What an Insurance Adjuster Does and Why They Matter to Your Claim
An insurance adjuster investigates your claim, determines what happened, and decides how much the insurance company will pay
When you file a claim, the insurance company assigns an adjuster to your case. That adjuster is the person who will contact you, inspect any damage, review your policy, and write a report recommending a payment amount. The adjuster works for the insurance company, not for you — their job is to verify that your claim is legitimate and that the amount you're requesting falls within what your policy covers.
Most adjusters are honest professionals following a standard process. But because they work for the insurer and not for you, there's a built-in conflict: the company pays them to settle claims fairly, but also to pay as little as possible. Understanding what adjusters do, what they're looking for, and what you should do when they contact you will help you protect your interests.
Key Takeaways
- An adjuster's job is to investigate your claim, inspect damage, and recommend a payment amount — they do not make the final decision on whether to pay.
- Adjusters work for the insurance company, so they have a financial incentive to minimize what they pay, even if they follow the rules correctly.
- You can hire your own adjuster (called a public adjuster) to represent your interests, though they take a percentage of any increase they win.
- You do not have to accept the adjuster's first offer, and you can dispute their findings by providing your own evidence or hiring an independent informed.
- Document everything the adjuster does — take notes on conversations, keep copies of all documents they request, and photograph any damage before they arrive.
The adjuster's investigation process
When an adjuster is assigned to your claim, they will contact you to schedule an inspection. For property damage (home, auto, or business), this usually means a visit to see the damage in person. For other types of claims — medical, liability, or theft — the investigation may be mostly paperwork and phone calls.
During an inspection, the adjuster will photograph or video the damage, measure affected areas, and take notes on the condition of the property. They may ask you detailed questions about what happened, when it happened, and what you've already done to prevent further damage. They will also review your policy to confirm that the type of damage you're claiming is actually covered.
After the inspection, the adjuster writes a report. This report includes their description of the damage, their estimate of repair costs, and their recommendation on whether to pay and how much. The report goes to the insurance company's claims department, which then makes the official decision on your claim.
Why the adjuster's role creates a conflict of interest
The insurance company employs the adjuster and pays their salary. While adjusters are required by law to investigate claims honestly and in good faith, the company's financial incentive is to pay less, not more. This doesn't mean adjusters are corrupt — most follow their legal obligations — but it does mean they have a reason to interpret ambiguous situations in the company's favor.
For example, an adjuster might argue that damage was caused by wear and tear (not covered) rather than a sudden event (covered), or that the cost to repair is lower than it actually is. They might also interpret your policy's language strictly, denying coverage for something you thought was included. None of this is necessarily dishonest, but it reflects whose side they're on.
This is why you should never assume the adjuster's first offer is fair or final. It's an opening position, not a settlement.
What to do when the adjuster contacts you
When the adjuster calls or visits, be polite but careful. You are required to cooperate with the investigation — refusing to do so can give the insurance company grounds to deny your claim. But cooperating doesn't mean you have to accept their conclusions.
Before the inspection, document the damage yourself. Take photographs and video from multiple angles, in good lighting, and with timestamps if possible. Write down what happened, when it happened, and any witnesses. Keep receipts for any emergency repairs you've made to prevent further damage (like boarding up a broken window). The insurance company is required to reimburse you for reasonable emergency repairs.
During the inspection, you can be present and take your own notes. You can ask the adjuster questions about what they're looking at and why. You can also tell them about damage they might have missed. After the inspection, ask the adjuster when you can expect their report and how you'll be notified of the decision.
Do not sign anything the adjuster asks you to sign unless you understand exactly what it says. Some adjusters ask claimants to sign a form authorizing the company to get medical records or other documents. That's usually fine. But if they ask you to sign something that releases the company from liability or limits your rights, do not sign it without reading it carefully or having a lawyer review it first.
Disputing the adjuster's findings
If the adjuster's report underestimates the damage or denies coverage you believe you're may have access to to, you have options. You can request a copy of the adjuster's report and review it carefully. If you disagree with their damage estimate, you can get your own estimate from a contractor and submit it to the insurance company. If you disagree with their interpretation of your policy, you can point to the specific language in your policy that you believe supports your claim.
Many insurance policies include an appraisal process for disputes over the amount of damage. If you and the adjuster disagree on repair costs, either of you can request an appraisal. In an appraisal, you each choose an appraiser, those two appraisers choose a third, and the three of them decide the value. The cost is usually split between you and the insurance company. An appraisal is faster and cheaper than going to court, but it only resolves disputes about the amount of damage, not about whether something is covered.
If the dispute is about coverage — whether your policy actually covers what happened — you may need to file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner or consult a lawyer.
When to hire a public adjuster
A public adjuster is an adjuster who works for you, not the insurance company. They investigate the claim on your behalf, prepare their own damage estimate, and negotiate with the insurance company's adjuster. Public adjusters are licensed professionals who specialize in getting higher settlements for claimants.
The downside is cost: public adjusters typically take 5 to 10 percent of any increase they win for you. So if the insurance company's adjuster recommends $50,000 and the public adjuster negotiates it up to $70,000, the public adjuster takes $2,000 to $3,000 of that $20,000 increase. This can be worth it for large, complex claims — especially those involving significant property damage or disputes over coverage — but may not make sense for small claims.
You can hire a public adjuster at any point in the process, even after the insurance company has already made an offer. Some people hire one only if they disagree with the initial settlement. Others hire one from the start if the claim is large or complicated.
The difference between an adjuster and other roles
An adjuster is not the same as a claims representative, though the terms are sometimes used interchangeably. A claims representative typically handles the paperwork and communication side of your claim, while an adjuster does the investigation. In practice, one person may do both jobs, especially for smaller claims.
An adjuster is also not the same as a lawyer. If your dispute with the insurance company involves a question of law — whether your policy actually covers something, or whether the company acted in bad faith — you may need a lawyer, not an adjuster. Some lawyers specialize in insurance disputes and can review your claim, negotiate with the company, or file a lawsuit if necessary.
An independent adjuster is an adjuster hired by the insurance company on a case-by-case basis, rather than a full-time employee. Independent adjusters work the same way as staff adjusters — they investigate the claim and report to the insurance company — but they may have more flexibility in their schedule and may handle claims in multiple states.
Red flags in the adjuster's process
Most adjusters follow the rules, but watch for these warning signs that something may be wrong. If an adjuster refuses to let you be present during the inspection, that's unusual and worth questioning. If they pressure you to accept their offer quickly or sign documents without giving you time to review them, that's a red flag. If they seem to be ignoring damage you point out or dismissing your concerns without explanation, document that and consider getting a second opinion.
If the adjuster's estimate seems significantly lower than estimates you've gotten from contractors, that's worth investigating. Get multiple contractor estimates and compare them to the adjuster's. If there's a large gap, ask the adjuster to explain their reasoning. If you're not satisfied with the explanation, you can request an appraisal or hire a public adjuster.
If the insurance company denies your claim entirely and you believe the denial is wrong, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner. The commissioner's office can investigate whether the company followed the law and may pressure them to reconsider.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse to let the adjuster inspect my property?
No. Your insurance policy requires you to cooperate with the investigation, and refusing an inspection can give the company grounds to deny your claim. However, you can be present during the inspection, ask questions, and take your own photographs and notes.
What if the adjuster's estimate is much lower than what contractors are quoting?
Get written estimates from at least two contractors and submit them to the insurance company. If there's still a significant gap, you can request an appraisal under your policy. An appraisal is a faster, cheaper alternative to court for disputes over the amount of damage.
Do I have to accept the adjuster's first offer?
No. The adjuster's recommendation is a starting point, not a final settlement. You can dispute their findings, provide your own evidence, or hire a public adjuster to negotiate on your behalf.
What should I do if I think the adjuster is being unfair?
Document everything — keep notes of all conversations, save copies of all documents, and photograph any damage. Request a copy of the adjuster's report and review it carefully. If you disagree with their conclusions, submit your own evidence or hire a public adjuster or lawyer to help you dispute the decision.
Is the adjuster required to explain their reasoning?
The adjuster's report should explain how they calculated the damage estimate and whether they found coverage under your policy. If the report is unclear or doesn't address something you think is important, you can ask the adjuster or the claims department for clarification.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.