You must answer truthfully, but your lawyer can object to questions that are unfair, ask for breaks, and advise you before you respond.
- The defendant's lawyer will ask about the circumstances of the death, your damages (medical bills, lost income, emotional harm), and anything that might weaken your case.
- Preparation with your own lawyer is essential—you should review documents, practice answering tough questions, and understand what the other side already knows about your case.
- Anything you say in your deposition can be used against you in trial, so accuracy and consistency matter more than trying to strengthen your case with exaggeration.
What the defendant's lawyer will ask you
The defendant's lawyer will start with background: your relationship to the person who died, how long you knew them, whether you depended on them financially, and what your life was like before the death. These questions establish who you are and why you have standing to bring the case.
Then they move to the death itself. They'll ask what you know about how it happened, what you saw or heard, what you were told by others, and what you've learned since. They're listening for inconsistencies between what you say now and what you said to police, in medical records, or to other people. They'll also ask whether you've discussed the case with your lawyer or other witnesses—not to trap you, but to understand how much of your knowledge is firsthand versus secondhand.
Finally, they'll ask about your damages: the financial losses (funeral costs, lost inheritance, lost wages if you were dependent), medical or mental health treatment you've needed since the death, and how the death has affected your daily life, relationships, and ability to work. They may ask for specific dates, amounts, and names of providers. This is where they look for exaggeration or claims that don't match your medical records or tax returns.
How to prepare with your lawyer before the deposition
Your lawyer should meet with you at least once, and ideally twice, before the deposition. In the first meeting, review the facts: what happened, what you know firsthand versus what you were told, and what documents exist (police reports, medical examiner's report, hospital records, emails, text messages). Your lawyer will explain what the other side already knows and what they're still fishing for.
In the second meeting, practice. Your lawyer will ask you the tough questions the defendant's lawyer is likely to ask, and you'll answer out loud. This isn't about memorizing answers—it's about getting comfortable with the rhythm of question and answer, learning to pause before you speak, and catching yourself if you're about to say something that contradicts your earlier statements or the documents. Your lawyer will also explain the rules: answer only what you're asked, don't volunteer extra information, say "I don't know" or "I don't remember" if that's true, and ask for a break if you need one.
Bring all relevant documents to your preparation meeting: funeral bills, medical records, pay stubs, emails, text messages, photographs, and anything else related to the death or your losses. Your lawyer needs to know what exists so they can prepare you for questions about it.
What you should and shouldn't do during the deposition
Listen carefully to each question before you answer. If you don't understand what's being asked, say so—don't guess. If you need time to think, pause. There's no penalty for silence. Speak clearly and in complete sentences so the court reporter can hear you; nods and shrugs don't show up on the record.
Answer only the question asked. If the lawyer asks "Did you see the defendant that day?" say "No" or "Yes," not "No, I was at work and didn't see him." The extra detail gives the other side more to work with. Your lawyer will have a chance to ask follow-up questions later if needed.
If you don't remember something, say so. Don't guess or fill in blanks. If you remember part of something but not all of it, say that too: "I remember he called me, but I don't remember what time." If a document refreshes your memory, ask to see it. Your lawyer can show it to you, and then you can answer based on what the document says plus what you remember.
If your lawyer objects to a question, stop talking and wait for the lawyer to tell you whether to answer. Some objections mean you shouldn't answer; others mean you can answer but the objection is noted for the record. Don't argue with the other lawyer or get defensive. Stay calm and professional even if the questions feel accusatory or unfair.
How your deposition will be used later
The defendant's lawyer will have the court reporter prepare a transcript—a typed version of everything said. Both sides get a copy. If your case goes to trial, the defendant's lawyer can read parts of your deposition to the jury to show what you said under oath. If you testify differently at trial, the jury will see the contradiction, which damages your credibility.
Your deposition is also used in settlement negotiations. If you came across as honest, consistent, and sympathetic, the other side may be more willing to settle. If you seemed evasive, exaggerated your damages, or contradicted yourself, they'll push back on settlement offers and be more confident at trial.
Your own lawyer will also use your deposition to prepare you for trial testimony. They'll review what you said and make sure you're ready to say the same thing in front of a judge or jury.
What happens if you make a mistake or change your story
If you realize during the deposition that you said something wrong, tell your lawyer when ready. Your lawyer can ask the court reporter to note the correction, and you can clarify on the record. It's better to correct yourself during the deposition than to have the other side catch it later.
If you remember something new after the deposition is over, tell your lawyer right away. They can decide whether to notify the other side or address it at trial. Hiding new information or waiting until trial to mention it will hurt your credibility.
If the defendant's lawyer catches you in a contradiction between your deposition and your trial testimony, your lawyer can ask you to explain the difference. Sometimes there's a good explanation (you misunderstood the question, you didn't have all the facts, your memory has improved). But if it looks like you were lying or exaggerating, the jury will doubt everything else you say.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I bring documents or notes to the deposition?
You can bring documents that help you remember, but the other lawyer can ask to see them. If you refer to a document while answering a question, the defendant's lawyer has the right to look at it. Don't bring anything you don't want the other side to see. Your lawyer will advise you on what to bring.
What if I get emotional during the deposition?
It's normal to get upset when talking about the death. Ask for a break, step out of the room, and compose yourself. The court reporter will pause the recording. Your lawyer can also request breaks on your behalf. Getting emotional won't hurt your case, but try to stay focused enough to answer questions accurately.
Can the defendant's lawyer ask me about things that aren't directly related to the death?
Yes, within reason. They can ask about your financial situation, your medical history, your relationship with the person who died, and anything else that might affect your credibility or your damages claim. Your lawyer can object if the questions become harassment or ask for information that's private (like your mental health records), but you may still have to answer some personal questions.
What if I don't want to answer a question?
You don't have a choice—you're under oath. Your lawyer can object to the question, but you still have to answer unless the judge rules that you don't have to. The only exceptions are questions protected by attorney-client privilege (conversations with your lawyer) or spousal privilege in some states. Your lawyer will tell you which questions you can refuse to answer.
Will the defendant be at my deposition?
Usually yes, though not always. The defendant has the right to attend and hear what you say. Some defendants choose not to attend. If the defendant is there, stay professional and don't direct your answers at them or try to convince them. Speak to the lawyer asking the question and the court reporter.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.