What To Look For in a Car Accident Attorney in Illinois
Start with whether the attorney handles cases like yours
Not every car accident attorney in Illinois takes the same kinds of cases. Some focus on cases where their client was clearly not at fault. Others take cases where fault is split or unclear. Some work only on cases worth above a certain amount—say $50,000—because smaller cases don't justify their overhead. A few take cases worth $5,000 or less. Before you call, look at their website or call their office and ask: do they take cases where you were partially at fault, or only clear liability cases? Do they have a minimum case value? Do they handle your specific situation—a rear-end collision, an intersection crash, a hit-and-run?
This matters because an attorney who specializes in high-value cases may not want to spend time on yours, even if they're excellent. An attorney who takes only cases with clear liability may drop you if the other driver's insurance company argues you share fault. You want someone whose practice actually fits what happened to you.
Key Takeaways
- Ask whether the attorney takes cases at your case's likely value and whether they handle cases where fault is disputed or shared.
- In Illinois, attorneys typically work on contingency for car accidents, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover—usually 25 to 40 percent—and you pay nothing upfront.
- Check whether the attorney is licensed to practice in Illinois and whether they have disciplinary history through the Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission (ARDC).
- Ask how long cases similar to yours typically take to resolve and whether the attorney will explain settlement offers and your options before accepting any deal.
- Meet the attorney who will actually handle your case, not just a paralegal or intake specialist, before you sign anything.
Understand how the attorney charges and what you'll actually owe
Most car accident attorneys in Illinois work on contingency, which means they take a percentage of what you recover and you pay nothing upfront. The percentage is usually 25 to 40 percent, depending on the attorney and how far the case goes. If the case settles before trial, the percentage is often lower—say 25 percent. If it goes to trial, it may be 33 or 40 percent. If you recover nothing, the attorney gets nothing.
But contingency does not mean free. You will likely owe costs: court filing fees, medical record requests, informed witness fees, deposition costs, and sometimes investigator fees. These can add up to $1,000 to $5,000 or more in a contested case. Ask the attorney upfront: do they advance these costs, or do you pay them as they come? Do you owe them back only if you win, or regardless? Some attorneys advance costs and deduct them from your recovery. Others ask you to pay them out of pocket. Get this in writing before you sign.
Check their license and disciplinary history
Every attorney licensed in Illinois is registered with the Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission (ARDC). You can search their database for free at iardc.org. Search by the attorney's name and look for their license status—it should say "active" or "in good standing." If it says "suspended," "inactive," or "disbarred," do not hire them.
Also look at the disciplinary history section. Minor complaints happen to many attorneys and are often dismissed. But if you see a pattern of complaints about dishonesty, failure to communicate with clients, or mishandling of client funds, that is a real warning. You are not looking for perfection—you are looking for whether this person has a track record of treating clients fairly and following the rules.
Ask about their experience with cases like yours and how long resolution takes
Experience matters, but not in the way many people think. You do not need an attorney who has tried 100 cases at trial. Most car accident cases settle, and settlement skill is different from trial skill. What you want to know is: how many cases similar to yours has this attorney handled? A rear-end collision is different from a left-turn crash, which is different from a hit-and-run. If the attorney has handled dozens of cases like yours, they know what insurance companies typically offer and what a judge or jury would likely award.
Ask how long cases similar to yours typically take to resolve. In Illinois, a straightforward car accident case with clear liability and moderate injury usually settles in 6 to 12 months. A case with disputed fault or serious injury may take 18 months to 2 years or longer. If an attorney promises resolution in 2 months, they are either not being honest or they are pushing you toward a low settlement quickly. Ask for a realistic timeline based on your specific facts.
Meet the attorney who will actually work on your case
Many law firms have intake specialists or paralegals who answer the phone and take initial information. That is normal. But before you sign a retainer agreement, you should speak directly with the attorney who will handle your case. This is not about being difficult—it is about knowing who you are working with and whether you can communicate with them.
In that conversation, ask: will you be the one handling my case, or will someone else take over? How often will you update me? Can I call you with questions, or do I go through a paralegal? What happens if you leave the firm or become unavailable? If the attorney says you will work with a junior attorney or a paralegal most of the time, that is fine—but you should know it upfront and should still meet the person doing the work. If the attorney is evasive about who will handle your case, that is a sign to look elsewhere.
Ask how they handle settlement decisions and whether they push clients toward quick deals
One of the most important moments in your case is when an insurance company makes a settlement offer. You need an attorney who will explain what the offer means, what you would owe in costs and attorney fees, what your case might be worth if you reject it and go to trial, and what the risks are of going to trial. Then you decide—not the attorney.
Some attorneys push clients to settle quickly because it is easier and faster than fighting. Others push toward trial even when settlement is reasonable because they want a bigger fee. Neither is in your interest. Ask the attorney directly: if an insurance company offers $20,000 and you think your case is worth $30,000, will you advise me to take it, reject it, or will you explain both options and let me choose? A good answer is: "I will explain what the offer means, what similar cases have settled for, what a jury might award, and what the risks are of trial. Then you decide, and I will support your decision."
Verify they are responsive and explain things in plain language
During your first conversation, notice whether the attorney listens to your story or cuts you off. Notice whether they explain things in plain English or hide behind legal jargon. Notice whether they answer your questions or deflect. These are not small things. You will be working with this person for months, possibly over a year. If they do not listen now, they will not listen later.
After you hire them, you should be able to reach them or their staff within a few business days with a question. You should receive regular updates—at minimum, when something significant happens in your case. If you send an email, you should get a response within a week. If the attorney is hard to reach or slow to respond during the hiring process, they will be harder to reach once you have signed and they have your case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I hire the attorney with the biggest office or the most ads?
No. Size and advertising budget do not predict how well they will handle your case. A solo attorney or small firm can be excellent. A large firm can be excellent or mediocre. What matters is whether they have handled cases like yours, whether they communicate clearly, and whether you trust them. Look at their actual experience and how they treat you, not their size.
What if an attorney wants me to sign a retainer agreement right away without meeting them?
Do not sign. Any reputable attorney will let you meet them and ask questions before you commit. If they pressure you to sign when ready, that is a red flag. You have time to make this decision carefully.
Can I hire an attorney from outside Illinois if I was in a car accident here?
An out-of-state attorney can advise you, but they cannot represent you in court without being licensed in Illinois or working with an Illinois-licensed attorney. If you want representation, hire someone licensed in Illinois. If you already have a relationship with an out-of-state attorney, ask them to refer you to someone in Illinois they trust.
What should I do if I already signed with an attorney and now I am unhappy?
You can fire your attorney and hire someone else. You will owe the first attorney for work they have done and costs they have advanced, but you are not stuck. If the first attorney refuses to release your file or becomes difficult, you can file a complaint with the ARDC. Most attorneys will cooperate with a transition if you ask clearly and in writing.
Does it matter if the attorney has trial experience if most cases settle?
Yes, but not the way you might think. An attorney does not need to have tried 50 cases to be good. But the insurance company knows whether your attorney will actually go to trial if the settlement offer is too low. If your attorney has never tried a case, the insurance company will offer less because they know you will probably settle. An attorney with some trial experience—even just a few cases—has more leverage in settlement negotiations.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.