Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When You're At Fault in a Car Accident: What Happens Next

What "at fault" means and why it matters

When you're found at fault in a car accident, it means the other driver's insurance company (or a court) has determined you caused the crash. This matters because your own insurance will likely cover the other person's damages — their medical bills, vehicle repairs, lost wages — up to your policy limits. You don't pay out of pocket directly in most cases, but your rates will go up, and there are limits to what your insurance will cover.

Being at fault doesn't automatically mean you're guilty of a crime. It's a civil information made by insurance adjusters or, if you end up in court, by a judge or jury. You can be found at fault even if you weren't speeding or breaking an obvious law — sometimes it comes down to who had the right of way, who was paying attention, or who made the unsafe decision in a split second.

The consequences depend on three things: whether anyone was injured, how much damage occurred, and whether your case stays between insurance companies or goes to court. Understanding each path matters because your choices now affect your costs and your record later.

Key Takeaways

  • Your insurance company will likely pay the other driver's damages if you're found at fault, but your own premiums will increase for three to five years.
  • You should report the accident to your insurance company within 24 to 48 hours, even if you think the other driver was at fault.
  • Do not admit fault at the scene or in writing before talking to your insurance adjuster, because statements can be used against you later.
  • If the damages exceed your policy limits or the other driver sues you directly, you may need a lawyer to protect your personal assets.
  • Your state's laws determine how fault is assigned (some use comparative fault, meaning both drivers share blame) and what you owe.

How insurance handles at-fault accidents

When you report an accident to your insurance company, they assign an adjuster to investigate. The adjuster will contact the other driver, review police reports if one exists, look at photos of the damage, and sometimes interview witnesses. Based on that investigation, they'll decide whether you were at fault, partially at fault, or not at fault.

If they find you at fault, your insurance will pay for the other driver's medical treatment, vehicle repairs, and other losses — but only up to your liability limits. Those are the dollar amounts you chose when you bought your policy, usually written as something like "25/50/25" (meaning $25,000 per person for injury, $50,000 total per accident, and $25,000 for property damage). If the other driver's damages exceed those limits, you may owe the difference yourself.

Your own insurance will not pay for your vehicle repairs or medical bills through the other driver's claim. You'll use your own collision and medical payments coverage for that, if you have it. You'll also pay your deductible out of pocket before your insurance pays anything.

What happens to your insurance rates

An at-fault accident will increase your premiums. How much depends on your state, your insurance company, your driving history, and the severity of the accident. A minor fender-bender might raise your rate 10 to 15 percent; a serious injury accident could double your premium or more. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent a single accident from raising your rate, but you usually have to pay extra for that coverage upfront.

The rate increase typically lasts three to five years from the date of the accident, even if you don't have another incident. After that period, the accident falls off your record and your rates should drop back down. If you have multiple accidents or violations, the increases stack and last longer.

Shopping around after an accident can help. Some insurance companies are more forgiving of accidents than others, and you may find a better rate elsewhere even with the accident on your record. Getting quotes from at least three companies takes an hour and can save hundreds of dollars per year.

When you might need a lawyer

You don't automatically need a lawyer for an at-fault accident. If the other driver's damages are small, your insurance company handles everything, and no one is seriously injured, the insurance process usually works without legal help. Your adjuster will negotiate with the other driver's insurance and reach a settlement.

You should consider talking to a lawyer if any of these are true: the other driver's damages exceed your policy limits; the other driver is suing you directly in court; someone was seriously injured and may claim ongoing medical costs; the other driver is claiming injuries you don't think are real; or your insurance company is denying coverage for some reason. A lawyer can protect you from a judgment that exceeds your insurance limits, which could mean wage garnishment or liens on your home.

Many car accident lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of any settlement or judgment rather than charging you hourly. If you're being sued, you can also ask your insurance company to provide a defense lawyer — most policies include this, and the lawyer's job is to protect you and your insurer.

How fault is determined in your state

Every state has its own rules for assigning fault. Some states use comparative fault, which means both drivers can share blame. If you're found 40 percent at fault and the other driver 60 percent at fault, your insurance pays 60 percent of their damages and theirs pays 40 percent of yours. Other states use contributory fault, which is stricter: if you're found even 1 percent at fault in some states, you can't recover anything from the other driver.

A few states still use no-fault insurance, which means each driver's own insurance pays their own damages regardless of who caused the accident. In those states, you can only sue the other driver if injuries are serious enough to meet a specific threshold.

Your state's rules matter because they determine what you owe and what you can recover. If you're unsure which rule applies where you live, your insurance adjuster can explain it, or you can search your state's Department of Insurance website.

Steps to take right after an at-fault accident

Even if you believe you caused the accident, do not say "I'm sorry" or "It's my fault" at the scene. Those statements can be used against you later, and fault is not always as clear as it seems in the moment. Instead, exchange insurance information with the other driver, take photos of both vehicles and the accident scene, and get contact information from any witnesses.

Call your insurance company within 24 to 48 hours and report the accident. Be factual and brief: describe what happened, where, and when. Don't speculate about what you did wrong or what you think caused the crash. Let the adjuster ask questions. If you're injured, seek medical attention right away and keep records of all treatment.

If police responded, get a copy of the accident report. It usually takes a few days to a week for the report to be filed, and you can request it from the police department or read it online in many jurisdictions. The report often includes the officer's opinion on fault, which carries weight with insurance companies.

What to expect during the claims process

After you report the accident, your adjuster will contact you within a few days to begin the investigation. They'll ask detailed questions about what happened, your speed, road conditions, and whether you saw the other vehicle before impact. Answer honestly and stick to what you actually remember — don't fill in gaps or guess.

The adjuster will also contact the other driver and any witnesses, review the police report, and sometimes hire an engineer to reconstruct the accident if it's serious. This process usually takes two to four weeks for a straightforward case, longer if injuries are involved or if the other driver disputes fault.

Once the investigation is complete, your adjuster will make a fault information and send you a letter explaining it. If you disagree, you can appeal within your insurance company, though this rarely changes the outcome. If you believe the information is wrong, a lawyer can help you challenge it or prepare for court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I lose my license if I'm found at fault in an accident?

Being at fault in a civil accident doesn't automatically cost you your license. You lose your license for criminal violations like DUI, reckless driving, or accumulating too many points on your driving record. An at-fault accident adds points in most states, but one accident rarely reaches the threshold for suspension unless you already have violations on your record.

What if the other driver doesn't have insurance?

If you're at fault and the other driver is uninsured, your liability coverage still pays their damages — that's what liability insurance is for. If you're not at fault, your uninsured motorist coverage (if you have it) pays for your own damages. Either way, the other driver's lack of insurance doesn't change your responsibility or your rates.

Does an at-fault accident show up on my driving record?

Yes, if a police report was filed, the accident will appear on your driving record for three to seven years depending on your state. Insurance companies can see it, and it affects your rates. The accident may also appear on background checks for employment or housing, though employers and landlords care more about violations than accidents.

Can I sue the other driver if I'm at fault?

In most states, no. If you're found at fault, you caused the accident, so the other driver has no claim against you. In comparative fault states, you could potentially recover a portion of your damages if the other driver was also partly at fault, but you'd need a lawyer to pursue that and it's rarely worth the cost.

What happens if my insurance denies coverage?

Insurance companies sometimes deny coverage if they believe you violated your policy — for example, if you were driving someone else's car without permission, or if you were committing a crime when the accident happened. If your claim is denied, you have the right to appeal within your insurance company and can hire a lawyer to challenge the denial in court.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.