Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Finding a Wichita Car Accident Attorney Who Will Take Your Case to Trial

What "experienced" and "goes to trial" actually mean when you're choosing a lawyer

Most car accident lawyers in Wichita settle cases. That is not a criticism—settlement often gets you money faster and with less uncertainty. But if an insurance company has undervalued your claim, refused to pay fairly, or denied liability altogether, you need a lawyer who is willing to walk into a courtroom and argue your case in front of a judge or jury. That willingness changes how an insurance adjuster negotiates with you from the start.

An attorney who "goes to trial" is not someone who threatens trial and then folds. It is someone with a track record of actually trying cases, which means they have prepared cases for trial, cross-examined witnesses, presented evidence to juries, and won verdicts. That experience shapes how they handle settlement talks—adjusters know that if negotiations stall, this lawyer will not pressure you into a bad deal just to close the file.

In Wichita, finding that lawyer means looking beyond marketing language. You are looking for someone with actual trial experience in Kansas state courts (where most car accident cases are filed), a willingness to turn down settlement offers that do not match your injuries, and a fee structure that does not punish you for going to trial.

Key Takeaways

  • A lawyer who goes to trial has actually tried cases in Kansas courts, not just threatened to—ask for the number of trials they have taken to verdict in the past three to five years.
  • Settlement pressure often comes from the lawyer's fee structure; if they earn the same percentage whether you settle or try the case, they have no financial reason to push you toward trial.
  • Wichita car accident cases are filed in Sedgwick County District Court, and your lawyer should have experience in that specific courthouse and with the judges who hear these cases.
  • Insurance companies negotiate differently with lawyers known for trying cases—they make higher offers earlier because they know you will not accept lowball settlements.
  • Trial readiness means your lawyer has already prepared your case as if trial is certain, not as a backup plan they will scramble to execute at the last minute.

How to verify a lawyer actually tries cases in Wichita

Ask directly: "How many car accident cases have you taken to trial verdict in the past three years?" A lawyer with trial experience will give you a number. If they say "I have tried many cases" or "I am trial-ready," that is not an answer—it is avoidance. You want a specific count.

Ask where those trials happened. Wichita car accident cases go to Sedgwick County District Court. If a lawyer's trial experience is mostly in small claims court, or in counties outside Wichita, that experience does not transfer directly. You want someone who knows the judges in Sedgwick County, understands how they rule on evidence, and has stood in front of them before.

Request a list of verdicts or settlements. Many lawyers publish case results on their websites or in marketing materials. If they do not, ask them to provide three to five examples of cases similar to yours—same type of injury, similar liability situation—and what the outcome was. If they refuse or say they cannot share that information, that is a red flag.

Check the Kansas Bar Association website. You can search for any licensed attorney and see their disciplinary history. This does not tell you if they try cases, but it tells you if they have been sanctioned, suspended, or faced complaints. A clean record is baseline; it is not a substitute for asking about trial experience.

The fee structure that does not punish you for going to trial

Most car accident lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover—typically 33 percent if the case settles before trial, and 40 percent if it goes to trial. That difference exists because trial takes more time and carries more risk for the lawyer. That is normal and fair.

What matters is whether your lawyer discloses that difference upfront and whether they are honest about what it means. If a lawyer quotes you 33 percent and then tells you later that it jumps to 40 percent if you reject a settlement offer, they are using the fee increase as a pressure tactic. A lawyer committed to trial will explain the fee structure in your first meeting and will not use it as leverage to push you toward settlement.

Some lawyers charge a flat fee for trial preparation, separate from the contingency percentage. This is less common in car accident cases but worth asking about. It can align incentives more clearly: the lawyer is paid for trial work regardless of outcome, so they have no financial reason to steer you away from court.

Read your fee agreement carefully. It should specify the percentage at each stage (pre-trial, trial, appeal), what costs you pay separately (court filing fees, informed witness fees, deposition transcripts), and what happens if you reject a settlement offer. If the agreement is vague or uses language like "fees may vary," ask for clarification in writing before you sign.

What trial experience looks like in practice

A lawyer with real trial experience approaches your case differently from the start. They are not waiting to see if settlement works out; they are preparing as if trial is the plan. That means they have already identified what evidence will matter to a jury, what weaknesses in your case need to be addressed, and what the other side's strongest arguments will be.

They will have taken depositions—recorded testimony from the other driver, witnesses, and sometimes medical experts—not to fish for information, but to lock in testimony and find contradictions they can use at trial. They will have retained accident reconstruction experts or medical experts if your case needs them, not at the last minute, but early enough to shape strategy.

They will know the local rules of Sedgwick County District Court—how judges handle discovery disputes, how strict they are about important date, what evidence they allow, and how they manage jury selection. A lawyer who has tried cases in that courthouse knows these things from experience, not from reading a manual.

When settlement talks happen, a trial-ready lawyer negotiates from strength. The insurance company knows the case is prepared for court. They know this lawyer will not fold under pressure. That shifts the negotiation: instead of the company offering low numbers and waiting to see if you will take them, they make a serious offer earlier, because they understand the cost and risk of going to trial against a prepared opponent.

Red flags that a lawyer is not trial-ready

A lawyer who says they "prefer to settle" or "most of my cases settle" is telling you they do not try many cases. Settlement is fine, but preference for settlement is not the same as trial readiness. You want someone who settles because it is the right outcome for your case, not because they avoid trial.

If a lawyer pushes you to accept a settlement offer quickly, or tells you that you should take it "while it is on the table," be cautious. Insurance companies do not withdraw offers because time passes. That pressure is coming from your lawyer, not the insurance company, and it usually means they want to close the file.

If a lawyer cannot explain the Sedgwick County court system, the judges, or the local rules without looking them up, they do not have trial experience in Wichita. You can ask: "Which judge in Sedgwick County would hear my case if we go to trial?" A lawyer with local experience will know the answer or will know how to find out quickly.

If a lawyer's website or marketing materials do not mention trial experience or case verdicts, that is not proof they do not try cases—but it is a reason to ask directly. Lawyers who try cases usually say so, because it is a selling point.

How to narrow your search in Wichita

Start with the Kansas Bar Association's lawyer referral service. You can search by practice area (personal injury or car accidents) and location (Wichita or Sedgwick County). This gives you a list of licensed attorneys, but it does not rank them by trial experience.

Call three to five lawyers on that list. In each call, ask: "How many car accident cases have you tried to verdict in the past three years?" and "Where did those trials happen?" You are not looking for the lawyer with the most trials—you are looking for someone with enough trial experience that they are comfortable with it, and who is honest about what they have done.

Ask if they will give you references—other clients who went to trial and can speak to how the lawyer prepared and performed. Not all lawyers will provide this, but some will. A client who actually went through trial with a lawyer can tell you things no marketing material can.

Meet in person if possible. A phone consultation tells you if a lawyer is willing to talk; an in-person meeting tells you if they are organized, if they listen, and if they seem confident about your case. Confidence based on trial experience feels different from confidence based on optimism.

What happens after you hire a trial-ready lawyer

Your lawyer will likely send a demand letter to the insurance company within a few weeks. This letter lays out your injuries, your damages (medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering), and what you are asking for. A lawyer with trial experience writes this letter as if it will be read by a judge or jury, because they know it might be.

The insurance company will respond with an offer, usually lower than your demand. Your lawyer will advise you on whether that offer is reasonable given your injuries and the strength of your case. If it is not, they will tell you so and explain what trial would look like—how long it would take, what it would cost, what the risks are, and what a jury might award.

Settlement talks may go back and forth for weeks or months. During this time, your lawyer is also preparing for trial: gathering evidence, taking depositions, retaining experts, and filing motions. This dual preparation is what trial readiness looks like. You are not choosing between settlement and trial; you are preparing for trial while negotiating settlement.

If settlement does not happen, your case will be scheduled for trial in Sedgwick County District Court. Your lawyer will prepare you to testify, will walk you through what to expect, and will handle the legal arguments and evidence presentation. You will have a say in every major decision, but your lawyer will be the one steering the case through the courtroom.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a lawyer who tries cases cost more than one who settles?

Not upfront. Most car accident lawyers charge the same contingency percentage whether they settle or try your case—usually 33 percent for settlement, 40 percent for trial. You pay more only if you recover more, and trial sometimes means a larger recovery. You should never pay an hourly rate or upfront fee for a car accident case.

What if I want to settle but my lawyer wants to try the case?

You have the final say. Your lawyer advises, but you decide whether to accept a settlement offer. If your lawyer is pressuring you to reject a fair offer so they can try the case, that is a conflict of interest and a reason to find a different lawyer. A good lawyer will tell you honestly whether an offer is reasonable, and will respect your decision either way.

How long does a car accident trial take in Wichita?

Most car accident trials in Sedgwick County District Court take two to five days. Jury selection usually takes a few hours, opening statements and evidence take one to three days, and closing arguments take a few hours. Your lawyer should tell you what to expect based on the complexity of your case.

Can I switch lawyers if the one I hired does not seem trial-ready?

Yes, but timing matters. If your case is early, switching is straightforward. If you are close to trial or settlement, switching becomes complicated and may delay your case. If you have concerns about your lawyer's trial readiness, raise them directly first. If they cannot address your concerns, you can fire them and hire someone else, though you may owe the first lawyer a portion of any recovery.

What should I ask a lawyer about their trial experience in our first meeting?

Ask: "How many car accident cases have you tried to verdict in the past three years?" "Where did those trials happen?" "Can you tell me about a case similar to mine that went to trial?" and "What is your fee structure if we go to trial?" The answers will tell you whether this lawyer has real trial experience or is just willing to talk about it.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.