Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Which States Let You Skip Your Deductible in a Hit-and-Run Claim

Hit-and-Run Deductible Waivers by State

A handful of states waive your collision or comprehensive deductible when you file a hit-and-run claim, meaning you pay nothing out of pocket before your insurer covers the damage. However, most states do not—you still owe your full deductible even though you were not at fault. The states that currently waive the deductible are Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, and West Virginia. Even within these states, the waiver often comes with conditions: your insurer may require you to report the hit-and-run to police within a set timeframe, provide a police report number, or prove you made a reasonable effort to identify the other driver.

The reason most states do not waive the deductible is that hit-and-run claims are harder to verify than accidents where both drivers exchange information. Your insurer cannot interview the other driver or confirm their account of what happened. Some states view the deductible as your share of the risk when the other party cannot be identified or located. States that do waive it treat hit-and-run differently—they recognize that you did nothing wrong and should not bear the cost of someone else's decision to flee.

Your own state's rule depends on state law, not on your insurance company's choice. Even if your insurer's national policy would normally charge a deductible, state law may override that. Conversely, if your state does not waive the deductible, no insurance company operating there can waive it for you. The best first step is to call your insurer and ask directly: "Does my state waive the deductible for hit-and-run claims?" They will know the current rule for your address.

Key Takeaways

  • Nineteen states currently waive your deductible for hit-and-run claims, but most states do not, and you will owe your full deductible even though you were not at fault.
  • States that waive the deductible usually require you to file a police report within a specific number of days and provide the report number to your insurer.
  • The deductible waiver is determined by state law, not by your insurance company, so your insurer cannot override it either way.
  • If your state does not waive the deductible, you can sometimes reduce your out-of-pocket cost by raising your deductible on other coverage or by asking whether a police report affects the claim outcome.

What You Must Do to Claim the Waiver

If you live in a state that waives the deductible, you cannot straightforward file a claim and expect the waiver to explore automatically. Most states require you to report the hit-and-run to police and provide your insurer with the police report number. Some require the report to be filed within 24 or 48 hours of the incident; others give you longer. Check your state's specific rule before you delay—filing late can cost you the waiver even if your state offers one.

When you call your insurer to report the claim, tell them you were hit and run and ask what documentation they need. They will typically ask for the police report number, the date and time of the incident, the location, and a description of the other vehicle if you saw it. If you do not have a police report number yet, ask your insurer whether you can file the claim first and provide the number later, or whether you must have it before they open the claim. Some insurers will hold the claim open pending the report; others will not process it without one.

Keep copies of everything: the police report itself, the report number, your claim number, emails from your insurer, and any letters they send about the deductible waiver. If your insurer later tries to charge you the deductible, you will have proof that your state requires them to waive it.

States Without Deductible Waivers and Your Options

If you live in a state that does not waive the deductible for hit-and-run claims, you still have options to reduce what you pay. The first is to review your current deductible. If you chose a $1,000 deductible when you bought your policy, you can contact your insurer and ask about lowering it to $500 or $250 for future claims. This will raise your monthly premium slightly, but it means the next time you are hit and run, you will owe less. You cannot retroactively lower your deductible for a claim that has already happened, but you can change it going forward.

The second option is to ask your insurer whether they will negotiate the deductible if you can provide strong evidence of the hit-and-run. Some insurers, even in states without a legal waiver, will waive or reduce the deductible as a customer service gesture if you have a police report, witness statements, or security camera footage. This is not may provide, but it costs nothing to ask. Frame it as: "I have a police report and [other evidence]. Will you consider waiving the deductible given the circumstances?"

The third option is to check whether your state has an uninsured motorist fund or a crime victim compensation program. A few states operate funds that reimburse drivers for hit-and-run damage when the other driver is never found. These are rare and usually have strict income limits, but they exist in some places. Your state's insurance commissioner's office can tell you whether such a fund exists in your state.

How Hit-and-Run Claims Differ From At-Fault Accidents

In a normal accident where both drivers are present, your insurer can investigate both accounts, review police reports, and sometimes settle liability with the other driver's insurer. In a hit-and-run, the other driver is absent. Your insurer must decide whether to believe your account based on the police report, any witnesses, and physical evidence like paint transfer or security footage. This uncertainty is why some states charge you a deductible—they treat it as a shared risk when the other party cannot be verified.

However, a hit-and-run is not the same as a collision you caused. You did not cause the damage; you were the victim of someone else's crime. States that waive the deductible recognize this distinction. They reason that you should not pay a penalty for being hit by someone who fled, especially when you did everything right by reporting it to police. States without a waiver take a different view: they see the deductible as a standard cost-sharing mechanism that applies to all collision claims, regardless of fault.

One important note: if you file a hit-and-run claim, it will not raise your insurance rates in most states, even though you are filing a claim. Hit-and-run claims are treated as not-at-fault claims, so they typically do not trigger a rate increase the way an at-fault accident would. Your insurer may still use the claim in underwriting decisions if you renew, but the impact is usually minimal.

What Happens If You Cannot Find a Police Report

If you reported the hit-and-run to police but cannot locate the report number, contact the police department's non-emergency line and ask for the report number by date, time, and location. Provide as much detail as you remember: the street, the approximate time, and what you were doing (parked, driving, etc.). The police can usually pull the report within a day or two. If they cannot find a report under your name, ask whether the incident was logged as a call for service even if no formal report was filed. Some departments will provide a call number that your insurer may accept.

If you did not report the hit-and-run to police at the time, you can still file a report now, even days or weeks later. It will be dated when you file it, not when the incident occurred, but it is still valid for your insurance claim. Tell the police officer that you are filing a late report because you did not realize the damage until later or because you did not have time to report it when ready. Most police departments will take a late report without issue.

If you genuinely cannot obtain a police report—for example, because the police department says they have no record and will not file one—ask your insurer in writing what they will accept as proof of the hit-and-run. Some will accept a signed statement from you, photos of the damage, witness contact information, or security camera footage. Document your effort to obtain a police report so you can show your insurer you tried.

Deductible Waivers and Your Insurance Rates

Filing a hit-and-run claim will not raise your rates in states that waive the deductible, and it typically will not raise your rates in states that do not waive it either. Hit-and-run claims are classified as not-at-fault claims because you did not cause the accident. Your insurer cannot penalize you for being the victim of someone else's crime. However, some insurers may use the claim as a factor in renewal underwriting—if you file multiple claims in a short period, they may decide not to renew your policy or may raise your rates for other reasons unrelated to the hit-and-run itself.

The deductible waiver does not affect your rates because it is a coverage rule, not a claims history issue. Whether you pay $0 or $1,000 out of pocket, the claim itself is still recorded as a not-at-fault claim. Your rates are based on your claims history and driving record, not on how much you paid toward a claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to file a police report to claim the deductible waiver?

In most states that waive the deductible, yes—you must file a police report and provide the report number to your insurer. A few states allow exceptions if you can prove the hit-and-run through other means, such as witness statements or security footage, but a police report is the standard requirement. File it as soon as possible after the incident; waiting too long may disqualify you from the waiver.

What if the police will not file a report because they say the damage is minor?

Insist on filing a report anyway. Police sometimes discourage reports for minor damage, but you have the right to file one. If the officer refuses, ask to speak to a supervisor or call the non-emergency line and ask for a report to be filed. Document the refusal in writing and provide that documentation to your insurer along with photos of the damage. Your insurer may still honor the waiver if you can show you made a good-faith effort to report the incident.

Can my insurer charge me the deductible if my state waives it?

No. State law overrides your insurer's policy. If your state waives the deductible for hit-and-run claims and you meet the requirements (usually filing a police report), your insurer must waive it. If they try to charge you, contact your state's insurance commissioner and file a complaint. Provide your policy number, claim number, and proof that your state waives the deductible.

Will a hit-and-run claim affect my ability to get insurance in the future?

Unlikely. A not-at-fault hit-and-run claim has minimal impact on your insurability because you did not cause the accident. Some insurers may ask about claims history during underwriting, but a single hit-and-run claim should not prevent you from getting coverage. Multiple claims in a short period may affect your rates or renewal, but that is true of any claims, not just hit-and-run.

What if I hit a parked car and left the scene—can I still claim the deductible waiver?

No. If you were the driver who hit the other car and left, you are the at-fault party, not the victim. You cannot claim a deductible waiver for your own hit-and-run. You would file a claim under your own collision coverage and owe your full deductible. You may also face legal consequences for leaving the scene of an accident.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.