How to File a Gap Insurance Claim After a Total Loss
File a claim with your gap insurance company, not your auto insurer
Gap insurance is sold by a separate company from your auto insurer, even though you bought it at the same time. When your car is totaled, you first file a claim with your auto insurance company for the actual cash value of the vehicle. Once that claim settles, you then file a separate claim with your gap insurance provider to cover the difference between what the insurer paid and what you still owe on the loan or lease.
The timing matters: gap insurance only pays out after your auto insurance has already paid. You cannot file a gap claim first or simultaneously and expect it to process. Your auto insurer's settlement letter becomes the document that triggers your gap claim.
Key Takeaways
- Gap insurance claims are filed with the gap insurance company, which is separate from your auto insurer, using your auto insurance settlement letter as proof.
- You must wait for your auto insurance claim to settle before filing a gap claim, because gap insurance only covers the remaining difference.
- Gather your loan or lease documents, the auto insurance settlement letter, and your gap insurance policy documents before contacting the gap company.
- Most gap insurance companies process claims within two to four weeks once they receive all required documents.
- If your auto insurer paid more than you owe, you will not have a gap claim — gap insurance only pays when there is a shortfall.
Locate your gap insurance policy and company contact information
Your gap insurance policy should have been issued when you bought the coverage, either at the dealership or through your auto insurer. Look for a separate policy document or a rider attached to your auto insurance paperwork. The document will have the gap insurance company's name, your policy number, and a phone number or claims email.
If you cannot find the original paperwork, contact the dealership where you bought the car or call your auto insurance company and ask them to identify which company sold the gap coverage. Many dealerships keep copies of gap policies in their records. Your loan or lease company may also have a copy on file.
Gather the documents the gap company will need
Gap insurance companies require specific paperwork before they will process a claim. Start by collecting your auto insurance settlement letter, which shows the actual cash value the insurer determined for your vehicle. You will also need your original loan or lease agreement, your gap insurance policy document, and proof of the accident or total loss (usually a police report or the auto insurer's damage assessment).
Have your vehicle identification number (VIN) and the current loan or lease payoff amount ready. You can get the payoff amount by calling your lender or logging into your loan servicer's online account. For leases, contact the leasing company directly. The gap company will compare the auto insurance payout against this payoff amount to determine whether you are owed anything.
Contact the gap insurance company and file your claim
Call the phone number on your gap insurance policy or visit the company's website to find their claims submission process. Some companies accept claims by phone, others require you to submit documents online through a claims portal, and some use email. Ask the claims representative which method is fastest for your situation.
When you call or submit your claim, have all your documents ready. Provide your policy number, VIN, the date of the total loss, and your auto insurance settlement amount. The gap company will ask you to send copies of the settlement letter, your loan or lease documents, and the gap policy itself. Do not send originals — send copies only, and keep copies for your records.
What happens after you submit your claim
The gap insurance company will verify the information you provided against your auto insurance settlement and your loan or lease payoff amount. This verification process typically takes two to four weeks. During this time, the company may contact your auto insurer or lender directly to confirm the numbers.
Once the company confirms that you owe more than the auto insurer paid, they will calculate the gap amount and issue payment. Most companies send payment directly to your lender or leasing company to pay down the remaining loan balance. Some will send payment to you instead — ask which method applies to your policy when you file.
What to do if the gap company denies your claim
A gap claim can be denied if the auto insurance payout was equal to or greater than what you owed, meaning there was no gap to cover. This is not a denial of coverage — it straightforward means the gap did not exist in your situation. You have no further claim to file.
A claim can also be denied if you did not have gap coverage at the time of the loss, if your policy had lapsed, or if the loss was excluded under your policy terms (for example, some policies exclude losses from racing or commercial use). Review your denial letter carefully to understand the reason. If you believe the denial is incorrect, contact the gap company's appeals department and provide any additional documentation that supports your case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I file a gap claim before my auto insurance claim is settled?
No. Gap insurance companies will not process a claim without a settlement letter from your auto insurer showing the actual cash value paid. You must wait for that settlement first, then file the gap claim using that letter as proof.
What if my auto insurer and I disagree about the car's value?
If you dispute the auto insurer's valuation, resolve that disagreement first — through appraisal, mediation, or your state's insurance commissioner if needed. Once you have a final settlement amount from the auto insurer, use that number to file your gap claim, even if you believe it is too low.
How long does it take to get paid after I file a gap claim?
Most gap insurance companies process claims within two to four weeks of receiving all required documents. Payment timing depends on whether the company pays your lender directly or pays you. Ask the claims representative for an estimated timeline when you file.
Do I need a lawyer to file a gap insurance claim?
No. Gap claims are straightforward paperwork — you submit documents, the company verifies them, and they pay or deny based on the numbers. A lawyer is not needed unless the gap company wrongfully denies a valid claim and you decide to pursue a dispute.
What if I still owe money after the gap insurance pays?
Gap insurance covers only the difference between the auto insurance payout and what you owed at the time of the loss. If you owe more than that difference, you are responsible for the remaining balance. This can happen if you had a very large loan, a short loan term, or if the vehicle depreciated faster than expected.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.