Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Find Law Firms That Have Won Large Car Accident Cases

What "Highest Verdicts" Means and Why It Matters

A verdict is a dollar amount a jury awards to a plaintiff (the person suing) after a trial. When you see a law firm advertising "highest verdicts," they are listing the largest jury awards their lawyers have won in past cases. This is different from a settlement, which is money an insurance company or defendant agrees to pay without going to trial.

High verdicts can signal that a firm has experienced trial lawyers and a track record of persuading juries. However, a large verdict in someone else's case does not predict what your case is worth or what a jury would award you. Your case depends on your specific injuries, the strength of evidence, your state's laws, and whether the defendant was clearly at fault.

Verdict amounts also vary dramatically by state and injury type. A $5 million verdict for a spinal cord injury in one state might be typical, while in another state the same injury might settle for less because state law caps damages or juries award smaller amounts. Comparing verdicts across states or injury types can be misleading.

Key Takeaways

  • Law firms publish verdicts to show trial experience, but a high verdict in another case does not determine what your case is worth.
  • Verdict amounts depend heavily on the type of injury, the state where the case was tried, and whether liability was clear—not just on the lawyer's skill.
  • You can research verdicts through your state bar association, legal databases like Justia or Google Scholar, and the firm's own website.
  • A firm with high verdicts may be less willing to settle quickly, which can mean longer wait times and higher legal fees before you see money.
  • The most important factor is whether the firm has handled cases similar to yours, not whether they have the single largest verdict in the state.

Where to Find Verdict Information

Law firms post their largest verdicts on their websites, usually in a section called "Results," "Case Results," or "Verdicts and Settlements." These are real cases, but the firm chooses which ones to highlight—they show their wins, not their losses or smaller payouts.

You can also search for verdicts independently through your state's court records. Most state court systems have online databases where you can search by case name, judge, or year. The verdict amount and judge's decision are public record. Your state bar association website often links to these databases or can direct you to them.

Legal research databases like Google Scholar (scholar.google.com), Justia, and FindLaw let you search published court decisions by keyword, state, and year. These databases include verdicts that were appealed or became precedent—cases important enough to be written up formally. Smaller verdicts and settlements often do not appear in these databases because they are not published decisions.

If you find a verdict that seems similar to your case, you can contact the law firm that won it and ask whether they handle cases like yours. Firms that regularly win high verdicts in a specific injury category (spinal cord injury, traumatic brain injury, wrongful death) usually have the informed to evaluate your case accurately.

Why High Verdicts Do Not may provide Your Outcome

A jury verdict depends on facts specific to that case: how severe the injuries were, how clear the defendant's fault was, what medical evidence existed, and how well each lawyer presented the case. A $3 million verdict for a broken leg in one case does not mean your broken leg is worth $3 million. The other plaintiff might have had permanent nerve damage, lost a high-paying job, or faced a defendant with obvious negligence that made the jury angry.

State law also sets limits on what juries can award. Some states cap non-economic damages (pain and suffering, emotional distress) at a fixed amount, usually $250,000 to $750,000. Other states have no cap. A firm in a no-cap state will naturally show higher verdicts than a firm in a capped state, even if both are equally skilled.

Insurance company limits matter too. If the at-fault driver's policy limit is $100,000, the jury verdict might be $500,000, but you will only collect $100,000 from insurance. The remaining $400,000 becomes a judgment against the driver personally—money you may never collect if they have no assets. Firms sometimes advertise the full verdict amount, not the amount actually paid to the client.

How Verdict Focus Affects Your Case Timeline and Costs

Firms that emphasize high verdicts often take cases to trial rather than settling early. Trials take longer—usually 6 months to 2 years from filing to verdict, compared to 3 to 12 months for a settlement. During that time, you are waiting for money while your medical bills may still be coming in.

Trial also costs more. The firm pays for informed witnesses, court reporters, investigators, and filing fees—sometimes $10,000 to $50,000 or more. These costs come out of your settlement or verdict before you see your share. A firm confident in high verdicts may be willing to spend that money, but it means you carry the risk longer.

Ask any firm you contact whether they prefer to settle or try cases, and what percentage of their cases go to trial. A firm that settles 90% of cases will move faster and cost less than one that tries 50% of cases, even if the trial firm wins larger verdicts on average.

Questions to Ask When Researching Firms

When you contact a firm about their verdicts, ask whether they have handled cases similar to yours—same type of injury, same type of accident, same state. A firm with a $2 million verdict for a truck accident brain injury has relevant experience for your truck accident case, but their informed in that area is what matters, not the verdict amount itself.

Ask what percentage of their cases go to trial and what the average settlement amount is for cases like yours. This gives you a realistic picture of what to expect, not just the best-case scenario. Ask also whether the verdicts listed on their website are the amounts actually paid to clients or the full jury award before insurance limits and costs.

Find out how the firm charges. Most car accident lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of your settlement or verdict (usually 25% to 40%) and you pay nothing upfront. Some firms charge higher percentages if the case goes to trial. Understand the fee structure before you hire.

Red Flags When Evaluating Verdict Claims

Be cautious if a firm lists verdicts from cases they did not try themselves. Some firms acquire other firms or hire lawyers from other firms, then claim credit for old verdicts. The lawyer who actually tried the case may no longer work there. Ask whether the lawyer handling your case personally tried the cases they are advertising.

Watch for verdicts listed without context. A $5 million verdict sounds impressive until you learn it was for a death case with clear liability and the defendant was a large corporation with a $50 million insurance policy. That same firm might have lost or settled for much less in a case with unclear liability or a smaller defendant. Context matters.

If a firm guarantees a certain outcome or promises you will "win big," that is a warning sign. No lawyer can may provide a verdict amount. Honest firms will tell you the range of possible outcomes based on similar cases and the specific facts of yours.

Alternatives to Verdict-Based Reputation

Consider also looking at lawyer ratings on Avvo, Google Reviews, and the Better Business Bureau. These reflect client experience—whether the lawyer communicated clearly, met important date, and treated the client fairly. A lawyer with a 4.5-star rating and moderate verdicts may serve you better than a lawyer with one famous $10 million verdict and poor client reviews.

Check your state bar association's disciplinary records. You can search by lawyer name to see whether they have been disciplined for ethics violations, malpractice, or complaints. A clean record is more reliable than a high verdict.

Ask for references from past clients with injuries similar to yours. A client who settled a case like yours for $150,000 can tell you more about the lawyer's actual process and communication than a press release about a $2 million verdict in a different type of case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a law firm's highest verdict tell me what my case is worth?

No. Your case value depends on your specific injuries, medical evidence, lost wages, state law, and the defendant's insurance limits—not on what the firm won in someone else's case. A firm can use past verdicts to estimate a range for cases like yours, but your case is unique.

Can I find out how much money the client actually received after the firm's fee?

Rarely. Firms advertise the jury verdict or settlement amount, not the net amount paid to the client after legal fees and costs. Ask the firm directly what the client received in a case similar to yours, after subtracting their fee and expenses.

What if the firm with the highest verdicts in my state is too expensive or won't take my case?

Firms that focus on high-value cases often decline smaller cases or cases with unclear liability. Contact firms that regularly handle cases like yours, even if their advertised verdicts are lower. A firm experienced in your injury type will give you a more accurate evaluation than a firm chasing the biggest cases.

Are verdicts from 10 years ago still relevant?

Somewhat, but with caution. Jury awards have changed over time, and state laws may have changed. A $2 million verdict from 2014 might be worth $2.5 million in today's dollars, but it also might reflect a legal standard that no longer applies. Ask the firm about recent verdicts in your state for cases like yours.

What does it mean if a firm lists a verdict but the case was appealed?

It means the verdict was challenged in a higher court. If the appeal was denied, the verdict stands. If the appeal was granted and the case was retried or settled, the final amount may be different from the advertised verdict. Ask the firm what happened after the appeal.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.