What Happens When You're Named as a Defendant in a Wrongful Death Case
Being named as a defendant means you are being held legally responsible for someone's death
A wrongful death lawsuit names you as the person or organisation whose actions or negligence caused someone to die. You will receive a summons and complaint — legal documents that explain what the plaintiff (the person suing) claims you did, how it led to the death, and what they are asking the court to award them. This is not a criminal charge; it is a civil case, which means the plaintiff is seeking money damages, not your imprisonment.
The moment you receive these documents, your time to respond is limited. You typically have 20 to 30 days to file an answer with the court, depending on your state and how you were served. Missing this important date can result in a default judgment against you — a court decision in the plaintiff's favour without a trial. This is one of the most consequential mistakes a defendant can make, so your first step should be to contact a lawyer, even if you think the claim is unfounded.
What happens next depends on whether you have insurance that covers this type of claim, what state you are in, and the specific facts of the death. Some cases settle before trial; others go to court. Understanding the process and your obligations now will help you make decisions that protect your interests.
Key Takeaways
- You have 20 to 30 days from the date you are served to file a written response with the court, or you risk losing by default.
- If you have homeowner's, business, or vehicle insurance, notify your insurer when ready — they may provide a lawyer and pay any judgment up to your policy limits.
- Anything you say to the plaintiff, their lawyer, or on social media can be used against you in court, so do not discuss the case outside of conversations with your own lawyer.
- A wrongful death case is civil, not criminal, so the goal is to determine how much money you owe, not whether you go to jail.
- Early settlement is common and often costs less than going to trial, but the decision to settle is yours to make with your lawyer's information.
Notify your insurance company when ready
If the death involved a car accident, a slip and fall on your property, a workplace injury, or an incident related to your business, you likely have insurance that covers wrongful death claims. Homeowner's insurance, auto insurance, commercial general liability insurance, and workers' compensation insurance all may cover these lawsuits. Check your policy documents or call your insurer's claims line as soon as you receive the summons.
When you notify your insurer, they will assign you a defence lawyer at no cost to you — this is part of what your premiums pay for. That lawyer's job is to defend you and protect the insurance company's interests. In most cases, these align: the insurer wants to pay as little as possible, and you want to avoid a large personal judgment. However, if a conflict arises — for example, if the insurer wants to settle and you want to fight — you may need your own separate lawyer. For now, the insurance company's lawyer is your primary resource.
Do not ignore the summons and hope your insurer handles it. You must still file a response with the court, even if your lawyer is working on your behalf. Your insurer's lawyer will do this, but you need to confirm it has been done. Ask your lawyer for a copy of the answer filed with the court.
Understand what the plaintiff must prove
In a wrongful death case, the plaintiff must show four things: that you owed the deceased person a duty of care, that you breached that duty, that the breach caused the death, and that the death caused measurable harm (usually financial loss to surviving family members). The standard of proof is lower than in a criminal case — the plaintiff needs to show it is more likely than not that you are responsible, not that you are guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
What "duty of care" means depends on the context. If you were driving, you had a duty to follow traffic laws and drive safely. If someone was injured on your property, you had a duty to keep it reasonably safe or warn visitors of dangers. If you were an employer, you had a duty to provide a safe workplace. If you were a medical professional, you had a duty to meet the standard of care expected of someone in your field. Your lawyer will explain what duty applies to your situation and whether the plaintiff can prove you breached it.
The causation part — proving your actions directly caused the death — is often where cases are won or lost. If the person had a pre-existing condition, was injured by someone else, or made a choice that contributed to their death, that can reduce or eliminate your liability. Your lawyer will investigate these details and use them to build your defence.
Do not discuss the case outside your lawyer's office
Anything you say about the death, the incident, or the lawsuit can be used against you. This includes conversations with friends and family, posts on social media, emails, text messages, and statements to the plaintiff or their lawyer. Even if you are trying to apologise or explain your side, your words will likely be quoted in court in a way that makes you look worse, not better.
If the plaintiff's lawyer contacts you directly, do not answer questions. Tell them to contact your lawyer. If they contact you by phone, you can say: "I have a lawyer. Please direct all communication to them." Then hang up. If they send a letter, forward it to your lawyer unopened if possible, or at least do not respond to it yourself.
Social media is particularly dangerous. Do not post about the case, the person who died, your feelings about the lawsuit, or anything related to the incident. Plaintiffs' lawyers routinely search defendants' social media accounts for statements that contradict their defence or show a lack of remorse. A casual comment made months ago can become evidence at trial.
The discovery process will require you to provide documents and answer questions
After you file your response, both sides enter a phase called discovery, where each side asks the other for documents and information. You will be asked to provide emails, text messages, photos, medical records, business records, or anything else related to the incident and the death. Your lawyer will help you gather these materials and decide what must be turned over.
You will also be deposed — questioned under oath by the plaintiff's lawyer. A court reporter will record your answers, and they can be used at trial. Your lawyer will prepare you for this and will be present during the deposition. You should answer questions truthfully but carefully; do not volunteer information beyond what is asked, and if you do not understand a question, say so and ask for clarification.
Discovery can take months or even years in complex cases. It is expensive and time-consuming, which is one reason many cases settle before trial. Your lawyer will advise you on what documents are most damaging to your defence and what information might help you.
Settlement negotiations may begin at any point
The plaintiff's lawyer may propose a settlement — an agreement where you (or your insurance company) pay a sum of money and the case ends without a trial. Settlement can happen early, during discovery, or even during trial. Many wrongful death cases settle because both sides want to avoid the cost and uncertainty of a jury verdict.
Your insurance company may push for settlement if the evidence against you is strong. You have the right to refuse a settlement offer, but if you do and you lose at trial, you could owe more than the settlement amount. Your lawyer will explain the risks and benefits of any offer. The decision is ultimately yours, but it should be made with full information about what a trial might cost and what a jury might award.
Settlement amounts vary widely depending on the age and earning potential of the deceased, the nature of the death, the strength of the evidence, and local jury attitudes. Your lawyer can tell you what similar cases have settled for in your area.
If the case goes to trial, a jury will decide your liability and the damages
If no settlement is reached, the case will go to trial. A jury will hear evidence from both sides, including testimony from you, witnesses, medical experts, and accident reconstruction experts. The plaintiff's lawyer will argue that you are responsible for the death; your lawyer will argue that you are not, or that your responsibility is limited.
The jury will decide two things: whether you are liable (responsible) and, if so, how much money you should pay. Damages in wrongful death cases typically include the deceased person's lost wages, medical expenses, funeral costs, and sometimes pain and suffering or loss of companionship. Juries in some states can also award punitive damages — extra money meant to punish you — if your conduct was especially reckless or intentional.
A trial is public, which means the details of the death and your conduct will be reported in the news and become part of the court record. This is another reason many defendants prefer to settle, even if they believe they might win at trial.
Your personal assets may be at risk if you do not have insurance
If you have insurance that covers the claim, the insurance company will pay the judgment up to your policy limits. If the jury awards more than your policy limit, you are responsible for the difference — and the plaintiff can pursue your personal assets: your home, savings, car, and future wages. This is called a judgment lien, and it can follow you for years.
If you do not have insurance, all of your personal assets are at risk from the start. This is why it is critical to notify your insurer when ready and to have a lawyer defending you. Even if you think you are not responsible, the cost of defending yourself in court is high, and a judgment against you can be devastating.
Some states allow defendants to file for bankruptcy to discharge a wrongful death judgment, but this is complicated and has serious consequences. Your lawyer can advise you on whether this is an option in your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if I cannot afford a lawyer?
If you have insurance, your insurer will provide one at no cost to you. If you do not have insurance and cannot afford a private lawyer, you may be able to find one who works on contingency (taking a percentage of any settlement or judgment) or who offers a payment plan. Contact your state bar association for referrals to lawyers who handle wrongful death defence.
Can the plaintiff's family members each sue me separately?
Wrongful death lawsuits are typically filed by one representative of the deceased's estate on behalf of all family members. However, some family members may also file separate claims for their own emotional distress or loss of companionship. Your lawyer will advise you on how many cases you may face and how they interact.
What happens if I ignore the summons?
If you do not file a response within the important date, the court can enter a default judgment against you. This means the plaintiff wins without a trial, and the court will order you to pay damages. You may be able to ask the court to set aside a default judgment if you have a good reason for missing the important date, but this is difficult and expensive. Do not ignore the summons.
Will this case show up on a background check?
A civil lawsuit is a matter of public record, so it may appear in background checks or online searches. A criminal conviction would be more serious, but a civil judgment can still affect your reputation, employment, and ability to borrow money.
Can I be sued criminally and civilly for the same death?
Yes. A wrongful death civil lawsuit and a criminal prosecution are separate. You could be found not guilty in criminal court and still lose a civil case, or vice versa. The standards of proof are different, and the consequences are different. Your lawyer can advise you on how to handle both if they occur.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.