What to Do When the At-Fault Driver's Insurance Won't Cover Your Damages
When the Other Driver's Insurance Limits Fall Short
If you were injured in a car accident in Pittsburgh and the at-fault driver's insurance won't pay the full cost of your medical bills, vehicle repairs, or lost wages, you have legal options. The driver who caused the crash is responsible for your damages under Pennsylvania law—but if their policy limit is too low, you may need to pursue that claim through other routes: your own underinsured motorist coverage, a lawsuit against the at-fault driver personally, or both.
This guide explains how underinsured motorist claims work in Pennsylvania, what you need to prove, and when you should talk to an attorney. It does not provide legal information and is not a substitute for speaking with a lawyer about your specific situation.
Key Takeaways
- Pennsylvania law requires all drivers to carry liability insurance, but minimum limits are often too low to cover serious injuries, so you may have underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy.
- Underinsured motorist claims pay you the difference between what the at-fault driver's insurance covers and what your damages actually cost, up to your policy limit.
- You must prove the at-fault driver was responsible for the crash and that your damages exceed their insurance limit before your own insurer will pay an underinsured claim.
- Pennsylvania allows you to sue the at-fault driver personally for any remaining damages after both insurance policies are exhausted, though collecting from an uninsured person is often difficult.
- An attorney can negotiate with both insurers, file a lawsuit if necessary, and help you understand whether settling or going to trial makes sense in your case.
How Underinsured Motorist Coverage Works in Pennsylvania
Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is part of your own auto insurance policy. It covers you when the other driver's liability insurance is not enough to pay your full damages. Pennsylvania does not require you to carry UIM coverage, but most policies include it unless you specifically declined it in writing.
Here is the basic math: if your medical bills, vehicle damage, and other losses total $75,000, but the at-fault driver's liability limit is only $25,000, their insurer pays you $25,000. Your own UIM coverage then pays the difference—up to your UIM limit. If your UIM limit is $50,000, you would receive an additional $25,000 from your own insurer, for a total of $50,000. You still absorb the remaining $25,000 in losses.
Your UIM limit is set when you buy your policy and is usually $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or higher. The higher your limit, the more protection you have if you are hit by an underinsured driver. Many people in Pittsburgh carry limits that match their liability limits—for example, $100,000 in both liability and UIM coverage.
What You Must Prove to Win an Underinsured Claim
Before your own insurer will pay a UIM claim, you must show three things: that the other driver was at fault, that your damages exceed their insurance limit, and that you have suffered actual losses (medical bills, lost wages, vehicle damage, pain and suffering).
Fault is usually the easiest part. If the police report says the other driver ran a red light, or if witness statements show they were texting while driving, fault is clear. Your insurer will review the accident report and any statements you provide. If fault is disputed, your attorney can gather evidence—photos, witness interviews, accident reconstruction reports—to build your case.
Damages exceeding the at-fault driver's limit must be documented. This means medical records showing treatment, bills from doctors and hospitals, repair estimates or invoices from body shops, pay stubs showing lost wages, and receipts for other out-of-pocket costs. If you suffered pain and suffering—ongoing pain, lost enjoyment of life, emotional distress—you will need to describe that in detail and may need a doctor's statement supporting it. Your attorney can help organize these documents and present them in a way that shows the full scope of your losses.
Your own insurer will also investigate the accident independently. They may request medical records, interview you, and review the at-fault driver's insurance file. This is normal and does not mean they doubt you; they are protecting their own interests by verifying the claim before paying.
The Settlement Process and Timeline
After you file a UIM claim with your own insurer, the process typically unfolds in stages. First, you will provide documentation of your damages. Your insurer will request the at-fault driver's insurance file and confirm their policy limit. Then both insurers will exchange information about your injuries and losses.
If your damages clearly exceed the at-fault driver's limit, your insurer may offer to settle quickly. If the amount is disputed—for example, if your insurer thinks your pain and suffering claim is too high—negotiation begins. This can take weeks or months. Your attorney can handle these negotiations on your behalf, which often results in a higher settlement than you would receive on your own.
In Pittsburgh, many UIM claims settle without a lawsuit. But if your insurer refuses to pay a fair amount, or if you and your insurer cannot agree on the value of your claim, you have the right to file a lawsuit. Pennsylvania law allows you to sue your own insurer to force them to pay what you are owed, though this is rare and usually happens only when the insurer has acted in bad faith.
Suing the At-Fault Driver Personally
Even after your UIM coverage is exhausted, you can sue the at-fault driver personally for any remaining damages. This is a separate lawsuit from your insurance claim and is filed in Allegheny County Court (or the county where the accident occurred).
The advantage of a personal lawsuit is that you can recover damages beyond what insurance will pay—for example, a larger award for pain and suffering, or punitive damages if the driver was reckless (such as driving drunk). The disadvantage is that the at-fault driver may have no assets or income to collect from, making the judgment difficult to enforce.
Your attorney will evaluate whether a personal lawsuit makes sense in your case. If the driver has a job, owns property, or has other assets, collection is more likely. If they are judgment-proof—meaning they have no money or property to seize—a lawsuit may not be worth the time and cost.
When You Should Talk to an Attorney
You do not need an attorney to file a UIM claim; you can do it yourself by contacting your own insurance company. But an attorney becomes valuable in several situations: if your damages are substantial (over $10,000), if your insurer is slow to respond or seems to be undervaluing your claim, if fault is disputed, or if you are unsure whether your injuries will require ongoing treatment.
An attorney can also help you understand the difference between settling now and waiting to see how your recovery progresses. If you settle too early, before you know the full extent of your injuries, you may not be able to recover additional damages later. An experienced attorney will advise you on timing and help you avoid this trap.
In Pennsylvania, most car accident attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of your settlement or judgment (usually 25 to 33 percent) and you pay nothing upfront. This makes it affordable to hire representation, and it aligns the attorney's interests with yours—they only make money if you recover money.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the minimum liability insurance in Pennsylvania?
Pennsylvania requires all drivers to carry at least $15,000 in bodily injury liability per person and $30,000 per accident, plus $5,000 in property damage liability. These limits are often too low for serious injuries, which is why underinsured motorist coverage is important.
Can I claim UIM benefits if I was partially at fault for the accident?
Yes, but Pennsylvania uses comparative negligence rules. If you were 20 percent at fault and the other driver was 80 percent at fault, your recovery is reduced by 20 percent. You cannot recover if you were more than 50 percent at fault. An attorney can help argue your percentage of fault downward.
What if the at-fault driver had no insurance at all?
That is an uninsured motorist claim, not underinsured. Your own uninsured motorist coverage (UM) covers you in that situation. The process is similar to UIM, but you do not have to wait for another insurer's limit to be exhausted first. Most policies include both UM and UIM coverage.
How long do I have to file a UIM claim?
Pennsylvania law gives you two years from the date of the accident to file a lawsuit, but you should report the claim to your own insurer much sooner—within 30 days if possible. Waiting too long can make it harder to gather evidence and may affect your credibility.
Will filing a UIM claim raise my insurance rates?
No. Pennsylvania law prohibits insurers from raising your rates because you filed a claim for underinsured motorist coverage. Your rates may increase if you were at fault in the accident, but not because you made a UIM claim.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.