Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When Distracted Driving Laws Hold Up in Court

What courts have actually decided about distracted driving ordinances

Distracted driving ordinances are lawful in most places, but not everywhere and not in every form. Courts have upheld bans on texting while driving, handheld phone use, and eating or grooming behind the wheel. The legal reasoning is straightforward: states and cities have the power to regulate traffic safety, and distracted driving causes real harm—the data on accidents and deaths is substantial enough that courts treat these laws as a reasonable use of that power.

The catch is that some ordinances have been struck down or narrowly interpreted because they were written too broadly. A law that bans "use of a mobile device" without defining what that means might fail if it catches activities courts think are protected—like hands-free calling or GPS navigation. A few states have also had constitutional challenges succeed on free speech grounds when the ordinance targeted specific content (like banning texting but not other phone use) without a clear safety reason.

Whether a distracted driving ordinance in your state or city will hold up depends on how it is written, what it actually prohibits, and whether it has been challenged in your jurisdiction. If you are facing a ticket, the ordinance's exact language matters enormously to your defense.

Key Takeaways

  • Most distracted driving ordinances survive legal challenge because courts recognize traffic safety as a legitimate government purpose.
  • Ordinances written too broadly—banning all "mobile device use" without exceptions for GPS or hands-free calls—are more vulnerable to being overturned or narrowly read by judges.
  • A few states have had distracted driving laws struck down on constitutional grounds, usually when the law targeted specific speech or activity without clear safety justification.
  • If you received a ticket, the exact wording of your state or city ordinance and any prior court decisions in your jurisdiction are what determine whether the law will hold up against your defense.

How courts test whether a traffic safety law is constitutional

Courts use a two-part test for traffic laws. First, they ask whether the government has a legitimate reason to pass the law. For distracted driving, that reason is clear: preventing accidents and deaths. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration data on distraction-related crashes is part of the public record, and courts treat it as sufficient justification.

Second, courts ask whether the law is narrowly tailored to that purpose—meaning it does not restrict more conduct than necessary to achieve the safety goal. This is where distracted driving ordinances sometimes fail. A law that bans all handheld phone use while driving is narrowly tailored because handheld phones are genuinely distracting. A law that bans all "electronic device use" might not be, because it could catch a passenger's device or a mounted GPS, which do not pose the same safety risk.

The strength of the safety evidence matters. If a city passes a distracted driving ordinance without any documented problem—no accident data, no traffic study—a court might find the law is not actually addressing a real safety concern and strike it down. Most jurisdictions that have faced legal challenge have won because they documented the problem first.

Which distracted driving bans have survived court challenges

Texting-while-driving bans have been upheld consistently across the country. Courts have found that texting is sufficiently distracting and that banning it does not interfere with any protected activity. The same is true for handheld phone use while driving—most states and cities have these laws, and they have held up.

Bans on eating, grooming, or other non-phone distractions have also survived, though fewer jurisdictions have passed them. When challenged, courts have upheld these laws on the same reasoning: the government can regulate conduct that creates a traffic safety risk, even if the conduct is not inherently illegal.

The ordinances that have fared worst are those that tried to ban broad categories without clear definitions. A law banning "use of a mobile device" without carving out exceptions for hands-free calling or GPS navigation has been narrowly interpreted by courts in some states, meaning judges read the law to exclude those activities even if the text does not explicitly say so. In a few cases, courts have struck down such laws entirely and required the legislature to rewrite them more clearly.

Where distracted driving laws have been challenged or limited

California's distracted driving law has been litigated extensively, but courts have upheld the core ban on handheld phone use. However, courts have read the law narrowly to exclude hands-free devices and GPS, even though the statute's language is broad. This means the law survives, but its reach is smaller than the text suggests.

New York has faced similar litigation. The state's texting ban has been upheld, but courts have clarified that it applies only to handheld use, not to voice-activated or hands-free systems. Again, the law stands, but its scope is narrower than written.

A small number of states have had distracted driving ordinances struck down on constitutional grounds. These cases are rare and usually involve ordinances that targeted specific speech or activity in a way that seemed arbitrary. For example, if a city banned texting but not voice calling, and could not explain why texting posed a greater safety risk, a court might find the distinction unconstitutional. But these cases are exceptions, not the rule.

What happens if you are ticketed under a distracted driving ordinance

If you received a ticket, your defense depends on whether the ordinance itself is lawful and whether your conduct actually violated it. You have two possible arguments: the ordinance is unconstitutional or overbroad, or your conduct did not violate the ordinance as written.

The first argument—that the ordinance is unconstitutional—is difficult to win unless there is already a court decision in your state or circuit striking down the same law. If you are the first person to challenge it, you will need to hire an attorney and be prepared for a longer case. If courts in your jurisdiction have already upheld the ordinance, your chances are low.

The second argument is often stronger. If the ordinance bans handheld phone use and you were using a hands-free device, you did not violate it. If it bans texting and you were using voice commands, you did not violate it. Read the ordinance word-for-word and compare it to what you were actually doing. Many tickets are dismissed because the conduct does not match the law's language.

How to find out what your state or city ordinance actually says

Your state's distracted driving law is in the vehicle code or traffic code, usually available on your state legislature's website. Search for "distracted driving" or "handheld phone" plus your state name. City ordinances are usually on the city clerk's website or the municipal code database.

Read the exact language of the law you are accused of breaking. Note what it prohibits, what it allows, and what definitions it uses. If the ordinance says "handheld mobile device," it may not explore to a mounted phone. If it says "texting," it may not explore to voice calls or GPS use. These distinctions matter in court.

If you are facing a ticket, bring the ordinance text to your court date or to an attorney consultation. The specific wording is your strongest defense tool. Courts interpret these laws based on their language, not on what the legislature might have intended or what other states do.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a city ordinance against distracted driving be struck down if the state already has a law?

Yes, but only if the city law is stricter or conflicts with the state law. Most cities pass ordinances that match or reinforce state law, and courts allow this. If a city law is weaker than state law, it is usually not challenged. If it is stricter—for example, banning all phone use while a state law allows hands-free—courts will usually uphold it unless it is so broad that it becomes unreasonable.

What if the distracted driving ordinance does not define what counts as "distracted"?

A vague ordinance is vulnerable to challenge. If the law does not define what conduct it prohibits, a court may strike it down or read it narrowly. For example, if an ordinance bans "distracted driving" without saying what that means, a court might interpret it to cover only the most obvious cases—texting or handheld phone use—and exclude other activities. Vagueness is a legitimate defense, but you will likely need an attorney to raise it effectively.

Do hands-free devices have the same legal protection as handheld phones?

It depends on the ordinance. Most laws that ban handheld phone use explicitly allow hands-free devices. Some older or broader ordinances do not mention hands-free at all, which creates ambiguity. Courts have usually read these laws to exclude hands-free devices, but the safest approach is to check your specific ordinance's language and any court decisions interpreting it in your state.

Can I challenge a distracted driving ticket if the ordinance has never been tested in court?

You can raise a constitutional challenge, but it is difficult and expensive without an attorney. You would need to argue that the ordinance is unconstitutional on its face or as applied to you. If no court in your jurisdiction has struck down the ordinance, you are arguing something new, and judges are reluctant to do that without strong legal reasoning. An attorney can tell you whether your jurisdiction has any case law that supports your position.

What if I was using GPS navigation and got a ticket for handheld phone use?

This is a strong defense if your ordinance bans handheld phone use but does not explicitly ban GPS. Most courts have held that GPS navigation is not the same as phone use, and a ticket based on GPS alone should be dismissed. Bring evidence that you were using GPS—your phone's location history, your navigation app, or a mounted phone holder—to show you were not using the phone for communication.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.