When a Defendant Countersues in a Wrongful Death Suicide Case
What a countersuit means in wrongful death suicide cases
A countersuit is a claim the defendant files against the person who sued them — in this case, the family or estate that brought the wrongful death case. In suicide wrongful death cases, defendants sometimes countersue to shift liability back onto the plaintiff, to recover their own legal costs, or to argue that someone else (including the deceased) bears responsibility for what happened.
The countersuit does not stop the original wrongful death case. Both claims move forward at the same time, and the court can rule on them separately. A defendant might countersue even if they believe they will lose the main case — the goal is often to reduce what they owe, to create leverage for settlement, or to establish that the plaintiff shares fault.
Countesuits in suicide cases are uncommon but not rare. They tend to appear when the defendant is a healthcare provider, employer, facility, or institution, and when the facts suggest the deceased's own choices or the plaintiff's own actions played a role in the death.
Key Takeaways
- A countersuit is a separate claim the defendant files against the plaintiff, and it proceeds alongside the original wrongful death case.
- Common counterclaims in suicide cases include comparative fault (arguing the deceased or plaintiff shares responsibility), breach of contract, or defamation if the plaintiff made public accusations.
- The existence of a countersuit can affect settlement negotiations, because the plaintiff now faces their own legal exposure and costs.
- State law determines whether the court can reduce a wrongful death award based on the deceased's own negligence or actions, which shapes how much a countersuit matters.
- You should discuss any countersuit with your attorney when ready, because it changes the risk profile and timeline of your case.
Common types of counterclaims in suicide wrongful death cases
The most frequent countersuit in a suicide case is a comparative fault claim. The defendant argues that the deceased's own actions — or the plaintiff's failure to supervise, warn, or intervene — contributed to the death. In cases involving a healthcare provider, the defendant might argue the patient did not follow treatment, did not disclose symptoms, or ignored warnings. In cases involving an employer or school, the defendant might claim the deceased had access to resources or support that they refused to use.
A second common type is a breach of contract counterclaim. If the plaintiff signed a liability waiver, a non-disparagement clause, or an agreement to arbitrate disputes, the defendant may countersue for breach. This is especially common in cases involving fitness facilities, mental health programs, or residential treatment centers.
A third type is defamation or tortious interference. If the plaintiff made public statements accusing the defendant of causing the death, or if the plaintiff contacted the defendant's clients or employees to discourage business, the defendant may countersue for damage to reputation or lost business.
Less common but possible: counterclaims for the defendant's own legal costs, claims that a third party (not the defendant) caused the death, or counterclaims based on the plaintiff's own negligence in a shared-duty scenario (for example, if both the defendant and the plaintiff were responsible for the deceased's safety).
How comparative fault rules affect the countersuit's power
Whether a countersuit actually reduces what the defendant owes depends on your state's comparative fault law. Some states follow pure comparative fault, meaning the jury can assign a percentage of fault to the deceased, and the wrongful death award is reduced by that percentage. Other states follow modified comparative fault, which bars recovery if the deceased is found more than 50% (or sometimes 51%) at fault. A few states do not allow comparative fault in wrongful death cases at all.
If your state allows comparative fault, a successful countersuit can cut the plaintiff's recovery significantly. If the jury finds the deceased 40% at fault and the defendant 60% at fault, the plaintiff receives 60% of the damages. If the jury finds the deceased 60% at fault, the plaintiff may recover nothing, depending on the state's rule.
This is why comparative fault counterclaims are powerful negotiating tools. Even if the defendant believes they will lose the main case, a credible argument that the deceased or plaintiff shares fault can pressure the plaintiff to settle for less. Your attorney should explain your state's comparative fault rule early, because it determines how much risk the countersuit actually creates.
How a countersuit affects settlement and trial strategy
A countersuit changes the cost-benefit math for both sides. The plaintiff now faces the possibility of losing money, not just failing to win. This can make settlement more attractive, because both sides have something to lose. The defendant may offer a higher settlement to avoid the risk of a large judgment; the plaintiff may accept a lower one to avoid the risk of a counterjudgment.
A countersuit also complicates discovery and trial. Your attorney will need to respond to the defendant's evidence on the counterclaim, which means more documents to produce, more depositions to attend, and more testimony to prepare. The trial itself may take longer, because the jury will hear arguments on both the original claim and the counterclaim.
Some counterclaims are easier to defend than others. A comparative fault argument requires the defendant to present evidence about the deceased's choices or the plaintiff's actions — evidence that may be painful for the family to hear in court, but that your attorney can challenge. A defamation counterclaim requires the defendant to prove the plaintiff made false statements; if the statements were true or opinion, the counterclaim may fail.
Red flags and weaknesses in common counterclaims
A comparative fault counterclaim often fails if the defendant cannot show the deceased actually knew about the risk or had a real choice. For example, if a healthcare provider argues the patient "should have" sought help, but the patient was not aware of the symptoms or did not understand the risk, the argument weakens. Similarly, if the defendant argues the plaintiff "should have" supervised the deceased, but the deceased was an adult with no legal duty of care owed by the plaintiff, the counterclaim may not survive a motion to dismiss.
Breach of contract counterclaims depend on whether the contract is enforceable. Many liability waivers are unenforceable in wrongful death cases, especially if they attempt to waive liability for gross negligence or intentional harm. Your attorney can challenge the validity of the contract itself, which may eliminate the counterclaim before trial.
Defamation counterclaims require the defendant to prove the plaintiff's statements were false, made with knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth, and caused real damage. If the plaintiff's statements were substantially true, or if they were opinion or hyperbole, the counterclaim fails. Public figures and matters of public concern receive extra protection, which can shield the plaintiff.
What you should do if the defendant files a countersuit
Tell your attorney when ready if you learn the defendant has filed a counterclaim. Do not ignore it or assume it is a bluff. Your attorney needs to file a response within the important date set by the court — usually 20 to 30 days — and that response shapes how the case proceeds.
Work with your attorney to understand the specific counterclaim and the evidence the defendant will use to support it. Ask what your state's comparative fault rule is, and what percentage of fault the defendant is likely to argue for. Ask whether the counterclaim has weaknesses that your attorney can attack in a motion to dismiss or at trial.
Be prepared for the possibility that the counterclaim will be discussed in settlement negotiations. Your attorney may recommend accepting a lower settlement to eliminate the risk of a counterjudgment, or may recommend proceeding to trial if the counterclaim is weak. That decision depends on the strength of your case, the strength of the counterclaim, and your own risk tolerance.
Do not make public statements about the defendant or the case once a counterclaim is filed. Anything you say can be used against you in the defamation or tortious interference counterclaim. Stick to factual statements, avoid accusations of intent or motive, and let your attorney do the talking in court filings and media.
How counterclaims interact with insurance and settlement
The defendant's insurance policy may or may not cover the counterclaim. Some policies cover the defendant's defense costs on a counterclaim but not the counterjudgment itself. Others exclude counterclaims entirely. This affects how aggressively the defendant's insurance company will defend the counterclaim, and whether settlement is likely.
If the defendant's insurance does not cover the counterclaim, the defendant may be more willing to settle the main case to avoid personal liability on the counterclaim. If the insurance does cover it, the insurance company controls the defense and may push for trial even if settlement would be better for the defendant personally.
Settlement agreements often include a clause that dismisses the counterclaim as part of the deal. Your attorney should make sure any settlement offer includes dismissal of the counterclaim with prejudice, meaning the defendant cannot refile it later.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the defendant countersue if they lose the main wrongful death case?
Yes. A counterclaim is a separate legal claim, and the court can rule against the defendant on the main case while still allowing the counterclaim to proceed. However, if the defendant loses the main case, a jury may be less sympathetic to the counterclaim, and the defendant's credibility may be damaged. In practice, a counterclaim that survives to trial after a defendant loses the main case is rare.
What happens if the jury finds the deceased 100% at fault?
In states that allow comparative fault, a finding of 100% fault to the deceased would bar the plaintiff's recovery entirely. The plaintiff would receive nothing. However, juries rarely assign 100% fault in suicide cases, because suicide involves complex mental health factors that courts recognize as shared responsibility in many situations. Your attorney should discuss your state's approach to comparative fault in suicide cases specifically.
Does a countersuit mean I should settle?
Not necessarily. A countersuit changes the risk calculation, but it does not mean you should accept a lower settlement. Your attorney should evaluate the strength of the counterclaim, the likelihood of a counterjudgment, and the cost of defending against it. A weak counterclaim may not justify a lower settlement offer. A strong one may. The decision is yours, with your attorney's guidance.
Can I countersue the defendant's counterclaim?
No. You cannot countersue a counterclaim. However, your attorney can file a motion to dismiss the counterclaim, challenge its legal sufficiency, or argue it is barred by law. If the counterclaim survives, you will defend against it at trial, and the jury will decide whether the defendant's claims have merit.
Will the counterclaim be discussed in front of the jury?
Yes, if the case goes to trial. The jury will hear evidence and arguments on both the original wrongful death claim and the counterclaim. However, if the counterclaim is dismissed before trial — either by the judge or by settlement — the jury will never hear about it. Your attorney can request that the judge instruct the jury to disregard any reference to a dismissed counterclaim.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.