Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Happens When You Depose the Other Driver in Your Car Accident Case

A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where you, your lawyer, and the other driver's lawyer sit down to get the defendant's account of the accident on the record.

During a deposition, the other driver answers questions under oath about how the accident happened, what they saw, what they were doing before impact, and anything else relevant to your claim. A court reporter transcribes every word. The defendant's lawyer is present and can object to questions, but the defendant still has to answer most of them. This is not a trial — there is no judge deciding anything — but what the defendant says in the deposition can be used against them later in court or to pressure them toward settlement.

Depositions happen in the discovery phase, which is the period after you file a lawsuit but before trial. They are one of the main ways both sides gather facts and test each other's story. For you as the plaintiff, a deposition is a chance to lock in the defendant's version of events while they are under oath, so they cannot change their story later without looking dishonest.

Key Takeaways

  • The defendant must answer questions under oath at a deposition, and a court reporter creates a written transcript that can be used in court or settlement talks.
  • Your lawyer prepares the questions and does most of the talking; you attend to observe and support your attorney, but you do not cross-examine the defendant.
  • The defendant's lawyer can object to certain questions, but objections do not stop the defendant from answering — they just create a record that the question was disputed.
  • Depositions usually happen at a lawyer's office and take one to four hours depending on how complex the accident was and how many details need to be covered.
  • What the defendant says in the deposition becomes evidence and can contradict their later testimony, which strengthens your case if inconsistencies emerge.

Why your lawyer deposes the defendant driver

Your attorney deposes the defendant to lock down their account of what happened. People's memories change, stories shift, and details get fuzzy over time. Once the defendant testifies under oath at a deposition, their words are recorded word-for-word. If they later tell a different story — in a settlement negotiation, in a demand letter, or at trial — your lawyer can show the transcript and prove they are being inconsistent. That inconsistency damages their credibility and strengthens your position.

A deposition also reveals what the defendant actually knows and does not know. Maybe they claim they did not see your car, or that the light was green, or that you were speeding. The deposition lets your lawyer ask follow-up questions that expose gaps in their story or catch them in contradictions. If the defendant admits something helpful to your case — "I was looking at my phone," "I did not check my mirrors," "I was going faster than the speed limit" — that admission becomes part of the record and can be used to prove negligence.

Depositions also help both sides understand the strength of the other's case. If the defendant's story is weak or full of holes, the insurance company may push them toward settlement rather than risk a jury trial. If the defendant's account is solid and consistent, your lawyer learns that early and can adjust strategy.

What happens before the deposition

Your lawyer will send the defendant's lawyer a deposition notice, which is a formal request to appear at a specific date, time, and location. The notice must be served at least 14 days in advance (the exact number varies by state, so check your local rules). The defendant is legally required to show up. If they do not, your lawyer can ask the court to compel them to appear, and failure to comply can result in sanctions or even a default judgment in your favor.

Before the deposition, your lawyer will prepare by reviewing the accident report, your medical records, witness statements, and any photos or video. They will also review the defendant's insurance claim, any statements the defendant gave to their insurer, and any prior depositions or discovery documents. Your attorney will then prepare a list of questions designed to establish the defendant's negligence, test their credibility, and lock in their version of events.

Your lawyer will also prepare you for what to expect. You will attend the deposition, but you will not be the one asking questions — your attorney will. You are there to observe, take notes, and support your lawyer. You may be asked to clarify something about your own account, but the focus is on the defendant's testimony.

How the deposition actually works

The deposition takes place in a conference room, usually at one of the lawyers' offices or a neutral location. The defendant, their lawyer, your lawyer, you, and a court reporter are all present. The court reporter swears in the defendant just as would happen in court, and the defendant promises to tell the truth.

Your lawyer then asks questions. The defendant's lawyer can object — for example, if a question is vague, assumes facts not in evidence, or asks for legal conclusions rather than facts. When an objection is made, the court reporter notes it in the transcript, but the defendant still has to answer the question unless the objection is that the answer would violate attorney-client privilege or another legal protection. The defendant cannot straightforward refuse to answer because their lawyer objects.

Questions typically start broad — "Tell me what happened on the day of the accident" — and then narrow down to specific details: speed, visibility, weather, what the defendant was doing before the crash, whether they were distracted, whether they checked mirrors or blind spots, and so on. Your lawyer may show the defendant photos, the accident report, or other documents and ask them to explain what they see or what they remember.

The deposition usually lasts one to four hours, depending on the complexity of the case. When your lawyer is done, the defendant's lawyer may ask questions to clarify or rehabilitate the defendant's testimony. Then the deposition ends, the court reporter prepares a transcript, and both lawyers receive a copy.

What the defendant's lawyer can do during the deposition

The defendant's lawyer is there to protect their client. They can object to questions that are improper, misleading, or seek information protected by privilege. They can also instruct the defendant not to answer if the question violates a legal protection — for example, if it asks about a conversation between the defendant and their lawyer.

The defendant's lawyer cannot tell the defendant to lie or refuse to answer a legitimate question just because the answer is damaging. If the defendant's lawyer tries to block a proper question, your lawyer can ask the court to compel an answer, and the judge will usually side with your lawyer. The defendant's lawyer can also ask clarifying questions after your lawyer is done, which gives the defendant a chance to explain or soften their testimony.

One important thing to know: the defendant's lawyer will likely coach the defendant before the deposition on how to answer — to be truthful but careful, to not volunteer information, to say "I do not remember" if they genuinely do not, and to ask for clarification if a question is unclear. This is legal and standard. It does not mean the defendant is lying; it means they are being prepared to testify carefully.

How deposition testimony is used later

The deposition transcript becomes part of the case file and can be used in several ways. If the case settles, your lawyer may reference the deposition testimony in settlement negotiations to show the defendant's liability or to pressure the insurance company into a higher offer. If the case goes to trial, your lawyer can use the transcript to impeach the defendant's testimony — meaning, if the defendant says something different at trial than they said at the deposition, your lawyer can read the deposition testimony aloud in front of the jury and ask the defendant to explain the contradiction.

Inconsistencies between deposition and trial testimony are powerful evidence of dishonesty. Juries notice when someone's story changes, and it makes them doubt everything else the defendant says. Even if the defendant does not testify at trial (which is their right), your lawyer can read parts of the deposition transcript to the jury as evidence of what happened.

The deposition can also be used in summary judgment motions. If the defendant's deposition testimony clearly shows they were negligent, your lawyer may ask the court to rule in your favor without a trial, based on the undisputed facts in the deposition. Conversely, if the defendant's testimony is strong and consistent, the insurance company may use it to argue that the case should settle or that a jury trial is risky for you.

Common mistakes to avoid during the deposition

If you are present at the deposition, do not interrupt or react visibly to what the defendant says, even if they are lying or blaming you. Your lawyer will handle the questioning. Showing anger or frustration makes you look biased and can undermine your credibility if the jury hears about it later.

Do not coach witnesses or the defendant before the deposition by telling them what to say. Your lawyer can prepare them on how to testify, but not what to testify. If you or your lawyer are caught coaching a witness to lie, it can destroy your case and result in sanctions.

Do not assume the deposition is the end of the case. Many cases settle after depositions, but some go to trial. Your lawyer will use the deposition to build your case, but the real test comes if a jury has to decide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the defendant refuse to answer a question at their deposition?

Not usually. The defendant's lawyer can object to a question, but the defendant still has to answer unless the objection is based on attorney-client privilege or another legal protection. If the defendant refuses to answer a proper question, your lawyer can ask the court to compel an answer, and the judge will almost always order the defendant to respond.

What if the defendant lies at their deposition?

If the defendant lies under oath, that is perjury, which is a crime. More practically, if you can prove the lie with evidence — a photo, a witness, a traffic camera, a medical record — your lawyer will use that contradiction to destroy the defendant's credibility at trial. Juries are very skeptical of witnesses who are caught lying.

Do I have to attend the defendant's deposition?

No, but most plaintiffs do. Being there lets you hear the defendant's story firsthand, take notes, and help your lawyer spot inconsistencies or weak points. It also shows your lawyer that you are invested in the case. Talk to your attorney about whether attending makes sense for your situation.

Can the defendant's deposition be used if the case goes to trial?

Yes. If the defendant testifies at trial and says something different from their deposition, your lawyer can read the deposition transcript to the jury to show the inconsistency. Even if the defendant does not testify at trial, your lawyer can read parts of the deposition to the jury as evidence of what the defendant said under oath.

How long does it take to get the deposition transcript?

The court reporter usually delivers a transcript within one to three weeks, depending on how long the deposition was and how busy the reporter is. Both lawyers receive a copy. You can request a copy from your lawyer, and you have the right to review it and note any corrections if the transcript is inaccurate.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.