What Happens When You Depose the Other Driver in a Car Accident Case
What a deposition is and why it matters in your case
A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you, your lawyer, and the other driver's lawyer sit down (usually in a conference room or law office) and the other driver answers questions under oath about the accident. A court reporter records everything word-for-word. The transcript becomes evidence that can be used at trial or to settle the case.
Deposing the defendant driver—the person who hit you or caused the collision—is often one of the most important steps in a car accident case. Their answers lock them into a story. If they say something different later, you can show the jury or judge that they changed their account. A deposition also reveals what evidence they have, what witnesses they plan to call, and whether their story holds up under pressure.
You do not have to depose the other driver. But if your case is serious enough to go to trial, or if settlement talks are stalled, a deposition usually happens. It is part of the discovery process—the phase where both sides exchange information before trial.
Key Takeaways
- A deposition is a recorded, sworn statement where the other driver answers your lawyer's questions about how the accident happened.
- The other driver's lawyer will be present and can object to questions, but the driver must still answer most of them.
- Your lawyer prepares you beforehand if you are also being deposed, and prepares a strategy for questioning the other driver.
- Depositions often reveal inconsistencies in the other driver's story or uncover new facts that strengthen your case.
- You can use the deposition transcript at trial to contradict the other driver if their testimony changes.
Who is present and what role each person plays
The deposition usually includes four people: you (or your representative), your lawyer, the other driver, and the other driver's lawyer. A court reporter sits nearby with a stenotype machine or digital recorder to capture every word. Sometimes a videographer is also present, especially in serious injury cases.
Your lawyer asks the questions. The other driver's lawyer can object to certain questions—for instance, if a question asks for legal opinion or is phrased in a way that is confusing—but objections rarely stop the other driver from having to answer. The other driver's lawyer cannot tell the driver not to answer, and the driver cannot refuse to answer just because they do not want to.
You are allowed to be in the room and watch. Many people find it helpful to see the other driver's face and hear their tone when they answer. You can also pass notes to your lawyer if you spot something wrong or want to flag a detail.
What your lawyer will ask the other driver
Your lawyer will ask detailed questions about the accident itself: where the other driver was coming from, how fast they were going, whether they saw you before impact, what they were doing in the seconds before the crash (texting, adjusting the radio, looking away), and whether they braked or swerved. They will also ask about the other driver's condition—whether they were tired, on medication, or had consumed alcohol or drugs.
Your lawyer will ask about the other driver's vehicle: its condition, whether the brakes worked, whether the lights were on, and whether there were any mechanical problems. They will ask about the road and weather conditions, and whether the other driver had any vision problems or distractions.
Your lawyer will also ask about the other driver's insurance, their driving history, any prior accidents, and whether they have been cited or convicted of traffic violations. They will ask what the other driver told police at the scene, and whether that account matches what they are saying now.
The goal is to lock the other driver into a detailed story, find holes in it, and gather ammunition for trial. If the other driver says they did not see you, your lawyer might ask why—was the sun in their eyes, were they looking at their phone, was your car hidden by another vehicle? Each answer either supports or weakens their defense.
How the other driver's lawyer will protect their client
The other driver's lawyer will be watching closely and will object to questions that are vague, argumentative, or ask for information the other driver cannot know. For example, if your lawyer asks "You were not paying attention, were you?" the other driver's lawyer will object because the question assumes a fact not in evidence and is phrased to push a particular answer.
The other driver's lawyer can also take a break if they believe their client needs time to think or if they want to confer privately. However, they cannot coach the other driver on how to answer or tell them to lie. If the other driver's lawyer tries to do that, it is a serious ethical violation and can be reported to the state bar.
After your lawyer finishes, the other driver's lawyer will ask you questions—if you are being deposed—or may ask follow-up questions of their own client to clarify or repair damage from your lawyer's questioning.
What happens if the other driver changes their story later
If the other driver testifies at trial and says something different from what they said at the deposition, your lawyer can show the jury the deposition transcript and ask the other driver to explain the contradiction. This is called impeachment, and it damages the other driver's credibility. A jury is much less likely to believe someone who tells two different stories.
The deposition transcript can also be read aloud at trial if the other driver does not show up, or if they become unavailable for some reason. In that case, the jury hears the other driver's sworn answers even though the other driver is not in the courtroom.
Depositions also serve a settlement function. If the other driver's answers are weak or hurt their case, their insurance company may be more willing to offer a higher settlement to avoid the risk of trial. Conversely, if the other driver's answers are strong and support their version of events, your side may need to reassess the case value.
How to prepare if you are also being deposed
If you are the plaintiff (the person suing), you will almost certainly be deposed by the other driver's lawyer. Your lawyer will prepare you in advance. They will go over the facts of the accident, review any documents (police report, medical records, photos), and explain what to expect.
Your lawyer will coach you on how to answer: be honest, answer only what is asked, do not volunteer extra information, speak clearly, and do not get angry or defensive even if the other driver's lawyer is aggressive. If you do not understand a question, say so. If you do not know the answer, say "I don't know" rather than guessing.
Your lawyer will also warn you about common traps: questions designed to make you contradict yourself, questions that assume facts you have not agreed to, and questions that try to get you to admit fault or downplay your injuries. Preparation reduces anxiety and helps you perform better under questioning.
When depositions happen and how long they take
Depositions usually happen after the initial pleadings are filed and both sides have exchanged basic information. In a straightforward case, the deposition might happen 6 to 12 months after the accident. In a complex case with multiple parties or serious injuries, it could take longer.
A deposition can last anywhere from one hour to a full day or more, depending on how much detail your lawyer wants to explore and how much the other driver's lawyer objects. Most depositions of a single driver take 2 to 4 hours. Your lawyer will schedule it in advance and coordinate with the other driver's lawyer and the court reporter.
The deposition is not a trial. There is no judge present (unless the case is unusual), and no jury. It is a private discovery tool, though the transcript is part of the case file and can be reviewed by either side later.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the other driver refuse to be deposed?
No. Once a lawsuit is filed, both sides have a legal duty to participate in discovery, which includes depositions. If the other driver refuses, your lawyer can ask the court to compel them to appear. Refusing a court order to appear at a deposition can result in sanctions, including fines or a default judgment against the other driver.
What if the other driver's lawyer objects to a question?
The other driver's lawyer can state an objection on the record, but the other driver usually still has to answer. The objection is noted in the transcript and can be raised later if the case goes to trial. Only a few types of objections—like attorney-client privilege—allow the other driver to refuse to answer.
Can I record the deposition myself?
The court reporter is already recording it, and you will receive a transcript. You should not make your own audio or video recording without permission from both lawyers and the court reporter, as this can violate local rules or state law. Your lawyer will have access to the official transcript and can provide you with a copy.
What if the other driver lies during the deposition?
Lying under oath is perjury, a criminal offense. However, it is up to your lawyer to spot the lie, prove it with evidence, and bring it to the judge's or jury's attention at trial. If you believe the other driver lied, tell your lawyer when ready so they can investigate and gather evidence to contradict the false statement.
Does a deposition mean the case will go to trial?
Not necessarily. Many cases settle after depositions because both sides have a clearer picture of the facts and the strength of each side's case. A deposition is a tool to gather information and evaluate the case, not a may provide that trial will happen.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.