Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When and How to Hire a Trial Attorney for Your Car Accident Case

What a trial attorney does in a car accident case

A trial attorney is a lawyer who represents you in court if your car accident case goes to trial — meaning a judge or jury decides the outcome instead of you and the other party reaching a settlement. Not every accident case reaches trial. Many settle before that point, often through negotiation or mediation. But if settlement talks break down, or if the other side refuses to offer what your case is worth, a trial attorney takes over the work of preparing evidence, questioning witnesses, and arguing your case in front of a judge.

Trial attorneys differ from settlement negotiators in what they focus on. A settlement attorney might spend most of their time exchanging documents and making settlement offers. A trial attorney spends months preparing for the possibility that nothing will be agreed to before trial — gathering informed witnesses, organizing evidence, and building the argument they will make in court. Some attorneys do both; others specialize in one or the other.

The decision to hire a trial attorney usually happens after you have already worked with a personal injury attorney on your case. That attorney may tell you they think trial is likely, or you may decide together that settlement offers are too low and it is time to prepare for court.

Key Takeaways

  • A trial attorney prepares your case for court and represents you if your accident case goes to trial before a judge or jury.
  • Most car accident cases settle before trial, so you may start with a settlement attorney and hire a trial specialist only if settlement fails.
  • Trial attorneys charge either a percentage of what you win (contingency fee) or an hourly rate, and you should understand which before hiring.
  • Preparing for trial takes months and costs money for informed witnesses, court filings, and discovery — costs that may come out of your settlement or award.
  • A trial attorney should have experience taking cases to verdict in your state and should be willing to explain their trial record and strategy.

When you need a trial attorney instead of a settlement attorney

You do not automatically need a trial attorney the moment you hire a lawyer for your accident. Most personal injury attorneys handle both settlement and trial work, and they will negotiate on your behalf first. A trial attorney becomes necessary when settlement is no longer realistic — either because the other side's offers are far below what your case is worth, or because they have stopped negotiating altogether.

Signs that trial may be coming include: the other insurance company has made a final offer and refused to budge, your attorney has told you they believe the case is strong enough to win in front of a jury, or you and your attorney have decided together that the settlement being offered does not cover your actual losses. If your case involves serious injury, significant medical bills, or ongoing disability, the gap between what insurance will pay and what you need can be large enough to justify the cost and time of trial.

Some cases are more trial-ready than others. If liability is clear — the other driver was obviously at fault — and your injuries are well-documented, a trial attorney may be confident about your chances. If liability is disputed or your injuries are harder to prove, trial becomes riskier and more expensive, and settlement may make more sense even if the offer is lower.

How trial attorneys charge for their work

Trial attorneys use two main fee structures: contingency fees and hourly rates. Under a contingency fee, your attorney takes a percentage of what you win — typically 25 to 40 percent, depending on whether the case settles before trial or goes all the way to verdict. You pay nothing upfront, and if you lose, your attorney gets nothing. This is the most common arrangement for car accident cases.

Under an hourly rate, you pay your attorney for every hour they work, whether you win or lose. Hourly rates for trial attorneys range widely by location and experience — from $150 to $500 or more per hour. You may be asked to pay a retainer upfront, and you will receive bills as the case progresses. Hourly billing is less common in car accident cases but may be used if you are already working with an attorney and need to bring in a trial specialist for part of the case.

Even under a contingency fee, you will likely pay case costs separately. These are the expenses of preparing for trial: filing fees, informed witness fees, court reporter fees for depositions, and costs to obtain medical records or accident reconstruction reports. These costs may be deducted from your final award, or you may be asked to pay them as they come due. Ask your attorney in writing what costs you are responsible for and when they are due.

What to look for when hiring a trial attorney

Not all personal injury attorneys are equally prepared for trial. Some spend most of their career settling cases and have never taken a car accident to verdict. Before hiring, ask your attorney directly: How many car accident cases have you taken to trial in the past five years? What was the outcome? Are you willing to try this case if settlement does not happen?

A trial attorney should be licensed to practice in your state and should have experience in the specific court where your case would be tried — usually your county district court or superior court. They should be able to explain their trial strategy in plain language: what evidence they will present, what witnesses they will call, and what they expect the other side to argue. If an attorney is vague about strategy or seems uncomfortable discussing trial, that is a warning sign.

Ask for references from past clients whose cases went to trial, and ask what those clients thought of the attorney's preparation and courtroom performance. You should also ask whether the attorney has any disciplinary history with your state bar — this information is public and searchable on your state bar's website.

The cost and timeline of preparing for trial

Preparing a car accident case for trial typically takes 6 to 18 months, depending on how complex the case is and how busy the court is. During this time, your attorney will conduct discovery — exchanging documents and written questions with the other side, taking depositions (recorded interviews under oath), and gathering informed reports. Each of these steps costs money and takes time.

informed witnesses are often the largest cost. If your case involves serious injury, you may need a medical informed to testify about your condition and prognosis. If liability is disputed, you may need an accident reconstruction informed. Each informed typically charges $2,000 to $10,000 or more for their report and testimony. These costs come out of case expenses, not your attorney's fee.

Court filing fees, deposition transcripts, and the cost of obtaining medical records add up quickly. By the time a case reaches trial, case costs can easily total $5,000 to $25,000 or more, depending on how many experts are needed and how much discovery is required. Your attorney should give you a realistic estimate of these costs early on and explain how they will be paid.

What happens if your case goes to trial

If settlement does not happen, your case will be scheduled for trial before a judge or jury. In most car accident cases, either side can request a jury trial. A jury trial means 6 to 12 ordinary people will hear the evidence and decide who was at fault and how much you should be paid. A bench trial means a judge makes that decision alone.

Your trial attorney will present evidence: documents, photographs, medical records, and testimony from you, witnesses, and experts. The other side will do the same. Your attorney will cross-examine the other side's witnesses and argue why the evidence supports your case. The trial itself typically lasts a few days to a week, though preparation takes months.

If you win, the judge or jury will award you a sum of money called a verdict. If you lose, you receive nothing — though you may have the option to appeal, which is a separate and lengthy process. Your attorney should discuss the risks of trial openly: there is always a chance you could lose, even if your case seems strong.

Questions to ask before hiring a trial attorney

Before you commit to working with a trial attorney, write down these questions and get written answers:

  • How many car accident cases have you taken to trial in the past five years, and what were the outcomes?
  • Are you willing to take my case all the way to trial if settlement does not happen, or would you refer it to someone else?
  • What is your fee structure — contingency, hourly, or both — and what percentage or hourly rate applies to my case?
  • What case costs do you expect, and who pays them if we lose?
  • What is your assessment of my case's strength, and what are the main risks if we go to trial?
  • What is your timeline for preparing this case for trial?
  • Will you be the attorney trying the case, or will someone else take over at trial?

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I switch attorneys if I am unhappy with my current lawyer?

Yes, you can fire your attorney and hire someone else at any point, though it may delay your case. If you are working on a contingency fee, your new attorney will need to agree to take over the case, and there may be disputes about how the fee is split between the old and new attorney. Get any fee agreement in writing before switching.

What if I cannot afford a trial attorney?

Most trial attorneys work on contingency, meaning you pay nothing unless you win. If cost is still a barrier, ask whether your current attorney can handle trial work or whether they have a relationship with a trial specialist who will take the case on contingency. Some attorneys also offer payment plans or reduced fees for cases they believe in strongly.

How much money do I need to win at trial to make it worth the cost?

That depends on your case costs and your attorney's fee. If case costs are $10,000 and your attorney takes 33 percent of the award, you need to win at least $15,000 just to break even. Your attorney should help you calculate this before trial and discuss whether the likely award justifies the risk and expense.

What if the other side offers to settle right before trial?

This happens often. You and your attorney can accept or reject any settlement offer at any time, even the day before trial. Your attorney should advise you on whether the offer is fair given what you might win or lose at trial, but the decision is yours. Get any settlement agreement in writing before you accept.

Can I represent myself at trial instead of hiring an attorney?

You have the right to represent yourself, but car accident trials involve complex rules of evidence and procedure that are difficult to navigate without training. Most judges and juries are skeptical of self-represented parties, and mistakes in procedure can cost you the case. An attorney's experience is usually worth the cost.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.