Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Do When the Other Driver Hires a Lawyer After Your Accident

The other driver's attorney will contact you directly, and you should not speak with them without your own lawyer present

When the other driver in your accident hires an attorney, that lawyer's job is to protect their client's interests—not yours. Once they have your contact information, they will likely call you, send letters, or both. Anything you say to them can be used against you in a claim or lawsuit. This is true even if you think you are being helpful or honest.

The moment you know the other driver has hired counsel, stop communicating with them directly. If their attorney calls, you can say: "I have received notice that you represent the other party. Please direct all communication to my attorney" or "I do not have an attorney yet, but I will not speak with you without one." Then hang up. Do not answer follow-up calls from that number.

This does not mean you are admitting fault or being uncooperative. It means you are protecting your legal position. Anything you say—even a casual comment about the accident—can be twisted or used out of context later.

Key Takeaways

  • The other driver's attorney represents them, not you, and will use anything you say to strengthen their client's case.
  • You should hire your own attorney before speaking with the other side's lawyer, or refuse to speak with them at all until you do.
  • Your own insurance company may provide a defense attorney at no cost to you, depending on your policy and state law.
  • The other driver's attorney will likely send a demand letter or file a lawsuit; your response important date depends on the type of document and your state's rules.
  • If you cannot afford an attorney, some work on contingency (they take a percentage of any settlement or judgment) or offer free initial consultations.

When your insurance company steps in

If you have liability coverage on your auto insurance policy, your insurer has a legal duty to defend you if the other driver sues. This means they will hire an attorney to represent you at no cost to you—you do not pay the attorney's fees. This attorney works for the insurance company, but their job is to defend you in the lawsuit.

Report the accident to your insurance company when ready, even if you are unsure whether you were at fault. Give them the other driver's name, contact information, and the accident details. Tell them if you have been contacted by the other driver's attorney. Your insurer will then assign a defense attorney and notify the other side's lawyer that you are represented.

Once your insurance company assigns you an attorney, all communication from the other side should go through that attorney. You should not speak directly with the other driver's lawyer, and you should not settle or make any agreement without your attorney's approval.

What happens if you do not have insurance or the other driver sues you personally

If you do not have liability coverage, or if the other driver is suing you for damages beyond your policy limits, you will need to hire your own attorney. Many personal injury attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they take a percentage of any money you recover or any settlement you receive—typically 25 to 40 percent. You pay nothing upfront.

Some attorneys offer a free initial consultation, where you can explain what happened and ask whether they think you have a defense. This is a good way to understand your options without spending money. During that call, be honest about the accident; anything you tell an attorney is protected by attorney-client privilege and cannot be shared with the other side.

If you cannot afford an attorney and do not have a strong defense, you may still want to consult one before responding to any demand letter or lawsuit. Many bar associations have referral services or can point you toward low-cost legal aid programs in your area.

Understanding demand letters and lawsuits

The other driver's attorney will usually start by sending a demand letter—a formal written request for money to settle the claim. The letter will describe the accident, list the other driver's injuries and damages, and state how much money they are demanding. It will also give you a important date to respond, usually 30 days.

A demand letter is not a lawsuit. It is a settlement offer. You do not have to accept it, and you do not have to respond by the important date if you have an attorney—your attorney will handle the response. If you ignore a demand letter and do not have an attorney, the other driver's lawyer may file a lawsuit in court, which does have strict important date you must meet.

If you are sued, you will receive a summons and complaint—official court documents. The summons tells you how many days you have to respond (usually 20 to 30 days, depending on your state). Missing this important date can result in a default judgment against you, meaning the court rules in the other driver's favor without hearing your side. If you receive a summons, contact an attorney when ready.

How to respond to written requests from the other side

The other driver's attorney may send you written questions called interrogatories or requests for documents. These are formal discovery requests—part of the lawsuit process where both sides gather information. Do not answer these yourself or ignore them.

If you have an attorney, your attorney will answer these requests on your behalf. If you do not have an attorney and receive these documents, you have a legal important date to respond (usually 30 days). At that point, you should hire an attorney, because how you answer these questions can significantly affect your case. If you cannot afford an attorney, contact your local bar association or legal aid office for guidance.

Never send documents or written statements directly to the other side's attorney without your own attorney reviewing them first. A single sentence taken out of context can be used against you.

What you should and should not do right now

Do not discuss the accident with anyone except your attorney, your insurance company, and the police (if they ask). Do not post about it on social media, do not text the other driver, and do not try to negotiate directly with them or their attorney.

Do keep all documents related to the accident: the police report, photos of the damage, medical records if you were injured, repair estimates, and any written communication from the other side. Give these to your attorney or insurance company.

Do write down your own account of what happened while it is fresh in your memory, but keep this private and share it only with your attorney. Do not share it with the other driver, their attorney, or anyone on social media.

Do respond to your insurance company's requests for information promptly. They need details to defend you, and delays can hurt your case.

Insurance settlement versus going to court

Most car accident claims settle before trial. Your insurance company's attorney will negotiate with the other driver's attorney. If they reach an agreement on a dollar amount, your insurer will pay it (up to your policy limits), and the case closes. You do not have to go to court.

If the two sides cannot agree on a settlement amount, the case may go to trial. At trial, a judge or jury will hear both sides and decide who was at fault and how much money should be paid. Trials are rare in car accident cases, but they do happen when the stakes are high or liability is unclear.

Your attorney (or your insurance company's attorney) will advise you on whether settling makes sense or whether you should fight the claim. That decision is ultimately yours, but a good attorney will explain the risks and likely outcomes of each path.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the other driver's attorney contact me directly?

Yes, they can call or write you, but you do not have to speak with them. Once you tell them you have an attorney (or will get one), they must direct all communication to your lawyer. If you do not have an attorney yet, you can straightforward say you will not speak with them without one and hang up.

What if I cannot afford an attorney?

Your insurance company will provide one at no cost if you have liability coverage. If you do not have insurance, many attorneys work on contingency (taking a percentage of any settlement). Contact your local bar association or legal aid office for referrals to low-cost or free consultations.

Do I have to respond to a demand letter?

If you have an attorney, they will handle the response. If you do not and you ignore it, the other driver's lawyer may file a lawsuit, which does have strict court important date you must meet. It is better to respond (through an attorney) or at least acknowledge receipt.

What if I was partially at fault for the accident?

Even if you were partially at fault, you still need an attorney. Your state's rules on comparative fault determine how much you owe. An attorney can argue that the other driver bears more responsibility, which reduces what you have to pay.

Can I settle the case myself without an attorney?

You can, but it is risky. The other driver's attorney is trained to negotiate in their client's favor. Without an attorney, you may agree to pay more than you legally owe or miss defenses that could reduce your liability. At minimum, have an attorney review any settlement before you sign it.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.