Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Finding a Car Accident Attorney in Wichita With Trial Experience

What trial experience means and why it matters in a car accident case

Trial experience means an attorney has actually taken cases to court in front of a judge or jury, not just settled them in negotiation. This matters because insurance companies know the difference. A lawyer who has tried cases—and won some—has credibility in settlement talks that a lawyer who has never been to trial does not. When an insurer knows you have representation willing to go to court, they tend to offer more reasonable settlements rather than risk a jury verdict.

Most car accident cases in Wichita settle before trial. But settlement amounts depend partly on what a jury might award if the case went forward. An attorney with trial wins in similar cases can point to those verdicts and say, "A jury awarded $X in a case like yours." An attorney without trial experience cannot make that argument with the same weight.

Trial experience also means your attorney knows how to prepare a case for court from the beginning—how to preserve evidence, how to depose witnesses, how to build a record that holds up under cross-examination. These skills matter even in settlement negotiations, because the other side can see whether your case is trial-ready.

Key Takeaways

  • Trial experience means an attorney has taken cases to court and obtained verdicts, which gives them credibility in settlement negotiations that settlement-only attorneys lack.
  • Insurance adjusters offer higher settlements when they know your attorney is prepared and willing to try the case rather than accept a lowball offer.
  • You can ask a potential attorney directly how many car accident cases they have tried to verdict in the past five years and what the outcomes were.
  • Wichita attorneys with trial experience often list their verdicts and settlements on their websites or in their bios, so you can research their track record before you call.
  • An attorney does not need to have tried hundreds of cases, but they should have tried enough similar cases that they can speak from real courtroom experience.

How to find attorneys in Wichita with documented trial experience

Start by searching for "Wichita car accident attorney" or "Wichita personal injury attorney" and look at the websites of firms that appear in the results. Most attorneys with significant trial experience list their verdicts and settlements prominently—often on a "Results" or "Verdicts" page. These pages show the case type, the amount awarded or settled, and sometimes the year. This is public information and a sign the attorney is confident in their record.

When you find an attorney whose results page shows car accident cases similar to yours, note the amounts and the years. Then call and ask directly: "How many car accident cases have you tried to verdict in the past five years?" Listen for a specific number, not a vague answer like "many" or "quite a few." An attorney who has tried 10 to 20 car accident cases to verdict in five years has real trial experience. An attorney who has tried two or three has some, but less.

You can also check the Kansas Bar Association website to verify that an attorney is licensed in good standing. The Bar does not publish trial records, but it will confirm the attorney is authorized to practice in Kansas.

What questions to ask about an attorney's trial background

When you speak to an attorney, ask these specific questions: "How many car accident cases have you tried to verdict?" "What was the range of verdicts you obtained?" "Have you tried cases in Sedgwick County District Court?" and "What percentage of your cases go to trial versus settle?"

The last question matters because it tells you whether the attorney actually tries cases or mostly settles. An attorney who settles 95 percent of cases may be good at negotiation, but they have less trial experience than one who tries 20 to 30 percent. There is no single "right" percentage—some cases should settle—but the number tells you how often they step into a courtroom.

Ask also whether the attorney will be the one trying your case or whether they will hand it off to another lawyer if it goes to trial. Some firms have trial specialists who take over at that stage. That is not necessarily bad, but you should know it upfront. If you want the attorney you hire to be the one in court, say so and ask whether they can commit to that.

Understanding the difference between settlement experience and trial experience

An attorney can be excellent at settling cases without having tried many to verdict. Settlement is a skill—knowing how to value a case, how to negotiate with adjusters, how to push back on lowball offers. But it is a different skill from trial work. A trial attorney has to know evidence rules, how to examine and cross-examine witnesses, how to present a case to a jury, and how to respond when things go wrong in court.

Some attorneys do both well. Others are stronger in one area than the other. The question for you is what you need. If your case is straightforward and likely to settle, settlement experience may be enough. If liability is disputed or your injuries are serious and the insurer is offering far less than your case is worth, trial experience becomes more important because it strengthens your negotiating position.

How trial experience affects settlement offers

Insurance companies have data on what juries award in different types of cases in different counties. They know, for example, what a Sedgwick County jury typically awards for a soft-tissue injury in a rear-end collision, or for a broken arm in a T-bone crash. When they evaluate your claim, they estimate what a jury might award and then offer less—their profit margin.

When your attorney has tried similar cases and won verdicts at or above what the insurer is offering, the insurer's calculation changes. They now know that if the case goes to trial, they might lose more than they would pay to settle. That knowledge moves the settlement offer up.

This is why an attorney's trial record is part of your negotiating power. You are not paying for the trial experience to use it; you are paying for it so you do not have to use it—because the other side will take you seriously and offer you a fair settlement rather than risk court.

What to look for in an attorney's verdict history

When you review an attorney's verdicts and settlements, look for cases similar to yours in type and severity. A verdict for $500,000 in a catastrophic spinal injury case does not tell you much about what your whiplash case is worth. But a verdict for $45,000 in a similar whiplash case with comparable medical bills and lost wages is relevant.

Also note the year. A verdict from 2015 is less current than one from 2023, because jury awards and settlement values change over time. Recent verdicts are a better guide to what your case might be worth today.

Be aware that attorneys sometimes list "settlements" and "verdicts" together, and they are not the same thing. A verdict is what a jury awarded after trial. A settlement is what the parties agreed to before trial. Both show the attorney's ability to obtain money for clients, but a verdict is stronger proof of trial experience because it means the case actually went to court.

Red flags when evaluating an attorney's experience

Be cautious if an attorney's website lists no verdicts or settlements at all, or if the results page is vague—"We have recovered millions for our clients" without specific case information. This often means the attorney does not have a strong track record to show, or they are new to practice.

Also be cautious if an attorney claims to have tried "hundreds" of cases to verdict. That number is unrealistic for most attorneys in a five-year period. A more believable claim is "dozens" or a specific number like "47 verdicts in the past six years."

If an attorney is evasive when you ask directly about their trial experience—if they deflect to talk about their settlement skills instead, or if they say "most cases settle so trial experience is not important"—that is a sign they may not have much trial experience to discuss. A confident attorney with a real trial record will answer the question directly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need an attorney with trial experience if I think my case will settle?

Most cases do settle, but having an attorney with trial experience strengthens your negotiating position even if your case never goes to court. Insurers offer higher settlements when they know your attorney is prepared and willing to try the case. You are paying for the credibility, not necessarily for the trial itself.

How many trials does an attorney need to have done before they have "real" trial experience?

There is no magic number, but an attorney who has tried 10 to 20 car accident cases to verdict in the past five years has meaningful trial experience. An attorney who has tried two or three has some experience but less depth. Ask for the specific number and the years, and ask to see the verdicts.

What if the attorney I want to hire has trial experience but has not tried a case in the past two years?

Ask why. If they have been busy settling cases, that is one thing. If they have stepped back from trial work, that is another. You want to know whether they are still actively trying cases and staying current with courtroom procedure and jury dynamics. An attorney who has not been in a courtroom in three years may be rusty.

Can I ask an attorney for references from past clients?

You can ask, but most attorneys cannot share client names due to confidentiality. What they can do is describe cases they have handled—the type of injury, the outcome, the settlement or verdict range—without naming the client. If an attorney refuses to describe any past cases, that is a red flag.

Does an attorney need trial experience in Sedgwick County specifically, or is experience in other Kansas counties enough?

Experience in Sedgwick County is ideal because you will be tried there and the attorney will know the judges, the local court rules, and how local juries tend to decide cases. But an attorney with trial experience in other Kansas counties has transferable skills. What matters most is that they have actually tried cases, not just where they tried them.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.