Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Happens After a First-Time Hit and Run: Your Legal Situation and Next Steps

A first-time hit and run is a criminal charge, not a civil accident claim

If you left the scene of an accident without providing your name, contact information, or insurance details, you have committed a hit and run — regardless of who caused the collision or how minor the damage appears. This is a criminal offense in every state, not a traffic violation you can settle with the other driver or your insurance company later.

The difference matters enormously. A criminal charge means police can arrest you, you may face jail time, and a conviction goes on your permanent record. You cannot straightforward apologize to the other driver or pay them money to make it go away. The state is the prosecutor, not the person whose car you hit.

What you do in the next few days — whether you contact a lawyer, whether you speak to police, what you say — will shape whether this becomes a misdemeanor or a felony, whether you serve time, and what your record looks like for years afterward.

Key Takeaways

  • Hit and run is a criminal charge in every state, and the penalties depend on whether anyone was injured and how much property damage occurred.
  • Contacting a criminal defense lawyer before speaking to police is the single most important step you can take — anything you say to police can be used against you in court.
  • Turning yourself in voluntarily, with a lawyer present, often results in lower charges and lighter sentences than being arrested later.
  • Penalties range from a few hundred dollars and license suspension for property-damage-only cases to felony charges, jail time, and permanent record consequences for injury cases.
  • Your insurance will not cover a hit and run you committed, and you may face civil liability from the other driver on top of criminal penalties.

How hit and run charges differ by injury and damage

Most states divide hit and run into two categories: property damage only, and injury or death. The category you fall into determines whether you face misdemeanor or felony charges and how serious the potential penalties are.

Property damage only — you hit a parked car, a fence, a mailbox, or another object, and no one was injured — is typically a misdemeanor. Penalties usually include fines (often $500 to $1,500, though this varies by state), points on your driving record, license suspension for 6 months to a year, and possible jail time of up to 6 months. Some states allow you to reduce charges by paying restitution to the property owner.

Injury or death — you hit another vehicle and someone was hurt, or you caused a fatal accident — is almost always a felony. Felony hit and run carries much steeper penalties: jail sentences of 1 to 15 years depending on the state and severity, substantial fines, permanent license revocation, and a felony record that affects employment, housing, and professional licensing for life.

The state where the accident happened determines which laws explore. If you hit someone in California, California law governs the charge. If you were driving through another state when it happened, that state's law applies. This matters because penalties vary significantly — a property-damage hit and run in one state might carry a $300 fine and 3-month suspension, while another state imposes $2,000 and a year-long suspension.

Why contacting a lawyer before police is critical

Your instinct may be to call police and explain what happened, especially if you feel guilty or want to "get ahead of it." Do not do this without a lawyer present. Anything you say to police — even if you think it helps your case — becomes evidence that the prosecutor can use against you in court.

Police are trained to ask questions that seem innocent but are designed to get you to admit you knew you were in an accident, that you left intentionally, or that you were aware someone might be hurt. Statements like "I didn't realize I hit anything" or "I was scared so I left" both admit to the core elements of the crime. Once you say them, you cannot take them back, and your lawyer cannot make them disappear.

A criminal defense lawyer can advise you on whether turning yourself in voluntarily is the right move for your specific situation, can negotiate with the prosecutor before charges are filed, and can be present during any police interview to protect your rights. Many lawyers will negotiate a voluntary surrender, which often results in lower charges or lighter sentences than being arrested later.

If you cannot afford a lawyer, you have the right to request a public defender at your first court appearance. Do not wait — request one when ready. In the meantime, do not speak to police except to give your name and say you want a lawyer.

The difference between misdemeanor and felony hit and run

Whether you face misdemeanor or felony charges depends primarily on whether anyone was injured. Some states also consider the amount of property damage or whether you had a prior hit and run conviction.

Charge TypeTypical TriggerPossible Jail TimeLicense ImpactRecord Consequence
MisdemeanorProperty damage only, no injuryUp to 6 months6 months to 1 year suspensionMisdemeanor record; can sometimes be expunged
FelonyAny injury, or death1 to 15 yearsPermanent revocation in many statesFelony record; permanent in most states

A felony conviction means you lose certain rights: you cannot vote in some states while incarcerated, you cannot own firearms, you may lose professional licenses (nursing, teaching, law, real estate), and you will face discrimination in housing and employment for the rest of your life. Even after you serve your sentence, employers can see the conviction, and many will not hire you.

A misdemeanor is less severe but still serious. It stays on your record and can affect job prospects, especially for positions requiring a clean driving record or background check. Some misdemeanors can be expunged (erased from your record) after a waiting period, but this depends on your state and the specific offense.

What happens if you turn yourself in voluntarily

Turning yourself in with a lawyer is often the best outcome available to you. It shows the court that you took responsibility, it prevents the more serious charges that sometimes come with arrest warrants, and it often results in the prosecutor offering a lower charge or lighter sentence.

The process typically works like this: your lawyer contacts the prosecutor or the police department and arranges a voluntary surrender. You appear at a police station or courthouse at an agreed-upon time with your lawyer. You are booked (fingerprinted, photographed, background checked), and you may be held for a few hours while bail is arranged. In many cases, you are released on your own recognizance (a promise to return for court) or with a low bail amount, especially if you have no prior criminal record and strong ties to the community.

At your first court appearance, you will be informed of the charges, told of your rights, and given a chance to request a public defender if you cannot afford a lawyer. Your lawyer can then begin negotiating with the prosecutor. Many cases are resolved through a plea agreement — you plead guilty to a reduced charge in exchange for a lighter sentence. This avoids a trial and gives you certainty about the outcome.

If you wait and are arrested later — because the other driver reported you, because police found your vehicle, or because a witness identified you — you face arrest without warning, possible jail time before bail is set, and a prosecutor who is less willing to negotiate because you did not come forward voluntarily.

Insurance will not cover a hit and run you committed

Your auto insurance policy does not cover damage or injuries you cause in a hit and run. This is true even if you have comprehensive and collision coverage. Insurance companies exclude coverage for criminal acts, and leaving the scene of an accident is a crime.

This means two things: first, you cannot use your insurance to pay for the other person's medical bills or vehicle damage, so you are personally liable for the full amount. Second, the other driver can sue you in civil court to recover their losses, and they can win a judgment against you even if you are acquitted in criminal court (the standards of proof are different).

If a judgment is entered against you, the other driver can garnish your wages, place a lien on your property, or pursue other collection methods. This debt can follow you for years and affect your credit score. Some states allow you to pay restitution as part of your criminal sentence, which may reduce or eliminate the civil judgment, but this depends on the court and the circumstances.

License suspension and driving privileges after conviction

A hit and run conviction almost always results in license suspension or revocation. For a misdemeanor, suspension typically lasts 6 months to 1 year. For a felony, many states permanently revoke your license, though some allow you to petition for reinstatement after several years.

During suspension, you cannot legally drive. Driving on a suspended license is itself a crime and can result in additional charges, fines, and jail time. Some states offer a hardship license that allows you to drive to work or school during suspension, but you must request this and meet specific criteria.

If your license is revoked permanently, you may be able to petition for reinstatement after 5 to 10 years, depending on your state. Reinstatement usually requires proof that you have completed any court-ordered programs, paid all fines and restitution, and maintained a clean record since the conviction. There is no may provide the petition will be granted.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still be charged if I came back to the scene later?

Possibly, but coming back voluntarily — especially with a lawyer — significantly strengthens your defense and usually results in lower charges. The prosecutor may argue you only returned because you were worried about being caught, but your lawyer can present evidence of your voluntary return as a sign of remorse and responsibility. This is very different from being arrested weeks later.

What if I did not know I hit something?

This is a common defense, but it is difficult to prove. Hit and run law in most states requires only that you knew you were in an accident — not that you knew you caused damage or that someone was hurt. If you felt an impact, heard a noise, or saw something in your mirror, the prosecution will argue you knew. Do not discuss this with police; discuss it only with your lawyer, who can evaluate whether this defense is viable in your case.

Will a hit and run conviction affect my job?

Yes, especially if your job involves driving or requires a background check. Many employers will not hire someone with a felony conviction, and some will not hire someone with a misdemeanor. Even if your current employer does not fire you, future employers will see the conviction. Some professions — nursing, teaching, law, security — have strict rules about criminal convictions and may permanently bar you from licensure.

Can I get the charge reduced or dismissed?

Possibly, depending on the circumstances and your state. A lawyer can negotiate with the prosecutor for a reduced charge (misdemeanor instead of felony, or a different crime altogether), can challenge whether police had probable cause to arrest you, or can identify weaknesses in the evidence. Some cases are dismissed because the other driver cannot be located or because the evidence is insufficient. This is why having a lawyer is critical — they know what defenses and negotiations are possible in your jurisdiction.

What if the other driver was partially at fault for the accident?

Fault in the accident does not matter for the hit and run charge. Even if the other driver caused the collision, you are still guilty of hit and run if you left the scene without providing your information. However, comparative fault may matter in a civil lawsuit the other driver brings against you — if they were partially at fault, it could reduce the amount they can recover. This is another reason to have a lawyer: they can defend you in both the criminal case and any civil case that follows.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.