Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When Filing an Auto Insurance Claim Costs You More Than It Saves

Filing a claim can raise your rates even when the accident wasn't your fault

You have the right to file a claim after an accident, but filing doesn't always work in your favor. Insurance companies track claims history, and even one claim can increase your premium at renewal—sometimes by 10 to 40 percent, depending on your insurer and state. If the damage is minor and you can pay for repairs yourself, not filing often saves you money over the next three to five years, because you avoid the rate increase altogether.

The math is straightforward: add up what you'd pay in higher premiums over time, then compare that to the repair cost. If the repair bill is less than the premium increase you'd face, you're better off paying out of pocket. This calculation changes based on your deductible, your current rate, and how much your insurer typically raises rates after a claim.

Key Takeaways

  • A single claim can raise your premium by 10 to 40 percent at renewal, even if you were not at fault, so compare the repair cost to three years of increased premiums before filing.
  • Damage under your deductible amount means you pay the full repair cost anyway, so filing gains you nothing except a rate increase.
  • At-fault accidents stay on your record for three to five years in most states, while not-at-fault claims usually have less impact on your rate.
  • Comprehensive claims (theft, weather, vandalism) typically raise rates less than collision claims, so the math may favor filing for those losses.
  • If you have accident forgiveness or a claim-free discount, check your policy details before deciding, because some insurers waive the first rate increase.

When the repair cost is below your deductible

Your deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before insurance covers anything. If the repair estimate is less than your deductible, filing a claim means you pay the full bill anyway—and you still get a rate increase. There is no financial benefit to filing.

For example, if your deductible is $1,000 and the damage is $800, you pay $800 whether you file or not. But if you file, your insurer records the claim, and your rate goes up at renewal. The only reason to file in this situation is if you want the claim documented for your records, though that rarely matters in practice.

Small damage that won't trigger a rate increase

Some insurers offer accident forgiveness or a claim-free discount that protects you from a rate increase after your first accident. If your policy includes this protection, filing a claim may not raise your rate—check your policy documents or call your agent to confirm.

Comprehensive claims (damage from theft, weather, vandalism, or hitting an animal) also tend to raise rates less than collision claims, because they don't suggest you're a risky driver. If your damage is from a weather event or theft and your repair cost is modest, the rate increase may be small enough that filing still makes financial sense. Compare the repair cost to what you expect your rate to rise, and factor in how long you plan to keep the policy.

At-fault accidents and your driving record

An at-fault accident—one where you caused the collision—stays on your record for three to five years in most states and raises your rate more than a not-at-fault claim. If you caused the accident and the damage is minor, the rate increase will be steeper and last longer, making it even more likely that paying out of pocket saves money overall.

Not-at-fault claims (where the other driver was at fault) have less impact on your rate in many states, though some insurers still raise rates slightly. If you were hit by another car and the damage is small, a not-at-fault claim may not raise your rate much, or at all. Call your insurer and ask how a not-at-fault claim would affect your specific premium before you decide.

When you plan to switch insurers soon

If you're planning to change insurance companies within the next few months, filing a claim now means the new insurer will see it on your record and may charge you a higher rate from day one. Most insurers check your claims history for the past three to five years, so a recent claim follows you to your next policy.

If you're unhappy with your current insurer and shopping around anyway, paying for minor damage yourself and then switching avoids the rate penalty. The claim won't appear on your new policy if it hasn't been filed yet. This strategy works only if the repair cost is something you can absorb and the damage doesn't affect the car's safety or resale value.

How to calculate whether filing makes sense

Gather three pieces of information: the repair estimate, your current annual premium, and your deductible. Then call your insurer and ask: "If I file a claim for this damage, how much will my rate increase at renewal?" Some insurers won't give an exact number, but they can tell you whether the increase will be 10 percent, 25 percent, or higher.

Multiply your annual premium by the expected percentage increase, then multiply that by three (the typical length of a rate increase). Add your deductible to that total. If the sum is higher than the repair estimate, you save money by not filing. If the repair cost is higher, filing is the better choice financially.

For example: your premium is $1,200 per year, your deductible is $500, and the repair estimate is $1,200. Your insurer says a claim will raise your rate by 20 percent. The math: ($1,200 × 0.20) × 3 years = $720 in extra premiums, plus your $500 deductible = $1,220 total cost to file. The repair is $1,200, so filing costs you about the same either way—but if the rate increase lasts longer than three years or is higher than 20 percent, paying out of pocket wins.

What happens if you don't file but the other driver does

If another driver caused the accident and files a claim against your policy, your insurer will contact you. You don't have to file your own claim to defend yourself—your insurer handles the investigation and pays the other driver's claim if they determine you were at fault. Your rate may still increase if you're found liable, even though you didn't file.

The difference is that if you file your own claim, you're initiating the process and paying your deductible. If the other driver files against you, your insurer investigates without you paying anything upfront. If they determine the other driver was at fault, their insurer pays instead. In situations where fault is unclear, not filing your own claim can sometimes work in your favor, because your insurer has no incentive to rush to judgment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my rate go up if I file a not-at-fault claim?

Not-at-fault claims usually raise your rate less than at-fault claims, and some insurers don't raise rates at all for a single not-at-fault claim. Call your insurer and ask how a not-at-fault claim would affect your specific premium. If the increase is small and the repair cost is high, filing makes sense.

How long does a claim stay on my record?

Most insurers look back three to five years when calculating your rate. An at-fault accident typically raises your rate for three to five years, while a not-at-fault claim may fall off sooner or have less impact. Your insurer can tell you exactly how long a claim will affect your rate.

What if I file a claim and then change my mind?

Once you file a claim, you cannot undo it—the claim stays on your record. You can withdraw the claim before the insurer pays, but the claim itself is still documented. If you're unsure, ask your insurer what happens if you withdraw before payment, and whether the claim will still affect your rate.

Does filing a claim affect my ability to get insurance elsewhere?

Yes. When you shop for a new policy, insurers check your claims history. A recent claim may result in a higher quote or a denial from some insurers. If you're planning to switch companies, paying out of pocket for minor damage avoids this penalty.

Can I file a claim if I'm not sure who was at fault?

You can file a claim, and your insurer will investigate to determine fault. If they find you were at fault, your rate will increase. If they find the other driver was at fault, your rate may not increase, or the increase will be smaller. Ask your insurer how they handle unclear fault situations before you decide to file.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.