What Happens After a Car Accident Deposition
Your deposition is over—here's what comes next
A deposition is a recorded statement you give under oath, usually in a lawyer's office. Once it ends, you leave the room and the real work begins—but not the kind you do. Your lawyer and the other side's lawyer now have your sworn account of what happened. They will use it to decide whether to settle, push harder in negotiations, or prepare for trial. You will not be in the room for most of what happens next, but understanding the timeline and the decisions being made will help you know what to expect.
The weeks after your deposition are when the case often shifts. Insurance companies review what you said and recalculate their risk. Your lawyer reads the other side's deposition (if they have given one) and looks for inconsistencies or admissions that help your case. Motions may be filed. Settlement talks may heat up or stall. None of this requires you to do anything when ready, but you should know what your lawyer is doing and why.
Key Takeaways
- After your deposition, your lawyer will review the transcript and compare it to the other side's statements to find strengths and weaknesses in your case.
- The insurance company will use your deposition to reassess the value of your claim and decide whether settling is cheaper than going to trial.
- Settlement negotiations often intensify after depositions because both sides now have a clearer picture of what a jury would hear.
- If no settlement is reached, your case moves toward trial and your deposition testimony becomes part of the record the judge and jury will consider.
- You should stay in regular contact with your lawyer and ask what stage your case is in, rather than waiting to hear from them.
What your lawyer does with the deposition transcript
Within a few days to a week, the court reporter sends a written transcript of your deposition to your lawyer. Your lawyer reads it carefully—not just to see what you said, but to spot anything that could hurt you later or anything that strengthens your position. If you misspoke, contradicted yourself, or said something that helps the other side's argument, your lawyer needs to know now, not at trial.
Your lawyer will also compare your deposition to the depositions of the other driver, any witnesses, and the police report. If the other driver's story changed between the police report and their deposition, that is a win for you. If a witness said something that backs up your account, your lawyer notes that. If there are gaps or lies in the other side's story, your lawyer builds on those.
Your lawyer may also hire experts—an accident reconstructionist, a medical doctor, an engineer—to review the deposition testimony and the evidence. These experts will write reports saying whether the injuries you described match the accident, or whether the other driver's version of events is physically possible. These reports often become the foundation for settlement negotiations or trial.
How the insurance company uses your deposition
The insurance company defending the other driver gets a copy of your deposition transcript. They read it to find anything that weakens your case: Did you admit you were distracted? Did you say you did not see the other car until the last second? Did you describe your injuries in a way that sounds exaggerated? Insurance adjusters are trained to spot these moments and use them to lower their settlement offer or argue that you share some blame.
At the same time, if your deposition was strong—you were clear, consistent, and credible—the insurance company's risk goes up. They now know that a jury would likely believe you. That usually pushes them toward settling rather than rolling the dice at trial, because trials are expensive and unpredictable. Your deposition may be the moment when the insurance company decides the case is worth more than they initially offered.
The insurance company also uses your deposition to assess your credibility as a witness. If you seemed evasive, confused, or dishonest, they will bet that a jury will see the same thing. If you seemed straightforward and believable, they will assume a jury will too. This assessment shapes their settlement strategy.
Settlement negotiations after depositions
Many car accident cases settle after depositions, because both sides now have a much clearer picture of what the case is worth and what a trial would look like. Your lawyer will likely send a settlement demand to the insurance company—a letter laying out your injuries, your damages, and the evidence supporting your claim. The insurance company will respond with a counter-offer. This back-and-forth may happen over weeks or months.
During these negotiations, your lawyer will keep you informed and ask whether you would accept a particular settlement offer. You do not have to accept the first offer, or even the fifth. But you should understand what your lawyer thinks the case is worth, what the risks of trial are, and what happens if you turn down an offer and the case goes to trial instead. Settlement means certainty; trial means risk.
If settlement talks stall, your lawyer may file a motion—a formal request to the court asking for something, like a ruling that certain evidence is admissible or that the other side must produce documents they have been hiding. Motions can sometimes break a deadlock in settlement talks because they force the other side to take the case more seriously.
What happens if the case does not settle
If no settlement is reached, your case moves toward trial. Your deposition becomes part of the trial record, and the other side's lawyer may use parts of it to cross-examine you in front of the jury. If you said something in your deposition that contradicts what you say at trial, the other side will point that out to make you look unreliable. This is why consistency between your deposition and your trial testimony matters.
Your lawyer will prepare you for trial by reviewing your deposition and making sure you remember what you said and why. You may do a practice cross-examination so you are ready for tough questions. Your lawyer will also prepare other witnesses—the people who saw the accident, your doctors, your experts—using their depositions as a guide.
The judge and jury will have access to your deposition transcript even if you testify at trial. If you become unavailable to testify (because you are ill or out of the country), your deposition can sometimes be read into the record instead. This is rare in car accident cases, but it shows how important your deposition is to the case.
Staying in touch with your lawyer during this phase
After your deposition, it is straightforward to feel like your case has stalled. You are not doing anything; you are waiting. But your lawyer should be working—reviewing transcripts, negotiating, preparing motions, or getting ready for trial. You should not wait passively. Instead, reach out to your lawyer every few weeks and ask where the case stands. Are settlement talks happening? Has the other side made an offer? What is the next important date?
If your lawyer is not returning your calls or emails within a few days, that is a problem. You deserve to know what is happening in your case. If you feel like your lawyer is not doing enough, you can ask for a detailed explanation of their strategy, or you can seek a second opinion from another lawyer. You have the right to fire your lawyer and hire someone else, though doing so late in a case can be complicated.
Keep your lawyer updated if anything changes in your life—if your injuries get worse, if you have new medical treatment, if you miss work because of pain or appointments. These changes can affect the value of your case and may give your lawyer new ammunition in settlement talks.
Documents and important date you may encounter
After depositions, the case enters what lawyers call discovery—the phase where both sides exchange documents and information. You may be asked to produce medical records, pay stubs, tax returns, or other documents related to your claim. Your lawyer will tell you what to gather and when to send it. Missing a important date can hurt your case, so take these requests seriously.
You may also receive a request for admissions—a list of statements the other side asks you to admit or deny. For example: "Do you admit that you were driving a 2019 Honda Civic?" These seem straightforward, but they matter legally. Your lawyer will review these with you and advise you on how to respond.
If your case is heading toward trial, you will receive a trial date from the court. This date may be months away, but it is real. Your lawyer will use this date to plan depositions, file motions, and prepare witnesses. You should mark it on your calendar and let your lawyer know when ready if something would prevent you from being available.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the other side use my deposition against me at trial?
Yes. If you say something different at trial than you said in your deposition, the other side's lawyer will show the jury your deposition transcript and ask why your story changed. This can make you look unreliable. If you said something in your deposition that hurts your case, the other side can use that too, even if you do not testify at trial.
How long does it usually take to settle after depositions?
It varies widely. Some cases settle within weeks of depositions; others take months. It depends on how far apart the two sides are on value, how willing the insurance company is to negotiate, and whether either side files motions that change the dynamics. Your lawyer can give you a better estimate based on your specific case.
What if I remember something new after my deposition?
Tell your lawyer right away. If it is important, your lawyer may file a supplemental deposition or bring it up in settlement negotiations. Do not try to hide it or bring it up for the first time at trial—that will make you look dishonest. Your lawyer will advise you on how to handle it.
Do I have to accept a settlement offer after my deposition?
No. You have the right to turn down any offer and go to trial instead. But you should understand the risks: trials are unpredictable, they cost money, and you might lose and get nothing. Your lawyer should explain what your case is worth and what the chances are at trial before you decide.
What should I do if my lawyer is not communicating with me?
Ask your lawyer directly what is happening in your case and when you should expect to hear from them next. If they do not respond within a few days, send a written email so you have a record. If communication does not improve, you can file a complaint with your state bar or consult another lawyer about your options.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.