What to Do After a Hit and Run: Finding Legal Help and Understanding Your Options
A hit and run attorney helps you recover damages when a driver leaves the scene of an accident
When someone hits your car and drives away, you face two separate problems: finding the driver, and paying for damage or injury they caused. A hit and run attorney handles the legal side — they work with police, your insurance company, and sometimes private investigators to identify the at-fault driver, and they pursue compensation through your own insurance or by suing once the driver is found.
The reason you need an attorney is that hit and run cases are more complicated than standard car accidents. The other driver is not there to exchange information. Your own insurance may initially deny your claim. The police investigation may stall. An attorney knows how to push each of these forward and knows which compensation routes are actually available to you in your state.
Key Takeaways
- Hit and run is a crime, so the police investigation happens separately from your insurance claim and any lawsuit — an attorney coordinates across all three.
- Your own uninsured motorist coverage usually covers hit and run damage, but insurance companies often deny these claims initially and require documentation of the hit and run.
- An attorney can hire a private investigator to find the driver using witness statements, traffic camera footage, and vehicle descriptions — something police may not prioritize.
- If the driver is found, you can sue them directly; if not found, your uninsured motorist claim is your main path to recovery.
- Most hit and run attorneys work on contingency, meaning you pay nothing upfront and they take a percentage of what you recover.
How police investigations and insurance claims work in parallel
When you report a hit and run to police, they file a report and may investigate — but police resources are limited, and hit and run cases without serious injury often sit low on the priority list. The police report itself is important because your insurance company will ask for it before processing your claim.
Your insurance claim moves on its own timeline. You report the accident to your insurer, provide the police report number, and describe what happened. Your insurer then decides whether to cover the damage under your uninsured motorist property damage coverage (for vehicle damage) or uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage (for injuries). Many insurers initially deny these claims, saying you did not do enough to identify the driver or that the accident does not meet their definition of a hit and run.
An attorney's job is to push back on denials, gather evidence the police may have missed, and sometimes hire investigators to find the driver while the police case is still open. If the driver is found, the attorney can then pivot to a direct lawsuit against them. If the driver is never found, the attorney makes sure your uninsured motorist claim is paid in full.
What evidence matters when the driver is unknown
Without a license plate or driver information, your case depends on what you and witnesses can describe. An attorney will ask you for details most people do not think to write down: the vehicle's color, size, body style, any distinctive damage or markings, the direction it went, the time of day, and whether you heard or saw anything about the driver. They will also ask whether there were security cameras nearby — at a business, gas station, traffic light, or parking lot.
Witness statements are often the strongest evidence. If someone saw the accident or the other vehicle leaving, their account can narrow the search significantly. An attorney will help you locate witnesses and get their statements in writing, which is much more useful to police and investigators than a casual conversation.
Traffic camera footage from nearby businesses or municipal cameras can show the vehicle and sometimes the license plate. An attorney knows how to request this footage formally — police can do it, but an attorney can also subpoena it if the business is slow to respond. Dashcam footage from your own vehicle or nearby drivers is equally valuable and sometimes surfaces weeks after the accident through social media or neighborhood apps.
When and how to hire a private investigator
If the police investigation stalls or you want to move faster, a private investigator can search for the hit and run driver using the information you have. They contact witnesses, review traffic camera footage, check repair shops for vehicles matching the description, and sometimes use databases of registered vehicles in your area. This costs money — typically $1,000 to $5,000 depending on how much work is needed — but if the investigator finds the driver, your recovery becomes much larger.
Most hit and run attorneys have relationships with investigators and can hire one as part of your case. Because the attorney works on contingency (taking a percentage of what you recover rather than charging you hourly), they will only hire an investigator if they believe finding the driver will result in enough compensation to justify the cost. This means the attorney is making a business decision about your case's value, not just following a standard process.
You can also hire a private investigator independently, but you should discuss this with an attorney first. An investigator's findings need to be presented correctly to police and insurance companies, and an attorney can make sure the investigation is done in a way that holds up legally.
Uninsured motorist coverage: what it covers and why insurers deny claims
Most car insurance policies include uninsured motorist coverage, though the amount varies. This coverage is designed to pay you when the at-fault driver has no insurance or cannot be identified. In a hit and run, you typically have both problems at once.
Insurance companies deny hit and run uninsured motorist claims for several reasons: they say you did not provide enough evidence that a hit and run actually occurred, they claim you did not cooperate with the investigation, or they argue that the damage is too minor to meet the policy's threshold. Some insurers also deny claims because they say you failed to report the accident within a certain timeframe, though this is often not a valid reason if you reported it as soon as reasonably possible.
An attorney challenges these denials by gathering the evidence the insurer says is missing — the police report, witness statements, photos of the damage, medical records if you were injured, and documentation of your cooperation with police. If the insurer still refuses to pay, the attorney can file a lawsuit against your own insurance company to force them to honor the policy. This is called bad faith litigation, and it can result in the insurer paying not just your claim but also your attorney's fees and sometimes additional damages for the wrongful denial.
What happens if the driver is found
If the hit and run driver is identified — whether through police investigation, a private investigator, or a tip from the public — your case changes significantly. The driver is now a known defendant, and you can sue them directly for all damages: vehicle repair or replacement, medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and sometimes punitive damages (extra money meant to punish the driver for fleeing the scene).
At this point, your attorney will investigate the driver's insurance coverage. If they have insurance, the claim goes to their insurer. If they do not have insurance or their coverage is too low, you may still recover through your own uninsured motorist coverage, and you can also pursue a judgment against the driver personally — though collecting from an individual is often harder than collecting from an insurance company.
The driver may also face criminal charges for leaving the scene of an accident. The severity depends on whether anyone was injured and the laws in your state. A criminal conviction can strengthen your civil case (the lawsuit for money), because it establishes that the driver was at fault. However, the criminal case and your civil case move separately, and you do not have to wait for the criminal case to finish before suing.
How contingency fees work and what to expect from an attorney
Most hit and run attorneys work on contingency, meaning they charge no upfront fee and instead take a percentage of the money you recover — typically 25 to 40 percent depending on the complexity of the case and whether it goes to trial. If you recover nothing, you pay nothing. This arrangement means the attorney has a financial incentive to find the driver and maximize your recovery.
Before hiring an attorney, ask what is included in their fee. Some attorneys charge contingency on the settlement or judgment but bill you separately for investigator costs, court filing fees, and informed witness fees. Others cover these costs upfront and deduct them from your recovery. The difference can be significant, so get this in writing.
You should also ask the attorney how they communicate with you, how often they update you on the case, and what they expect from you. Hit and run cases can take months or years if the driver is never found, so you want an attorney who will keep you informed and explain what is happening at each stage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to report a hit and run to police to recover money?
Yes, most insurance policies require a police report before they will pay an uninsured motorist claim. Even if you think the damage is minor, file a report. The police report number becomes part of your insurance claim and is essential if you later hire an attorney. If you did not report it when ready, report it as soon as you realize it was a hit and run — insurers may question the delay, but an attorney can explain why you did not report it right away.
What if I was hit in a parking lot and no one saw it happen?
Parking lot hit and runs are common and harder to solve because there are usually no witnesses. Focus on finding security camera footage from the parking lot or nearby businesses, and ask the property manager or business owner to check their cameras. An attorney or private investigator can also help request this footage formally. Your uninsured motorist claim should still cover the damage even without a witness, though the insurer may initially deny it.
Can I sue the hit and run driver for pain and suffering if I was injured?
Yes, if the driver is found, you can sue for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering from your injuries. If the driver is never found, your uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage should cover these costs, though the amount depends on your policy limits. An attorney can help you document your injuries and calculate what you are owed.
How long do I have to file a lawsuit after a hit and run?
The time limit depends on your state and is called the statute of limitations. For car accidents, it is usually two to six years, but it can be shorter in some states. Do not wait — hire an attorney as soon as possible so they can begin investigating and preserve evidence before it disappears.
What if my insurance company says I did not do enough to find the driver?
This is a common reason insurers deny hit and run claims, but it is often not valid. You are not required to hire a private investigator or do police work yourself. You are required to cooperate with police and provide accurate information about the accident. An attorney can push back on this denial by showing that you did cooperate and that the insurer's standard is unreasonable.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.