What Interrogatories Are and How to Answer Them in a Car Accident Lawsuit
Interrogatories are written questions the other side's lawyer sends you before trial
An interrogatory is a formal written question that the defendant's insurance company or their lawyer sends to you as the plaintiff (the person suing). You must answer under oath, meaning your answers are legally binding and can be used against you in court. Interrogatories are part of the discovery process—the phase where both sides exchange information before the case goes to trial.
In a car accident case, interrogatories typically ask about how the accident happened, your injuries, your medical treatment, your lost wages, and your version of events. The defendant's lawyer uses these answers to understand your claim, find weaknesses in your story, and prepare their defense. You cannot ignore interrogatories or refuse to answer them without a court order; failure to respond can result in sanctions, including dismissal of your case.
The number of interrogatories varies by state and court rules. Federal courts typically allow 25 interrogatories per side unless the parties agree otherwise. State courts have their own limits, which your lawyer or the court's local rules will specify. You usually have 30 days to respond, though this can be extended if both sides agree or if a judge grants more time.
Key Takeaways
- Interrogatories are written questions you must answer under oath within 30 days, and false or evasive answers can be used against you in court.
- The defendant's lawyer will ask about the accident, your injuries, medical care, lost income, and any prior injuries or claims you have made.
- You must answer each interrogatory fully and truthfully, or object in writing with a legal reason—silence or partial answers are not acceptable.
- Your lawyer should review your answers before you submit them to make sure they are accurate and do not contradict other evidence in your case.
- Interrogatory answers become part of the court record and can be read aloud at trial or used to challenge your testimony if your story changes.
Common interrogatory topics in car accident cases
The defendant's lawyer will ask you to describe the accident in detail: where it happened, what time, weather conditions, road conditions, traffic signals, your speed, the other driver's speed, and what you saw just before impact. They will ask whether you were distracted, whether you had consumed alcohol or drugs, and whether you were wearing a seatbelt. These questions establish the facts of the accident and look for any admission that you were partially at fault.
You will be asked about your injuries: what parts of your body were hurt, when the pain started, how severe it was, and whether it has improved. The defendant wants to know whether your injuries are as serious as you claim and whether they could have been caused by something other than the accident. They will ask whether you had any prior injuries to the same body parts, any pre-existing medical conditions, and whether you sought medical care for similar complaints before the accident.
Interrogatories will cover your medical treatment: which doctors and hospitals you visited, what tests or imaging you had, what medications you were prescribed, and whether you followed your doctor's instructions. The defendant will ask whether you missed any appointments, whether you stopped treatment early, and whether you sought treatment for anything unrelated to the accident. They will also ask about your current symptoms and whether you still need medical care.
You will be asked about lost income: your job title, employer, hourly rate or salary, how many days you missed work, and whether your employer paid you while you were out. The defendant will ask whether you have returned to work, whether you have lost any job opportunities, and whether you have had to change jobs or reduce your hours. These answers establish the financial damages you are claiming.
How to prepare and answer interrogatories accurately
Work with your lawyer to gather the documents you will need before answering. Pull together your medical records, bills, pay stubs, tax returns, and any communications with the other driver or their insurance company. Review the police report and any photos or video of the accident scene. Write down your own recollection of the accident while it is still fresh, and compare it to what you told the police officer and what you have told your doctor. Inconsistencies between your interrogatory answers and other evidence will be used to undermine your credibility.
Answer each interrogatory completely and directly. Do not be vague, do not say "I do not recall" unless you genuinely do not remember, and do not leave blanks. If you do not know the answer to a question, say so. If a question asks for multiple pieces of information, answer each part. For example, if asked "Describe all medical treatment you received for your injuries," list every provider, the dates you saw them, and what they treated. A one-sentence answer when more detail exists will look evasive and will give the defendant ammunition to argue you are hiding something.
Be truthful even when the truth hurts your case. If you were speeding, say so. If you did not see the other car before impact, say so. If you have had back pain before, disclose it. Lying on interrogatories is perjury, and if the defendant discovers the lie through other evidence, your entire case can be dismissed and you can face criminal charges. Courts and juries expect accident victims to be honest about the facts, even unfavorable ones.
Have your lawyer review your answers before you sign them. Your lawyer will check for accuracy, make sure you have not contradicted anything else in your file, and flag any answers that might need clarification. Your lawyer may also advise you to object to certain interrogatories if they are overly broad, ask for information protected by attorney-client privilege, or seek information that is not relevant to the case. Objections must be made in writing and must state a legal reason.
When you can object to an interrogatory
You do not have to answer every interrogatory. You can object if the question is unclear or ambiguous, if it asks for information protected by attorney-client privilege (conversations between you and your lawyer), if it asks for trade secrets or confidential business information, or if it is overly broad or burdensome. You can also object if the information requested is not relevant to the case or if answering would require you to produce documents that are not in your possession.
An objection must be made in writing and must state the specific reason. For example: "Interrogatory 12 is objected to as overly broad and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence." straightforward refusing to answer without an objection is not permitted. If you object to part of an interrogatory but can answer the rest, you must answer the part you can. Your lawyer will advise you on which objections are appropriate in your case.
If the defendant disagrees with your objection, they can file a motion to compel, asking the court to order you to answer. The judge will decide whether your objection is valid. If the judge overrules your objection, you must then answer the interrogatory. If you still refuse, you can face sanctions, including fines or dismissal of your case.
What happens after you submit your answers
Once you submit your interrogatory answers, they become part of the court record and are available to the defendant's lawyer. The defendant will use your answers to prepare their case, to depose you (question you in person), and to challenge your testimony at trial if your story changes. If you say in an interrogatory that you had no prior back injuries, but the defendant later discovers medical records showing you did, that contradiction will be presented to the jury and will damage your credibility.
Your interrogatory answers can also be used to impeach you at trial, meaning the defendant's lawyer can read your written answer aloud and ask you to explain why your testimony is different. This is a powerful tool for the defense, so accuracy and consistency are critical. If you realize after submitting your answers that you made a mistake or left something out, tell your lawyer when ready so they can file a supplemental response.
Interrogatory answers are also used during settlement negotiations. If your answers show that your injuries are less severe than you claimed, or that you were partially at fault for the accident, the defendant's insurance company will use that information to argue for a lower settlement. Conversely, if your answers are detailed, consistent, and support your claim, they strengthen your negotiating position.
Common mistakes to avoid when answering interrogatories
Do not answer from memory alone. Use documents—medical records, bills, pay stubs, emails, text messages—to verify your answers. If you say you missed 10 days of work, have your pay stubs or employer records to back that up. If you say you saw a doctor on a certain date, check your medical records. Memory is unreliable, and the defendant will challenge any answer that cannot be verified.
Do not exaggerate your injuries or damages. If your pain has improved, say so. If you have returned to your normal activities, disclose it. Exaggeration is obvious to judges and juries, and once they catch you in one exaggeration, they will doubt everything else you say. Stick to the facts as they are, not as you wish they were.
Do not give narrative answers when the interrogatory asks for specific information. If asked "On what date did you first seek medical treatment?" do not write a paragraph about how much pain you were in. Write the date. If asked "List all medical providers you have seen," provide a list with names, addresses, and dates, not a story about your treatment journey.
Do not ignore interrogatories or miss the important date. If you do not respond within 30 days, the defendant can file a motion to compel or ask the court to impose sanctions. Missing the important date can result in fines, dismissal of your case, or a judgment entered against you by default. If you need more time, ask your lawyer to request an extension in writing before the important date passes.
How interrogatory answers relate to your deposition and trial
Your interrogatory answers are a preview of what you will say under oath at your deposition (a question-and-answer session with the defendant's lawyer) and at trial. The defendant's lawyer will have your written answers in front of them during your deposition and will ask follow-up questions to test your consistency and credibility. If your deposition testimony differs from your interrogatory answers, the defendant will point out the contradiction and argue that you are not reliable.
At trial, if you testify differently than you answered in interrogatories, the defendant's lawyer can show your written answers to the jury and ask you to explain the discrepancy. This is called impeachment, and it is one of the most effective ways to undermine a plaintiff's case. Jurors expect witnesses to tell the same story consistently, and any change in your account—no matter how small—will be used to suggest you are either lying or confused.
For this reason, your interrogatory answers should be as detailed and accurate as possible. Do not hold back information hoping to surprise the defendant at trial. Discovery is designed to prevent surprises; both sides are supposed to know the other's case before trial. If you try to hide something in interrogatories and it comes out later, you will lose credibility and likely lose the case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change my interrogatory answers after I submit them?
Yes, but only if you discover the answer was incorrect or incomplete. You must file a supplemental response in writing and explain why the change is necessary. Do not straightforward change your story because you thought of a better answer. Courts allow supplemental responses only when there is a legitimate reason, such as discovering new documents or realizing you made a factual error. Tell your lawyer when ready if you need to correct an answer.
What if I do not remember the answer to an interrogatory?
Say so. Write "I do not recall" or "I do not have sufficient information to answer this interrogatory." Do not guess or make up an answer. However, use documents to refresh your memory first—your medical records, calendar, emails, or photos may help you remember. If you genuinely cannot recall after checking available sources, it is acceptable to say you do not remember, but this answer should be rare and only used when truthful.
Can my lawyer write my interrogatory answers for me?
Your lawyer can help you prepare and review your answers, but you must sign them under oath. The answers must come from your own knowledge and recollection, not from your lawyer's interpretation of the facts. Your lawyer can advise you on how to phrase an answer clearly and accurately, but the substance must be yours. Signing interrogatory answers that you do not believe are true is perjury.
What if the interrogatories ask about conversations with my lawyer?
You can object on the grounds of attorney-client privilege. Conversations between you and your lawyer about your case are confidential and protected by law. You do not have to disclose them. However, if you have discussed the accident with anyone else—a friend, family member, or doctor—those conversations are not privileged and you must disclose them if asked.
Can interrogatory answers be used against me if I settle the case?
If you settle before trial, interrogatory answers are typically not used in court because there is no trial. However, they may be used during settlement negotiations, and the defendant's lawyer will have them in their file. If the case is later reopened or if you file a different lawsuit, those answers could potentially be discovered and used. For this reason, accuracy is important even if you expect to settle.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.