What Happens During a Motor Vehicle Accident History and Physical Exam
Why insurers and lawyers order accident history and physical exams
After a motor vehicle accident, an insurance company or attorney may order you to undergo a medical examination called a Motor Vehicle Accident (MVA) History and Physical. This is a standard medical evaluation where a doctor reviews your medical background, documents your current injuries, and performs a physical exam to assess your condition related to the accident.
Insurers order these exams because they need medical evidence of what injuries you sustained and how severe they are. Your own doctor's records may not exist yet, or may not be detailed enough for claims purposes. A lawyer may order one to build your case or to have an independent medical record before settlement talks begin. The exam creates a formal medical document that both sides can reference.
This is different from your regular doctor visit. The examiner is usually chosen by the insurance company (if they're paying) or by your attorney (if you hired one). The exam is documented in detail and becomes part of your claim file or legal record. Understanding what to expect and what your rights are during this process protects you from surprises and helps may support the exam is fair.
Key Takeaways
- An MVA History and Physical is a medical exam ordered by an insurer or attorney to document injuries from the accident and create a formal medical record for your claim.
- You have the right to bring a witness, to refuse certain tests, and to request a copy of the exam report for your own records.
- The examiner will ask detailed questions about the accident, your symptoms, your medical history, and how the injuries affect your daily life.
- If the insurance company orders the exam, you typically do not pay; if your attorney orders it, the cost is usually covered by your case budget or paid later from settlement.
- The exam report becomes evidence in your claim or lawsuit, so accuracy and honesty about your symptoms matter significantly to your case outcome.
Who orders the exam and who pays for it
The defendant's insurance company (the at-fault driver's insurer) most often orders an MVA History and Physical if you have filed a claim against them. They pay for the exam directly. This is called a defense medical exam or independent medical exam (IME). The insurer chooses the doctor, schedules the appointment, and receives the report first.
Your own attorney may also order an exam, usually early in your case to have an independent medical record before the other side does. If your attorney orders it, the cost comes from your case budget or is deferred and paid from any settlement you receive later. You do not pay out of pocket in either scenario.
In rare cases, your own health insurance or workers' compensation may order an exam if the accident involves a work-related injury or a coverage dispute. Ask whoever contacts you to schedule the exam who is ordering it and who will pay, so you know what to expect.
What the examiner will ask and document
The examiner will conduct a structured interview covering your accident history, current symptoms, and medical background. Expect questions about how the accident happened, what you were doing at the time, whether you lost consciousness, and what you felt when ready after impact. The examiner will ask you to describe each injury in detail: where it hurts, when the pain started, what makes it worse or better, and how it affects your work and daily activities.
You will be asked about your medical history before the accident—prior injuries, surgeries, chronic conditions, medications, and any ongoing pain or limitations. The examiner will also ask about your current treatment: which doctors you are seeing, what tests or imaging you have had, what medications you are taking, and whether you have had physical therapy or other rehabilitation. Be honest and specific. Vague answers or gaps in your account can be used later to suggest your injuries are not as serious as you claim.
The physical exam itself includes standard medical checks: blood pressure, heart rate, range of motion tests, strength tests, and neurological checks (reflexes, sensation, balance). The examiner may ask you to touch your toes, rotate your neck, or perform other movements to assess your mobility and pain response. They will palpate (feel) areas where you report pain to check for swelling, tenderness, or muscle tightness. Some examiners use special tests for specific injuries—for example, a straight-leg raise for lower back pain or a Lachman test for knee injuries.
Your rights during the exam
You have the right to bring a witness—a family member, friend, or your attorney—to observe the exam. The witness cannot answer questions for you, but their presence creates an independent record of what was asked and how you responded. If your attorney is present, they can also object to inappropriate questions or tests. Notify the examiner in advance that you are bringing someone.
You can refuse to answer a question or decline a specific test, though refusal may be noted in the report and could be used against you later. For example, if you refuse to perform a range-of-motion test, the examiner will document that you refused, and the insurance company may argue that your refusal suggests you are exaggerating your injury. If a test causes you pain or you believe it is unsafe, say so clearly and ask the examiner to note your concern in the report.
You have the right to request a copy of the exam report. Ask for it in writing after the exam is complete. If the insurance company ordered the exam, you may have to request it through your attorney or through a formal discovery process if a lawsuit is filed. If your attorney ordered it, you will receive a copy automatically. Do not sign any document at the exam that waives your right to the report or limits how it can be used.
How to prepare for the exam
Wear comfortable clothing that allows the examiner to access the areas where you have injuries. If you have a neck injury, avoid a high collar. If you have a shoulder or arm injury, wear a short-sleeved shirt. Bring any medical records you have from your own doctors, including imaging reports (X-rays, MRI results) and notes from physical therapy or other treatment. Bring a list of your current medications and supplements, including dosages. Bring your insurance card and photo ID.
Write down your symptoms and how they affect you before the exam. Note specific examples: "I cannot lift my right arm above shoulder height," "I have sharp pain when I turn my head to the left," "I cannot sit for more than 20 minutes without lower back pain." Specific, concrete descriptions are more credible than general statements like "I hurt all over." If you have kept a symptom diary or journal since the accident, bring it.
Be on time and bring water. The exam typically lasts 30 minutes to two hours depending on the complexity of your injuries. Eat a light meal beforehand so you do not feel faint during physical tests. If you are taking pain medication, take it as prescribed before the exam—do not skip it to appear more injured, and do not take extra to appear more symptomatic. Either approach undermines your credibility.
What happens after the exam
The examiner will write a detailed report documenting your history, the physical findings, and their medical opinion about your injuries and prognosis. The report typically includes a summary of your account of the accident, a list of your current symptoms, the results of the physical exam, any imaging or test results reviewed, and the examiner's conclusions about causation (whether your injuries were caused by the accident) and severity.
If the insurance company ordered the exam, they receive the report first and use it to evaluate your claim. If the report supports your injuries, it strengthens your case. If the report minimizes your injuries or suggests they are unrelated to the accident, the insurer may use it to reduce their settlement offer or deny your claim. If you disagree with the report's conclusions, your attorney can order a rebuttal exam by another doctor or can challenge the report's findings in writing.
If a lawsuit is filed, the exam report becomes part of the discovery process—both sides exchange medical records and reports. The examiner may be deposed (questioned under oath) or called to testify at trial. Your own medical records and your doctor's opinions will be compared to the defense examiner's findings. Consistency between your account at the MVA exam and your medical treatment records strengthens your credibility.
Common concerns and what they mean for your claim
One common concern is that the examiner seems skeptical or dismissive of your symptoms. Defense examiners are hired by the insurance company and have an incentive to minimize injuries. This does not mean the exam is unfair or that you should have refused it. It means you should be clear, specific, and honest about your symptoms. If the examiner's report contradicts your medical treatment or your own doctor's findings, your attorney can address that discrepancy in settlement negotiations or at trial.
Another concern is that you performed better on physical tests than you expected. This can happen if adrenaline, anxiety, or the artificial setting of the exam affects your performance. If you can normally only walk 10 minutes before pain forces you to stop, but you walked 15 minutes during the exam, the examiner will note that. Your attorney can explain the difference—for example, that you were anxious during the exam, or that you paid for it later with increased pain—but the report will reflect what happened during the exam itself.
If the examiner's report is significantly more favorable than you expected, that is good for your claim. If it is less favorable, do not panic. One exam report is not the final word. Your own medical records, your doctor's opinions, and your testimony about your ongoing symptoms all matter. Your attorney will use all available evidence to build your case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse to take the exam?
You can refuse, but it will likely hurt your claim. If the insurance company ordered the exam and you refuse, they may deny your claim or reduce their settlement offer, arguing that your refusal suggests your injuries are not serious. If a lawsuit is filed and the court orders the exam, refusing can result in sanctions against you. Your attorney can advise whether refusing is wise in your specific situation.
What if the examiner's report says my injuries are not from the accident?
Disagreement between examiners is common. Your own doctor's opinion, your medical records, and your testimony about when your symptoms started all matter. Your attorney can order a rebuttal exam by another doctor or can argue that the defense examiner's conclusion contradicts the evidence. One unfavorable report does not end your claim.
Will the exam report be shared with my health insurance company?
Typically, no. The exam report is part of your personal injury claim or lawsuit file, not your health insurance records. However, if your health insurance company is seeking reimbursement from your settlement (called subrogation), they may request access to the report. Your attorney will manage that process and protect your interests.
Do I have to answer every question the examiner asks?
You can decline to answer, but refusal will be noted in the report. If you feel a question is inappropriate or invasive, say so and ask the examiner to explain why it is relevant to your injuries. Your attorney, if present, can object on your behalf. Most questions are legitimate and designed to assess your injuries and credibility.
How long does it take to get the exam report?
The examiner typically completes the report within one to three weeks. If the insurance company ordered it, they may not share it with you when ready. Request a copy in writing. If your attorney ordered it, you will receive it as soon as it is available. Do not wait passively; follow up if you do not have a copy within a month.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.